Given the lies, slander, and innuendo present in Emmet Dunphy's letter one could only assume he is a Bush supporter.
aspiring to genteel poverty
Even McCain doesn't have a monopoly on "lies, slander and innuedo"
It is ad hominem to attack someone on the basis of being an xxxx supporter. You have to address the substance (or lack of) of their argument. Being a Bush supporter, is not, of itself, a capital offence - especially as it doesn't look like the Dems are going to impeach him... Vote McCain for war without gain
