The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
Perhaps, yes, in a parallel universe.
In this one, however, when Russia tells you up front, ahead of time, before you start mowing down S. Ossetian villages, that if you start mowing down S. Ossetian villages, they will retaliate, when Russia makes it as clear as humanly possible to you that it has a previous agreement with S. Ossetia in which they will defend S. Ossetia should you start mowing down S. Ossetian villages, then, in this universe, the balance of probabilities is that Russia will retaliate and do everything in their power to defend S. Ossetia.
C'mon. Anyone who's ever taken History 101 knows that when Russia says it will fight back, it does, and they usually do not err on the side of restraint. I can understand some of the greatest megalomaniacs in history underestimating Russia's will, but Saakashvili? That has to fall into the category of "THAT stupid." Or "delusional." Or "assuming the US and NATO would go to war with Russia on behalf of Georgia." "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
With due respect to poemless' anti-war diary, we should all realize that part of the Russian response is revenge for the civilians and soldiers killed in the Georgian offensive in S. Ossetia. (And part of that is sheer political calculation: 1) the residents of S. Ossetia are now fully convinced that Russia is their only friend in the world; and 2) Georgia, Ukraine, Estonia, etc. are now fully apprised of consequences.) As soon as the message is acknowledged and all of the Georgian troops are out of Abkhazia and Ossetia, military action will cease. paul spencer
MOSCOW -- The past week's events in South Ossetia are bound to shock and pain anyone. Already, thousands of people have died, tens of thousands have been turned into refugees, and towns and villages lie in ruins. Nothing can justify this loss of life and destruction. It is a warning to all. The roots of this tragedy lie in the decision of Georgia's separatist leaders in 1991 to abolish South Ossetian autonomy. This turned out to be a time bomb for Georgia's territorial integrity. Each time successive Georgian leaders tried to impose their will by force -- both in South Ossetia and in Abkhazia, where the issues of autonomy are similar -- it only made the situation worse. New wounds aggravated old injuries. Nevertheless, it was still possible to find a political solution. For some time, relative calm was maintained in South Ossetia. The peacekeeping force composed of Russians, Georgians and Ossetians fulfilled its mission, and ordinary Ossetians and Georgians, who live close to each other, found at least some common ground. Through all these years, Russia has continued to recognize Georgia's territorial integrity. Clearly, the only way to solve the South Ossetian problem on that basis is through peaceful means. Indeed, in a civilized world, there is no other way. The Georgian leadership flouted this key principle. What happened on the night of Aug. 7 is beyond comprehension. The Georgian military attacked the South Ossetian capital of Tskhinvali with multiple rocket launchers designed to devastate large areas. Russia had to respond. To accuse it of aggression against "small, defenseless Georgia" is not just hypocritical but shows a lack of humanity.
The roots of this tragedy lie in the decision of Georgia's separatist leaders in 1991 to abolish South Ossetian autonomy. This turned out to be a time bomb for Georgia's territorial integrity. Each time successive Georgian leaders tried to impose their will by force -- both in South Ossetia and in Abkhazia, where the issues of autonomy are similar -- it only made the situation worse. New wounds aggravated old injuries.
Nevertheless, it was still possible to find a political solution. For some time, relative calm was maintained in South Ossetia. The peacekeeping force composed of Russians, Georgians and Ossetians fulfilled its mission, and ordinary Ossetians and Georgians, who live close to each other, found at least some common ground.
Through all these years, Russia has continued to recognize Georgia's territorial integrity. Clearly, the only way to solve the South Ossetian problem on that basis is through peaceful means. Indeed, in a civilized world, there is no other way.
The Georgian leadership flouted this key principle.
What happened on the night of Aug. 7 is beyond comprehension. The Georgian military attacked the South Ossetian capital of Tskhinvali with multiple rocket launchers designed to devastate large areas. Russia had to respond. To accuse it of aggression against "small, defenseless Georgia" is not just hypocritical but shows a lack of humanity.
Emphasis mine.
Could not have said it better myself. "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
by ARGeezer - May 24 2 comments
by DoDo - May 23 41 comments
by Nomad - May 10 14 comments
by JakeS - May 15 7 comments
by Metatone - May 14 85 comments
by ARGeezer - May 16 15 comments
by gmoke - May 17 2 comments
by DoDo - May 12 11 comments
by ARGeezer - May 242 comments
by DoDo - May 2341 comments
by gmoke - May 172 comments
by ARGeezer - May 1615 comments
by JakeS - May 157 comments
by Metatone - May 1485 comments
by DoDo - May 1211 comments
by Nomad - May 1014 comments
by Migeru - May 78 comments
by marco - May 782 comments
by Migeru - May 6100 comments
by Ted Welch - May 35 comments
by afew - May 341 comments
by ceebs - May 26 comments
by gmoke - Apr 301 comment
by Frank Schnittger - Apr 3067 comments
by joelado - Apr 2954 comments
by Metatone - Apr 2854 comments
by ATinNM - Apr 275 comments
by ceebs - Apr 265 comments