Display:
Re 8, I see I haven't completed the sentence: For fairness I add one counter-point myself: freight trains are quite often late, thus a switch back to passenger service may need a longer time gap. However, for example for those locos needed in passenger service for rush-hour extra trains, the benefit remains even so.

Re 9: in this point, I focused on benefits other than operational. The Einheitsloks (both the steamers of the thirties and the electrics of the fifties-sixties) had a geat many interchangeable parts. In the locomotive shop, even main parts could be cycled between locomotives of different classes in revision at the same time. There have even been conversions between the 110 (originally express), 139 (mountain freight) and 140 (freight) classes.

*Lunatic*, n.
One whose delusions are out of fashion.

by DoDo on Sun Jul 12th, 2009 at 04:24:22 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Re#8 This point is no longer significant as the freight customers have to a large extent voted with their money and moved to trucks, the railroads that want their business will have to move the freight when the customer wants it moved. There are many freight trains moving during the peak commuter hours, just not in the zones where the commuter trains are moving. This is why the dedicated freight corridors are being proposed to prevent the interference between passenger and freight traffic. BTW have you noticed that even the staunch advocates of the Universal locomotives, the Austrians, have begun to break up the OeBB Traktion fleet, with some of the 1116s being equipped to operate in Hungary on non-ETCS lines.

Re#9 the Br 110s were converted to BR 139s by taking bogies from retired Br 140s, which probably required modifications to the traction motor cooling ducts as the  Br 140 uses a bogie with a longer wheelbase.

The death knell of the Universal locomotive was sounded by the increasing differences in the type of services they are needed for. Passenger locomotives are required to achieve higher speeds, supply electrical power to passenger cars, and operate in push-pull mode. While freight locomotives need signalling systems for multiple countries, and likely the ability to operate under at least two power systems. Trying two combine both in one locomotive will result in an unaffordable price.

by jfbeaulieu on Wed Jul 22nd, 2009 at 09:07:39 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password
Occasional Series