European Tribune

Display:
It seems to me that this silver bullet is the same kind of Magic Thinking that is used in the U.S. medical system, where if you take the right pink pill (or blue or green one), all your symptoms will go away and you will be all better.

What people don't want to know is that the little pills are likely to "cure" the symptoms, but leave the underlying causes in place.

But we 'merricans do like our magic. Look at how many people believed the tales of how Iraq would greet the invading army with candy and flowers.

I'm all for oil-producing bugs, but until they hatch I'm going to continue finding ways to reduce my energy consumption and (I'm afraid it's already become a cliche) carbon footprint.

by Mnemosyne on Wed Jun 18th, 2008 at 07:54:58 PM EST
Just two questions about these bugs:  

  1. Assume it works.  What happens when the bugs get loose in the world--as is merely inevitable?  

  2.  Do not assume it works.  Rather, ask, can it work?  Potential energy is not like Wall Street accounting:  Every molecule has a fixed potential energy, which can be modified by its context, but that too is fixed.  So the energy to keep these bugs alive, and the energy for the oil they produce comes from . . . where?  

As far as I can tell, the most optimistic scenerio has farm waste which could be composted but won't be, instead fed to these bugs which then turn a fraction of the energy in the farm waste into oil that can be burnt.  

By the way, there is no way this can be carbon negative, or even neutral:  You are taking fixed carbon  (farm waste) and oxidizing some of it (to feed the bugs) so that the bugs will turn (most of) the rest of it into oil which you then burn (CO2 POSITIVE).  

This smells an awful lot like the guy (posted on ET) who was getting "water" to burn.  

Peak Oil is ultimately about arithmetic.  And the fact that arithmetic is against us.  There may be amelioration but there is no solution.  The numbers are right and we are wrong.  Dead wrong.  

by Gaianne on Thu Jun 19th, 2008 at 01:21:21 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password
Recommended Diaries
On Rhetoric
by rg - Dec 3
58 comments

After Democracy
by marco - Dec 3
40 comments

Bugger Thy Neighbour
by redstar - Dec 3
260 comments

Not quite the 'perfect fix'?
by djhabakkuk - Dec 3
4 comments

Google Translate political bias?
by DoDo - Dec 3
10 comments

So, Ideology is Dead. So now what ?
by ValentinD - Nov 26
574 comments

Beggar Thy Neighbour
by redstar - Dec 3
60 comments

Friedmanite Folly and the Mugabe Option
by ChrisCook - Dec 2
42 comments

Debates
Campaigns
Occasional Series