Display:

I do not believe that you or I have the right to take a life unless that life is directly threatening your life.

That makes sense, and is indeed consistent. Where we disagree, and I guess this is not something that can easily be argued one way or another, is that a fetus is a life. If you don't mind me asking some further questions to react further to your position, could you tell me:

  • at what point do you think a fetus becomes a life? From intercourse?From the date pregnancy is detected? From a specific date that can by physiologically identified?

  • as you see a moral responsibility in bringing all fetuses to the world, do you also see an associated moral responsibility to ensure that, once born, the kids are properly cared for, housed, fed, educated and loved by both parents, or do you see this as a completely separate issue?


In the long run, we're all dead. John Maynard Keynes
by Jerome a Paris (etg@eurotrib.com) on Sun Aug 26th, 2007 at 10:32:08 AM EST
[ Parent ]
You previously mentioned that a fetus is not alive until a certain point. If it is not alive then how is it developing. Of course it is alive. Then the next question generally raised is that the fetus is entirely dependent on the mother's womb to sustain that life. Very true. But it is alive, very much the same way Christopher Reeve and most parapalegics are kept alive through life support systems. Should we consider them to be dead as well. Or how about the person who is in coma or some vegetative state. Do we also consider them not alive and turn off their systems.

I can understand if a woman somehow finds herself carrying a fetus and finds it inconvenient to her life for whatever reason and does not want it. I have a fundamental and moral issue with treating that like an inanimate object without finding alternatives. A solution that would satisfy all would be to have the ability to remove an unwanted fetus, place it in some special incubation chamber until full term. Unfortunately that does not yet exist.

by BJ Lange (langebj@gmail.com) on Sun Aug 26th, 2007 at 10:44:54 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password
Occasional Series