Display:
Even Hillary has released a statement on the case after being proded by the US Senator Maria Cantwell. Cantwell has appointed herself judge and jury of the whole affair. The conclusion that Italians are anti-American is painfully ridiculous. Comments like that, to the contrary, smack of anti-Italianism and condescension. Yes, indeed, Cantwell and Knox are of a superior breed.
by de Gondi (publiobestia aaaatttthotmaildaughtusual) on Sun Dec 6th, 2009 at 05:09:34 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Sometime over the last 6-12 months, opinion in Seattle shifted dramatically in Knox's favor. I was still living there when the murder and arrest occurred in 2007, and public opinion was very strongly against Knox. In typical American style she seemed to have been judged and convicted as guilty within the first few days and weeks.

So I was a bit surprised to find that in the reporting from Seattle, in both the corporate media and the blogs, there was a lot of support for Knox and belief that she wasn't guilty of murder. She and her handlers have done an excellent job of presenting her as a sympathetic figure, at least to the Northwestern public (dunno what "America" thinks, since I don't believe the case has much of a profile outside the Pacific NW). It may have been the case that Knox's family and defenders calculated they had a better chance of winning in the US court of public opinion than in a Perugia courtroom.

Senator Cantwell's outspoken statement is a good example of how effective that strategy has been.

Knox's defenders are exploiting Berlusconi for their own purposes, painting Italy as a fundamentally corrupt place with a rigged system of justice, and they hold up Berlusconi as high-profile evidence of their claims, as if he somehow proves that the whole system is untrustworthy. The fact that Berlusconi's immunity was overturned by the Italian high court doesn't seem to have registered at all, and certainly hasn't dented the emerging view of Italy as a place where a cute coed can't get a fair shake.

Of course, this whole line of argument in Knox's defense says more about the US "system" of "justice" than it does about Italy. When a jury returns a verdict that the public dislikes, they've found ways to discredit the jurors and the verdict, and Knox's defenders assume the same playbook can be used against the Perugia court. Further, the notion that Knox got railroaded in an unfair court system is little more than projection, as it is the US justice system itself that is fundamentally and deeply unjust, with rampant corruption and a complete lack of accountability that makes a mockery of our claims to fairness and democracy.

And the world will live as one

by Montereyan (robert at calitics dot com) on Sun Dec 6th, 2009 at 06:05:05 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password
Occasional Series