Display:
I distance myself from the spirit and content of the above diary. In my opinion it doesn't represent a valid contribution to the public discourse in France, Germany and Belgium. Quite on the contrary, it falls way, way back behind the recommendations of the joint Franco/German historic school book commission and what is the shared view between our countries. I feel particularly offended by the cheap poetry and its recurrent reference to "God" and "eagles". And I can -obviously- not relate to "torches" that must be past on to quarrel with the "foe". (Quarrel? - not mass slaughter of human beings?) I also reject the notion that a dead soldiers' place should be 'marked' by 'rows and rows'. It is actually a quite disgusting display of yet another triumph of militarism, because it dehumanises the individual citizen and puts him in a rigidly choreographed mass of subjects. And last but not least I don't 'adore God and soldiers' I don't even 'thank them for their service'. The troops were drafted, they didn't go to war on their own well informed will. They had no choice and were not allowed to make a decision. And it is not true that the soldiers were loved by the Flemish people.

I find this line totally revolting:

"Up, up the long, delirious burning blue
I've topped the windswept heights with easy grace
Where never lark, or even eagle flew."

Here is my poetic answer to that:

http://www.archivio-zeta.org/immagini/persiani/vela.JPG

It shows you the 'eagle's wing', the triumphant arrow on top of the Futa pass mountain, it is the monument which you reach after a tormentuous climb following the, at first first, long winding, and then, ever more narrowly spiralling steep path up the hill. The visitor can only venture short and very restricted glimpses on the adjacent war graves, the open view is constantly hindered and blocked by trees, rocks and a stone wall which runs alongside the path. This never allows him/her to see the whole cemitery. The visitor will also be shielded from the wind during his two km long climb and begin to sweat and suffer from the heat of the 'blue skies'. All the while he will see the 'eagle's wing' high above him in the distance.

It is only when he will reach the plateau, right on the top of the mountain, that he will be stepping out of the wind sheltering 'trench'. It is in this instant that he will be hit hard by gusts of wind and look up to the monument right above him and discover the the 'eagles wing' which he saw from the distance was never capable to 'fly'. It is broken. It doesn't rise up into the sky. The broken edge points down towards the graves. Which can only from here, from under the broken wing, be seen for the first time in their entirety. The 'delirious' spiral never 'topped the windswept heights with easy grace'. It was an illusion. There was never an 'eagle's wing. It has been always a broken arrow.

http://www.heinrich-haus.de/Futaweb/skizzefriedhof.jpg

"The USA appears destined by fate to plague America with misery in the name of liberty." Simon Bolivar, Caracas, 1819

by Ritter on Fri Nov 11th, 2005 at 06:18:09 PM EST
... that was not my intention at all.

I read the poems above figuratively, and the reference to God as an overarching spirt of one's choosing. And the final poem I view as transcendence to something greater.

The importance of the marking the day is to take a moment to reflect, not to celebrate militarism in any way.

Again, sorry to offend.

by olivia on Fri Nov 11th, 2005 at 06:32:50 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Thanks for the links, Ritter, and for giving another point of view.  Also to Migeru's above.

In general, I don't like anything that glorifies or, worse, celebrates war.  That said, I consider honoring the dead to be somewhat of a different matter.  It is the rulers who declare wars and the people who fight them.  I don't have a problem remembering people who fought and gave their lives, even if their rulers weren't doing the right thing.

Maybe this makes no difference, I don't know, but my heart goes out to anyone who was caught up in these tragic events.  And I do think it's important to remember.  I think it's important to reflect on the human costs of political decisions and try to figure out how the hell to stop the powerful from doing this.

Maybe we can eventually make language a complete impediment to understanding. -Hobbes

by Izzy (izzy at eurotrib dot com) on Fri Nov 11th, 2005 at 06:35:10 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password
Occasional Series