Display:
BBC - Whaling nations set for majority

Pro-whaling nations look set to command a majority of the votes when the International Whaling Commission (IWC) annual meeting begins on Friday. Several countries which appear likely to vote with the pro-whaling bloc have joined the body in recent weeks. UK marine affairs minister Ben Bradshaw said he is "very concerned".

A pro-whaling majority could lead to the scrapping of conservation and welfare programmes, though not a return to full-scale commercial whaling.

That would need three-quarters of the delegates to vote in favour, which is extremely unlikely.

But a simple majority would be enough to end IWC work on issues which Japan believes to be outside its remit, such as welfare and killing methods, whale-watching and anything concerning small cetaceans such as dolphins.



by Alex in Toulouse on Mon Jun 12th, 2006 at 02:58:40 AM EST
[ Parent ]
At some point I'll need to find a way to explain convincingly that eating cows is not any different than eating dogs, and that eating whales is not any different than eating apes. Cultural trends fuzz out the proximity between these species, but where am I wrong in saying this above? (ie. we know that (some) Japanese consider whales to be fish, that (some) Koreans consider dogs to be protein, that (some) Frenchies consider rabbits to be a deliquacy, that (some) Americans will keep pet rabbits but eat more beef than anyone else in the world, and that (some) in all these nations think the pig starring in Babe will look better on a barbecue.)

Eating fish or lizards on the other hand, is a lot harder to amalgamate to eating mammals ... ie. it's easier to go "awwww ain't that cute" when seeing a calf breast-feeding but harder to say the same thing when seeing a lizard dump eggs in the sand somewhere and walk away. Eating birds ... I don't know, it kind of sucks too ... they go tweep tweep, are (mainly) monogamous, care for their little lones ... so that should make them prone to "awwww ain't that cute" syndrome too.

I just don't think I get the whole "I'll eat this mammal but not this one, which is man's friend (or man's cousin)" thing.

by Alex in Toulouse on Mon Jun 12th, 2006 at 05:57:18 AM EST
[ Parent ]
The issue with whaling, whether Sirocco likes it or not, is a long history of various nations abusing the hunting of the small common whales to hunt the large rare ones who are close to extinction.

In my philosophical view, if you can farm blue whales you are welcome to eat them, but I think there is a decent argument for opposing them becoming extinct just because you like their flavour.

by Metatone (metatone [a|t] gmail (dot) com) on Mon Jun 12th, 2006 at 06:09:59 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password
Occasional Series