The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
I haven't seen anything like it. The Iraq demos were as big maybe, but not as intense. There was palpable outrage in the air. I mean calls for burning the parliament building dominated the demo, chanted not by hard-core black-block anarchists by by pensioners and mothers with baby-carts.
The situation is unstable. Imagine what happened here in December 08, but on a much larger scale - that is the mood. Perhaps a bit more desperate. Tens of thousands of young people, at the same time, are looking for opportunities to emigrate. Shops are closing at an impressive rate.
I'm writing a diary about the situation in Greece for about a week now, and I keep postponing it because new developments make previous summaries obsolete. A few hours ago the Greek parliament voted to accept the IMF package and the resulting transfer of sovereignty. But both major parties had leaks. 3 socialist MPs abstained, and one major cadre of the conservative party (a candidate for its presidency a few months ago) voted for the agreement. All were banned from their parties. The far-right supported the socialist government for "patriotic" reasons: for the survival of our homeland.
It's a mess. And the only hope, I can see, is some sort of large scale euro relaunch in the framework of a tighter political union. Otherwise there will be a European Union in the street protests, because it seems from here that Portugal and Spain are not far behind where we are now... But that is a wider discussion.
I'll try to post the diary by tomorrow (I hope :-) )
The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom - William Blake
If not, these protests are futile.
She believed in nothing; only her skepticism kept her from being an atheist. -- Jean-Paul Sartre
But there are other silver bullets, such as state asset sales, land sales (250 billion worth of land), huge reduction in military expenditures, etc.
The best thing for the country would be for the ministers to resign en masse. That would create the political will to get Greece on the right track. The protests would not be futile at all if they simply focused on one of the main messages of the protest: "Thieves, Thieves."
Other than Papandreou and the financial team, the entire party structure has to go, and one of the best signs visible today is that New Democracy kicked out Dora Bakoyannis or her supporters. This is the kind of bloodletting that Greece needs. Factions within the parties tearing at one another. (I am not criticizng Bakoyannis and I suspect that she'd be more resolute on some issues than those who kicked her out).
Force the ministers out, establish a unity gov't with totally new clean leaders, and start building jails for white-collar criminals.
If I were Greek, I wouldn't care what comes next. I would gladly accept austerity measures if the following was accomplished.
As Upstate NY said one could, for good measure, start with the military budget. Freeze all military purchases (at 2,3 billion Euros/year currently - that's after a recent 25% cut). Take a serious look into church and monastery wealth - tax it, hard, heck confiscate most of it. Chase large scale tax evasion seriously. Reform the tax system. Do something with the banks and with eschewing corporate taxes legally. A moratorium on small housing and consumer loan payments for those who lose their jobs would be nice. A confiscatory tax on anything over 100k Euros/year personal income... etc.
I should note that the IMF recipe is neoliberal economics writ large: a condemnation to a Latvia-style depression which, in the best case scenarios lead to some sort of rebound only under ideal global economic conditions. Otherwise a whole generation is screwed for life. I mean in 2014 the IMF's estimates is that Greek public debt would be at 150% of GDP, unemployment over 20% and most of the higher qualified working force will be working abroad. And then they say that the economy would rebound - from Vietnamese wages and rampant child malnutrition I guess.
In these circumstances, I note, destruction becomes enjoyable for its own sake for an ever widening part of the impoverished populace.
There is of course the opinion, that even if Greece rejected (or insisted in negotiating harder) the IMF bail-out, the consequences of its default would be such to the global monetary system (not to mention the european banking system) that some sort of less destructive solution would be necessarily offered. This might be true, but some of these same people insisted that Merkel was bluffing, that she couldn't risk destabilizing the euro for some local elections in Germany...
And there are those that reckon that a quick default/restructuring (some say within the euro, and some say after leaving the eurozone) would be the better option. Again there are those that say this because they think that debt restructuring is unavoidable even with the IMF/EU package (and say that restructuring/partially defaulting on 300 billion Euro now is better than restructuring/partially defaulting on 400 billion Euro in 2-3 years time - and Krugman seems to move toward this camp) and others who are saying that this (or even a total default) coupled with a return to the drachma (something that they acknowledge would be disastrous, but they claim less disastrous than the alternative) might offer a chance for some Argentine-style lightning recovery.
Me, I expect that the crisis spreading to Iberia and beyond, might change the rules of the game considerably. So I protest and I persevere, and I froth in anger at the injustice of measures which reward the most egregious villains in the Greek economic saga - the kleptocracy (...And I'm semi-seriously starting to check abroad for job opportunities)...
[I'll put up a diary soon, BTW, I know I will]
The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom - William Blake
I agree entirely that the political change is what is most important here. There are options for dealing with the economics and I think there is will to take "austerity measures" but only if the responsible parties have first been deposed and the people feel like they have control of their government again.
Germany suggested selling some land and many scoffed but I think that in a situation like this, fuck it, here's an island, now go away. I don't think the Greek people would have a huge problem with that either. As an American I know that if we could sell Montana to get out from under our debts we'd all do it in a second, as nice as the place may be.
That would be like much like the USA selling Hawaii to Japan.
That and we don't rightfully own it haha.
That's what I was referring to.
that said, Fidel doesn't want Miami, that's where he sends all of his undesirables.
by Frank Schnittger - May 20 14 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 20 3 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 15 22 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 19 3 comments
by Zwackus - May 12 18 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 11 11 comments
by Zwackus - May 6 69 comments
by Bernard - May 6 41 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 203 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 2014 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 193 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 1522 comments
by Zwackus - May 1218 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 1111 comments
by Bernard - May 641 comments
by Zwackus - May 669 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 419 comments
by Frank Schnittger - Apr 2918 comments