In general the critique should include the disastrous decision to convert the E. German mark on a 1-1 basis and to raise wages to an almost W. German level. If you take an already struggling enterprise and choose to massively hike its costs overnight, it will die. That's what happened on a large scale in E. Germany. Not that it would have been easy to do anything else - people might have voted with their feet, but still that's a major reason why in many ways the E. German economy has done so much worse than those of the new member states.