The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
Wolfgang Münchau on why the euro will survive In his FT column, Wolfgang Münchau noted that the euro critics who predicted the immediate demise of the eurozone had been proven wrong by last week's events. George Papandreou reshuffled the cabinet, and Angela Merkel capitulated on the private-sector involvement debate, which has been the biggest obstacle to an agreement on a second Greek loan package. The events of last week produced a political economy lesson about the eurozone - events are pushing the eurozone towards further economic and political integration. Greece will eventually default (or be foregiven its debts) - of this there can be no doubt - but Greece will default into the EFSF/ESM/bilateral programmes. Three finance options will then be available, monetisation, fiscal transfer or a eurozone bond. The ECB will reject the former, the member states will reject the second. The eurozone bond will emerge as the only realistic way out. There may still be a major accident on this path, but it will not happen this month, and probably not this year either.
In his FT column, Wolfgang Münchau noted that the euro critics who predicted the immediate demise of the eurozone had been proven wrong by last week's events. George Papandreou reshuffled the cabinet, and Angela Merkel capitulated on the private-sector involvement debate, which has been the biggest obstacle to an agreement on a second Greek loan package. The events of last week produced a political economy lesson about the eurozone - events are pushing the eurozone towards further economic and political integration. Greece will eventually default (or be foregiven its debts) - of this there can be no doubt - but Greece will default into the EFSF/ESM/bilateral programmes. Three finance options will then be available, monetisation, fiscal transfer or a eurozone bond. The ECB will reject the former, the member states will reject the second. The eurozone bond will emerge as the only realistic way out. There may still be a major accident on this path, but it will not happen this month, and probably not this year either.
Though of course I have grown noticeably more pessimistic since then (was that really only five months ago?).
- Jake Austerity can only be implemented in the shadow of a concentration camp.
I find it hard to believe, however, that the EU could make that transformation so quickly, given that they are only now admitting to the systematic nature of the problems. One of the fault lines is the relative speed of national developments in Greece, Portugal and Spain (especially by the Greeks who are trying to re-make democracy for us all), compared with laden-tanker-like responses of the EU.
My bet, for what it's worth, would still be on Eurobond issuance and cobbling the thing together for this year.
We know roughly what would happen in the event of a Eurozone breakup - we've seen it all before (Iceland, Russia, Argentina, etc.).
We also know roughly what would have to happen to make the Eurozone not break up.
If I were a betting man, I'd give it around 50/50 odds.
It explains how the Japanese avoided a full blown recession while their asset prices fell by 87% after their bubble burst. And you've guessed it - the Japanese government spent and continued to spend while the private sector deleveraged and did not invest. The national deficit grew rapidly, but they didn't cut themselves into a great depression. In the process, various neo-classical articles of faith were shown not to hold in a time of asset-bubble hangover deflation.
Precisely the opposite of the ECB/IMF prescription.
by Migeru - Jun 15 73 comments
by Frank Schnittger - Jun 17 20 comments
by Katrin - Jun 12 88 comments
by Jerome a Paris - Jun 9 68 comments
by Ted Welch - Jun 19
by DoDo - Jun 9 22 comments
by Zwackus - Jun 11 64 comments
by Metatone - Jun 8 4 comments
by Frank Schnittger - Jun 1720 comments
by Migeru - Jun 1573 comments
by Katrin - Jun 1288 comments
by DoDo - Jun 1126 comments
by Zwackus - Jun 1164 comments
by Jerome a Paris - Jun 968 comments
by DoDo - Jun 922 comments
by Metatone - Jun 84 comments
by DoDo - Jun 671 comments
by DoDo - Jun 418 comments
by Ted Welch - Jun 31 comment
by gmoke - Jun 211 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 3113 comments
by A swedish kind of death - May 3113 comments
by ceebs - May 2927 comments
by ARGeezer - May 2915 comments
by Zwackus - May 271 comment
by DoDo - May 2631 comments
by DoDo - May 2346 comments