While some French high-speed lines have been great successes, many have been over-budget, under-used white elephants.
Which ones? The SNCF has long been blamed for refusing to build more high speed lines because they would not hit minimum return targets. That attitude is still prevalent with RFF (the entity that now manages the network independently of the railways), and this is what delayed the Eastern TGV for so long.
Maybe the most problematic one has been the Eurostar, but surely that has causes not completely related to France... (cf Mitterrand's great jibe about the ability to leisurely enjoy the beautiful English countryside...) In the long run, we're all dead. John Maynard Keynes
But, a line fitting the description up to the white elephant is the TGV Mediterranée: expensive, and initial traffic somewhat below predictions. However, it should be noted that the envisaged air/rail market share was reached -- in other words, the lower numbers were recession-related and hit the entire market, not just rail.
One thing I don't have data about is the financial performance of the Atlantique line. *Lunatic*, n. One whose delusions are out of fashion.
Mitterrand's great jibe about the ability to leisurely enjoy the beautiful English countryside...
Or well, considering the externalities of all non-rail transportation, all railroads are good railroads. Peak oil is not an energy crisis. It is a liquid fuel crisis.
The problem is that when it comes to doing the VERY difficult things, government financial support combined with a strictly enforced meritocratic bureaucracy produces far superior results. A well organized group of smart folks can usually outperform the greatest individual genius.
So here we have it. The French have demonstrated that when it comes to running very fast trains, strategy 2 is clearly the winner. But our poor Brit friend has had his most deeply held, most theologically sacred beliefs challenged but rather than admit the obvious, he actually starts an argument with a TRAIN.
I am so deeply sorry I am a monolingual Midwestern 'Merikun because their are time when I believe the simple act of thinking in English is a prime cause of mental retardation or as Veblen put it more gently, "trained incapacity." "Remember the I35W bridge--who needs terrorists when there are Republicans"
because their are time when
that's
because there are times when
sheesh "Remember the I35W bridge--who needs terrorists when there are Republicans"