The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
European Tribune - Would an abortion have saved Savita Halappanavar?
It might also have been possible to accelerate the process by inducing an earlier delivery.
I don't know if this was considered, and if so why that option was rejected. Presumably her medical records will shed some light on this. Given that miscarriage is basically premature childbirth triggered if there is some malfunction - I'm not sure if it is known precisely why or how - but which is a naturally occurring end to many pregnancies, perhaps the medical team felt - at the time - there was no need to accelerate the process, or that it was proceeding normally and naturally and with no excessive risk to the mother.
I share your view that this is a somewhat far fetched scenario given that, reportedly, her membrane had ruptured, and that this posed a significant risk of infection. I do know that many successful child-births can take a long time and that induction is often used to accelerate the process, so the suspicion has to be that this was not done here because it was known the foetus was unviable and so that an induction at that time could be construed as an abortion.
However the Catholic Church has often used the somewhat Jesuitical distinction between a treatment intended directly to abort a foetus, and a treatment required by the mother and which has the "side-effect" of aborting the foetus, and so it seems to me the medical team where not "theologically" precluded from pursuing this option. However the failure of the Irish Parliament to legislate to provide greater clarity as to what is and is not legally allowed under the current Constitution may have contributed to uncertainty and procrastination on their part.
Presumably the inquiry team will question them precisely on this point.
Index of Frank's Diaries
by DoDo - Mar 1 13 comments
by marco - Mar 3 43 comments
by maracatu - Feb 25 13 comments
by Oui - Mar 5 53 comments
by Metatone - Feb 28 7 comments
by Katrin - Feb 20 13 comments
by A swedish kind of death - Feb 20 26 comments
by gmoke - Feb 26 3 comments
by afew - Mar 7
by Oui - Mar 553 comments
by Oui - Mar 413 comments
by marco - Mar 343 comments
by vbo - Mar 123 comments
by Oui - Mar 11 comment
by Oui - Mar 13 comments
by DoDo - Mar 113 comments
by Metatone - Feb 287 comments
by vbo - Feb 27110 comments
by gmoke - Feb 263 comments
by vbo - Feb 25102 comments
by maracatu - Feb 2513 comments
by Oui - Feb 2427 comments
by Oui - Feb 2214 comments
by Oui - Feb 211 comment
by Katrin - Feb 2013 comments
by Democrats Ramshield - Feb 202 comments
by A swedish kind of death - Feb 2026 comments
by Democrats Ramshield - Feb 191 comment