Display:
There is much to dislike about the idea, but the question is whether some well-crafted version would be better than the alternatives.
----------

Regarding exiting a group, I think this must be a universal right, but not timed so as to escape an acceptable punishment for an offence (the meaning of "acceptable" here is in need of crafting, and the boundary would surely be fuzzy). The analogy here is emigration, only not necessarily geographical in nature.

Regarding corporations and taxes, as you say, this is already a problem; non-geographical (or fine-grained geographical) law does not change anything essential. (As for corporations, there is no reason to regard them as having rights in the first place, which provides considerable latitude for applying restrictive laws.)

Regarding castes, freedom of exit makes an enormous difference. Membership in a restrictive group would be optional, reversible, and not necessarily hereditary.
----------

The alternative, it seems to me, is to pit groups seeking order and decency (by their standards) against those seeking a different sort of order and decency. Or, to put it concretely, indigenous peoples (e.g., those of Europe) have more reason to fear immigrants if those immigrants may eventually establish noxious laws that are universally applicable throughout their ancestral homeland. They would have less reason to fear if groups could get most of what they want without forcing it on others.

Note that the world is becoming saturated with surveillance systems, and that this will change possibilities for law enforcement in relevant ways. In particular, it will likely make restrictions more effective and potentially personalised. All the more reason to be able to opt out of other people's offencive notions of right and wrong -- and to opt into a context that enforces one's own enlightened standards.

Words and ideas I offer here may be used freely and without attribution.

by technopolitical on Fri Feb 15th, 2008 at 03:01:56 AM EST
[ Parent ]
technopolitical:
They would have less reason to fear if groups could get most of what they want without forcing it on others.

Really interesting point.  I think the UK approach tries to provide for the needs and wishes of different communities but not to the extent that it forces this on any other individual or community.  So the balance is continually being struck sometimes with success and sometimes not.

Ad astra per aspera

by In Wales (inwales aaat eurotrib.com) on Fri Feb 15th, 2008 at 03:15:16 AM EST
[ Parent ]
How does a community express its wishes?
by Colman (colman at eurotrib.com) on Fri Feb 15th, 2008 at 03:27:02 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Partly through research and stats (including focus groups, surveys etc) and also through the usual means of elected representatives, local councillors, representative organisations seeking feedback from communities.

But the UK has been through various models of 'public engagment' or consultation over the years.

The approach is to accept that information will not get out to everyone and even when it does, not everyone will know what alternatives they could ask for or to be empowered to ask for that. So services have a responsibility to anticipate need based on good practice elsewhere, and research findings on the needs of different communities and successful interventions.

Ad astra per aspera

by In Wales (inwales aaat eurotrib.com) on Fri Feb 15th, 2008 at 03:49:39 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password
Recommended Diaries
The Real Jesse Helms: An LTE
by Drew J Jones - Jul 19
6 comments

The Political Mind by George Lakoff
by ARGeezer - Jul 19
11 comments

Stealing a Mile : A possible Bellydance Ancestry
by Helen - Jul 20
3 comments

Finnish Tango
by Sven Triloqvist - Jul 20
11 comments

A Rorschach Test
by Migeru - Jul 20
66 comments

Obama in Berlin
by jandsm - Jul 18
29 comments

The July 18 in Spain
by PerCLupi - Jul 18
3 comments

Can the US/EU be Self-Sufficient?
by rdf - Jul 18
17 comments

Debates
Campaigns
Occasional Series
Germany
by DoDo - Jul 20

Anglo Disease
by Migeru - Jul 17

Most Commented threads ever
by Migeru - Jul 8
10 comments

Agriculture
by afew - Jul 7

Countdown to $200 oil
by Migeru - Jul 2

Wind power
by Jerome a Paris - Jul 2
1 comment

Train Blogging
by DoDo - Jul 1

TOC: Socratic Economics
by Migeru - Jun 26