Display:
All these objections to bikes seem rather feeble to me as one who has been bike-based for years.  I know several families with children (ranging from toddlers to teenagers) who are carfree, so even that is not an insuperable problem.

Plenty of utility trailers, specialised bikes, and luggage for conventional bikes are available for hauling Stuff.  I haul a fair amount of stuff and almost never need to borrow a car.  And for the price of a car, sheesh, you could own a fleet of bikes and trailers.

Perceptions of cycling risk are imho grossly exaggerated.  40,000 people die yearly in the US inside cars, only about 700-800 while cycling -- despite the "terribly dangerous" nature of cycling.  I myself have cycled pretty regularly -- on surface streets, not sidepaths -- for over 30 years and my only crashes have been at very low speed, and resulted in only a few scrapes and bruises.  However the perception that cycling is dangerous is very persistent (it is the most common excuse I hear among Americans for not cycling or walking:  "it's too dangerous" or "I won't do it until the government builds me a bike road network") and this discourages millions of people from cycling -- hence they drive a lot more, increasing the moderate but genuine danger to others who cycle or walk.

An interesting feature of cycling safety is that the only really consistent correlation with cyclist safety is number of cyclists.  Everything else -- road engineering, prosthetic interventions like helmets and pads -- everything except, possibly, night lighting (though even this may be confounded by Dutch results) -- has only minor, or contested effects.  But afaik in all longitudinal studies there is a strong correlation between the number of cyclists on the roads and the risk per cyclist.  The more common cycling is in a country, the safer each cyclist is.

Which means, of course, that the most effective thing any of us can do to make cycling safer is to go out there and do it :-)

On a related note, the BMJ once concluded that, weighing up the health benefits of regular exercise via cycling vs the risk factors of road cycling, the average road cyclist was 20 times more likely to extend his or her lifetime than to curtail it by cycling regularly.  The leading causes of death in the US last time I looked were smoking and cardiovascular unfitness.  Not too many cyclists smoke (you need your lung power) and most are, even if not athletic (I'm not), fairly robust in the cardio department.

I also know several people with back, hip, shoulder problems who are not able to walk or run but can cycle at low speed in comfort, and use their bikes as a "mobility aid".  So the notion that older folks are automatically disqualified from cycling also seems highly questionable to me.  I'm pushing 50 myself and can ride 30 miles for pleasure without collapsing (and believe me I am morphologically closer to Yogi Bear than Lance Armstrong).

A friend of mine has a sig that I think bears on the discussion:  It is easier to act your way in to a new way of thinking, than to think your way into a new way of acting.  If we start by thinking that riding a bike is dangerous and difficult then the action (actually doing it) will never happen;  but if we start by actually riding the bike, the odds are that whole new ways of travelling and thinking may result.  At least that is what happened for me.  I now regard trips in a car or plane as brief experiences of inhumane incarceration, which leave me longing to get back on my bike and enjoy real freedom.  But as they say, "Your mileage may vary."

The difference between theory and practise in practise ...

by DeAnander (de_at_daclarke_dot_org) on Sat Jul 9th, 2005 at 11:35:59 PM EST
Indeed. And the Viennese poster below spoke of his Danish acquitances who had bike accidents, yet those didn't quit biking.

Also, for Americans, it's not just the perceptions about security - I believe the width of US streets should enable biking on roads even in downtown areas with high traffic without problems.

*Lunatic*, n.
One whose delusions are out of fashion.

by DoDo on Sun Jul 10th, 2005 at 04:19:20 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password
Recommended Diaries
Occasional Series