I am sorry, but your excerpts don't tell me where she stands on human rights? What's her position on the Afghanistan war? Is she an Atlanticist or what? Where does she stand on women rights - in general? Is she a hawk or is a dove concerning military interventions? Etc. I have not seen much informations  what her positions on these topics are. But maybe you can enlighten me.

That's what I am interested in - not if she is charming or if she has a good relation with Barroso or if she gets much done, that's nice but I would like to know here ideas behind what she gets done.

It is absolutely possible that she might turn out to do a great job, but at the moment this is all guesswork, until we know where stands on these and other topics.

And you have every right to see it your way, but I am still not convinced - that if Miliband had accepted, there would be two man in this two top positions