The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
Imagine the following scenario (of which I know many examples):
Person has a small plot of land (really small, maybe not even enough for subsistence) with a small home. Person is unemployed, cannot make much money, etc. If there is some kind of property tax that this person cannot pay then (s)he might get expropriated. So, from a poor person with a measure of self-reliance we now have a desperate slave.
One just needs a property tax that is designed to hit this segment.
I agree that georgism is not without question marks. However your example is not one of those:
Person has a small plot of land (really small, maybe not even enough for subsistence) with a small home.
This person would pay zero LVT, because his plot produces only subsistence. LVT taxes only surplus, not necessary costs of capital or labour.
What would tax collector benefit by capturing worthless land?
The tax collector could be an agent, not of the people, but of the very rich people.
You mean that the tax collector would change the tax code at the moment the ownership is changed? Why otherwise would very rich people pay tax from a plot that does not produce anything? And when the land becomes more valuable, the tax increases even more. You are not talking about land tax at all. You are talking about "poll tax."
The tax collector is an agent of the very rich people now. They tax labour for the benefit of banks and property owners.
You mean that the tax collector would change the tax code at the moment the ownership is changed?
by afew - Jan 28 30 comments
by melo - Jan 23 4 comments
by gmoke - Jan 15 5 comments
by DoDo - Jan 20 4 comments
by Frank Schnittger - Jan 16 111 comments
by ChrisCook - Jan 1 66 comments
by afew - Jan 5 50 comments
by afew - Jan 2830 comments
by melo - Jan 234 comments
by DoDo - Jan 204 comments
by Frank Schnittger - Jan 16111 comments
by gmoke - Jan 155 comments
by afew - Jan 550 comments
by rifek - Jan 59 comments
by DoDo - Jan 25 comments
by ChrisCook - Jan 166 comments
by melo - Dec 316 comments
by Metatone - Dec 3129 comments