The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
A new report says that joining the eurozone has proved to be a "damaging step" for Ireland now facing further economic decline.The study is published just a few days before Irish citizens will have a chance to vote on the eurozone fiscal discipline pact.The Irish go to the polls on 31 May to give their verdict on the controversial deal thrashed out by EU leaders.Called "Ireland and the euro - A journey without a map", the study argues that the decision to join the EU currency union has proved to be "damaging for the Irish economy and development of the country".It goes on to warn that "without taking necessary action the future of Ireland is likely to be one of unrelieved economic decline marked by plunging living standards, mass unemployment and emigration".The study was published in Brussels by a right-leaning think tank, "New Direction - The Foundation for European Reform."
a right-leaning think tank, "New Direction - The Foundation for European Reform."
With such an Orwellian name and an acknowledged "right-leaning" bias it must be a rabid right-winger astroturf outfit... Wind power
The EU has been accused of not allowing a wine to be called wine because it is made from grapes sourced outside the EU.According to EU law, an English wine produced in Kent by Chapel Down & Wines of Argentina cannot be classified as a wine.This is despite it being made of Malbec grapes air-freighted to the UK from Argentina.As a result, the wine owner has been told he must call it a "fruit derived alcoholic beverage from produce sourced outside the EU"....The ruling has been attacked by UKIP leader Nigel Farage who hosted a "non-wine" tasting event in parliament to highlight the issue.Farage said, "This must be one of the most ridiculous EU stories of the year. It is up there with bendy bananas."...Further comment from UKIP member Roger Helmer who said, "It is about time the EU backed off and left the English language to the English."
Oh, it's an English language problem?
Right, it isn't wine. It's an outrage. What idiots can get an idea like that?
Pathetic. We make excellent beer and, apparently, some passable scotch. So it is utterly beyond me why they both slag off the French yet fetishize French drinks.
Our elites still hanker after Henry II's kingdom, while most of us could give a toss keep to the Fen Causeway
Downing Street has played down suggestions of a rift between David Cameron and Francois Hollande ahead of their first face-to-face meeting. Downing Street said the talks are "not awkward" despite Mr Cameron's backing for Mr Hollande's opponent in the recent French presidential election. The prime minister had earlier praised the newly elected Socialist president's deficit reduction plans. He was speaking ahead of the G8 summit in the United States.
Downing Street has played down suggestions of a rift between David Cameron and Francois Hollande ahead of their first face-to-face meeting.
Downing Street said the talks are "not awkward" despite Mr Cameron's backing for Mr Hollande's opponent in the recent French presidential election.
The prime minister had earlier praised the newly elected Socialist president's deficit reduction plans.
He was speaking ahead of the G8 summit in the United States.
Assumptions in Brussels that France's government would be more EU-friendly than its predecessor have been challenged by President François Hollande's choice to appoint two men who opposed the EU constitution in 2005 in leading positions. At the time, France's Socialist party was split into two camps, one advocating a `No' vote in the referendum and the other advocating a `Yes'. Laurent Fabius, who was appointed as foreign minister on Wednesday (16 May), was firmly in the `No' camp. Bernard Cazeneuve, appointed as Europe minister, was also against the constitution.Fabius, who served prime minister in 1984-86 and as an MEP in 1989-1992, was the most high-profile Socialist in the `No' camp, in direct opposition to Hollande who was in the `Yes' camp. Fabius said at the time that the constitution did not have enough social protection and was weighted against working people. In the end the constitution was rejected, with 55% of the French people voting `No'.
Assumptions in Brussels that France's government would be more EU-friendly than its predecessor have been challenged by President François Hollande's choice to appoint two men who opposed the EU constitution in 2005 in leading positions.
At the time, France's Socialist party was split into two camps, one advocating a `No' vote in the referendum and the other advocating a `Yes'. Laurent Fabius, who was appointed as foreign minister on Wednesday (16 May), was firmly in the `No' camp. Bernard Cazeneuve, appointed as Europe minister, was also against the constitution.
Fabius, who served prime minister in 1984-86 and as an MEP in 1989-1992, was the most high-profile Socialist in the `No' camp, in direct opposition to Hollande who was in the `Yes' camp. Fabius said at the time that the constitution did not have enough social protection and was weighted against working people. In the end the constitution was rejected, with 55% of the French people voting `No'.
Oh dear. And these are not the only "Non" supporters in the government. This surely means trouble.
Laurent Fabius, who led the Socialist opposition to the draft European Constitution, has been tapped by Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault to head France's foreign ministry. A close aide, Bernard Cazeneuve, will manage European affairs. EurActiv France reports. Fabius was François Hollande's main opponent during the referendum vote on the draft European Constitution in 2005. He will be assisted by Cazeneuve, the deputy mayor of Cherbourg who was named minister delegate for European Affairs. Besides the Constitution, the two men voted against the Lisbon Treaty to reform EU institutions in 2007.
Laurent Fabius, who led the Socialist opposition to the draft European Constitution, has been tapped by Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault to head France's foreign ministry. A close aide, Bernard Cazeneuve, will manage European affairs. EurActiv France reports.
Fabius was François Hollande's main opponent during the referendum vote on the draft European Constitution in 2005. He will be assisted by Cazeneuve, the deputy mayor of Cherbourg who was named minister delegate for European Affairs.
Besides the Constitution, the two men voted against the Lisbon Treaty to reform EU institutions in 2007.
- Jake If you only spend 20 minutes of the rest of your life on economics, go spend them here.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/may/20/europe-waits-greece-choose-flame-fear-spreads?newsfee d=true
Jean-Claude Trichet, who stood down as president of the European Central Bank last autumn, made a speech on Thursday night in which he argued that eurozone states should be able to declare fellow members bankrupt, and take over their tax and spending policy - an idea that the economist Nouriel Roubini rapidly dismissed as "totally undermining national sovereignty".
A couple of years ago, this would not have frightened me in the least, but now I see the people in charge would be the Weidmann's and Bini Smaghi's. With plenty of advice from the Issing's and Werner Sinn's. This whole treaty has significantly less appeal given the exigent reality we are looking at today.
"In this union of tomorrow, or of the day after tomorrow, would it be too bold, in the economic field, with a single market and a single central bank, to envisage a ministry of finance of the union?" he said as he accepted the Charlemagne prize for contributions to European unity.
"Looking at the euro area today, we see clearly that countries that abide by the rules of the single currency can thrive and prosper," Trichet said. "But we also see the opposite. Strengthening the rules to prevent unsound policies is therefore an urgent priority." ... "But if a country is still not delivering, I think all would agree that the second stage has to be different," he said, suggesting that eurozone authorities be given "a much deeper and authoritative say in the formation of the country's economic policies if these go harmfully astray". He added: "It would be not only possible, but in some cases compulsory, in the second stage for the European authorities - namely the council on the basis of a proposal by the commission, in liaison with the ECB - to take themselves decisions applicable in the economy concerned."
...
"But if a country is still not delivering, I think all would agree that the second stage has to be different," he said, suggesting that eurozone authorities be given "a much deeper and authoritative say in the formation of the country's economic policies if these go harmfully astray".
He added: "It would be not only possible, but in some cases compulsory, in the second stage for the European authorities - namely the council on the basis of a proposal by the commission, in liaison with the ECB - to take themselves decisions applicable in the economy concerned."
The leaders of the G8 group of the world's most powerful economies say they want debt-stricken Greece to remain in the eurozone. In their summit communique, G8 leaders also committed themselves to promoting growth alongside fiscal responsibility. However, the leaders acknowledged "the right measures are not the same for each of us". Greece's possible exit from the eurozone was high on the agenda, following inconclusive elections there.
The leaders of the G8 group of the world's most powerful economies say they want debt-stricken Greece to remain in the eurozone.
In their summit communique, G8 leaders also committed themselves to promoting growth alongside fiscal responsibility.
However, the leaders acknowledged "the right measures are not the same for each of us".
Greece's possible exit from the eurozone was high on the agenda, following inconclusive elections there.
Barack Obama and David Cameron on Saturday clashed with the German chancellor Angela Merkel, demanding she drop her G8 resistance to setting out a clear path for Europe out of its crisis. Measures resisted by the Germans included a looser monetary policy for the European Central Bank that would enable quantitative easing similar to that deployed by the Federal Reserve and the Bank of England.Obama and Cameron discussed their joint position at a G8 summit in Camp David during a 7am meeting held on a treadmill, possibly the first UK-US bilateral to be conducted in a gym.With the pressure from stock markets on world leaders to come up with a decisive plan for solving the crisis, it emerged that the Germans were resisting the inclusion of details in the final communiqué about the best course of action for the eurozone. The so-called sherpas, appointed by national leaders to draft summit communiqués, were at work until 4am on Saturday trying to forge a common position that said something specific about the euro-crisis.It was being suggested that the Germans, partly due to their isolation at the summit, were pressing for specifics to be deferred to an informal EU council later this week, and arguing it was not the business of the G8, including Canada, Russia, Japan and the US, to tell the EU states how to handle their economy. Cameron's aides took the view that it would look distinctly odd if the communiqué did not highlight solutions.
Barack Obama and David Cameron on Saturday clashed with the German chancellor Angela Merkel, demanding she drop her G8 resistance to setting out a clear path for Europe out of its crisis. Measures resisted by the Germans included a looser monetary policy for the European Central Bank that would enable quantitative easing similar to that deployed by the Federal Reserve and the Bank of England.
Obama and Cameron discussed their joint position at a G8 summit in Camp David during a 7am meeting held on a treadmill, possibly the first UK-US bilateral to be conducted in a gym.
With the pressure from stock markets on world leaders to come up with a decisive plan for solving the crisis, it emerged that the Germans were resisting the inclusion of details in the final communiqué about the best course of action for the eurozone. The so-called sherpas, appointed by national leaders to draft summit communiqués, were at work until 4am on Saturday trying to forge a common position that said something specific about the euro-crisis.
It was being suggested that the Germans, partly due to their isolation at the summit, were pressing for specifics to be deferred to an informal EU council later this week, and arguing it was not the business of the G8, including Canada, Russia, Japan and the US, to tell the EU states how to handle their economy. Cameron's aides took the view that it would look distinctly odd if the communiqué did not highlight solutions.
Obama and Cameron discussed their joint position at a G8 summit in Camp David during a 7am meeting held on a treadmill
So much lol in one short sentence.
Greece's election campaign, the second in as many months, officially kicked off on Saturday as polls indicated that fears of expulsion from the eurozone have helped consolidate support for parties backing the tough terms under which Greece received a bailout to keep its debt-stricken economy afloat. Signs of a nascent backlash against anti-bailout groups that took the country by storm in an inconclusive ballot two weeks ago have emerged with surveys showing that the conservative New Democracy party is beginning to rally voters on concerns that opposition to EU- and IMF-dictated austerity may lead Greece to the eurozone exit door.
Signs of a nascent backlash against anti-bailout groups that took the country by storm in an inconclusive ballot two weeks ago have emerged with surveys showing that the conservative New Democracy party is beginning to rally voters on concerns that opposition to EU- and IMF-dictated austerity may lead Greece to the eurozone exit door.
Interestingly, the article doesn't actually give results of any of these polls.
A bomb exploded in front of a girls' school in southern Italy, killing a 16-year-old girl and wounding seven others with suspicion quickly falling on the local Mafia. The explosion, near the entrance of a school named after the wife of murdered anti-Mafia judge Giovanni Falcone, occurred as girls were arriving for the start of the school day, which in Italy includes Saturdays. Authorities said at least two gas canisters appeared to have been placed in or near rubbish containers at the school on Saturday, which local media said was located near the main court in Brindisi, a port city on the "heel" of the Italian peninsula. "This is a tragedy," Mimmo Consales, the mayor of Brindisi, told SkyTG24 television. There was no claim of responsibility and no indication of who had planted the bomb, but initial suspicions were directed at the local mafia, known as the United Sacred Crown. Consales noted that the incident occurred just a few days before the 20th anniversary of the murder of Falcone and his wife, Francesca Morvillo, by a bomb in Sicily on May 23, 1992. An anti-Mafia march had been planned in Brindisi later in the day.
A bomb exploded in front of a girls' school in southern Italy, killing a 16-year-old girl and wounding seven others with suspicion quickly falling on the local Mafia.
The explosion, near the entrance of a school named after the wife of murdered anti-Mafia judge Giovanni Falcone, occurred as girls were arriving for the start of the school day, which in Italy includes Saturdays.
Authorities said at least two gas canisters appeared to have been placed in or near rubbish containers at the school on Saturday, which local media said was located near the main court in Brindisi, a port city on the "heel" of the Italian peninsula.
"This is a tragedy," Mimmo Consales, the mayor of Brindisi, told SkyTG24 television.
There was no claim of responsibility and no indication of who had planted the bomb, but initial suspicions were directed at the local mafia, known as the United Sacred Crown.
Consales noted that the incident occurred just a few days before the 20th anniversary of the murder of Falcone and his wife, Francesca Morvillo, by a bomb in Sicily on May 23, 1992.
An anti-Mafia march had been planned in Brindisi later in the day.
As the Mafia revels in symbols it appears the most likely of the two. In the past destructive acts have been perpetrated against monuments or symbols of the judges Falcone and Borsellino during the anniversaries of their assassinations. This marks the 20th anniversary of Falcone's death, along with his wife and five agents. Apparently the mafias have decided to send a message that they're still around. If the mafias did it, the highly symbolic choice of the time and place would, in my opinion, point to organized crime in general rather than local organizations. Local organizations do not resort to clamorous crimes without a nulla obstat from the rest. If it's a local crime, the perpetrators will be found quickly, in no condition to speak. Otherwise, Italy is in for more bombs.
(Reuters) - Troubles at Finland's Nokia Oyj (NOK1V.HE) aren't just bad news for the company, its staff and shareholders. They're also a warning sign for the small Nordic country's welfare model. Just as Nokia's sure touch with well-designed, consumer-friendly products seems to have deserted it, fears are growing that Finland, whose reputation for innovation rested largely on the handset maker's success, may be losing its competitive edge.While Finland remains one of the few triple-A rated countries in the euro zone, its reputation as an egalitarian society with a stellar education system belies worries about a decline in once-mighty export manufacturers and a rapidly ageing population.For the 5.4 million Finns, the message is stark: prepare for tougher times, later retirement or lower pensions. And for government, the need is to encourage business growth beyond traditional mainstays like forestry while balancing social commitments with economic realities.On Tuesday Finland reported a second straight monthly current account deficit. For 2011 as a whole, it posted a deficit of 1.3 billion euros ($1.7 billion) due to slower export growth.
(Reuters) - Troubles at Finland's Nokia Oyj (NOK1V.HE) aren't just bad news for the company, its staff and shareholders. They're also a warning sign for the small Nordic country's welfare model.
Just as Nokia's sure touch with well-designed, consumer-friendly products seems to have deserted it, fears are growing that Finland, whose reputation for innovation rested largely on the handset maker's success, may be losing its competitive edge.
While Finland remains one of the few triple-A rated countries in the euro zone, its reputation as an egalitarian society with a stellar education system belies worries about a decline in once-mighty export manufacturers and a rapidly ageing population.
For the 5.4 million Finns, the message is stark: prepare for tougher times, later retirement or lower pensions. And for government, the need is to encourage business growth beyond traditional mainstays like forestry while balancing social commitments with economic realities.
On Tuesday Finland reported a second straight monthly current account deficit. For 2011 as a whole, it posted a deficit of 1.3 billion euros ($1.7 billion) due to slower export growth.
(Who are the candidates for the neuro again?)
"Prepare for tougher times, later retirement, or lower pensions"--or, get up and invent something. Not cameras, watches, or phones, something else.
What is left is VTT - the national technical research organization (who did much key research for Nokia - though it's never been visible in VTT's accounting) and the infrastructure of talent, know-how, start-ups (some now large like F-Secure and Stonesoft)) that has surrounded Nokia and will be left in good health after Nokia is consumed.
From the marketing point of view, the principal benefit that Nokia has given to Finland is to put the country on the map. The value in terms of total FDI is more than Nokia ever provided to the Finnish economy directly. That is not easy to measure, but I am paraphrasing a couple of people who should know about this stuff.
In my field I have worked in two main types of organizations: movies where company structures come and go almost monthly (and being a TV freelance is no different), and ad companies which reach a critical mass after 5 years and then 'seed' new hot agencies (the top team leaves and then the remains of the old agency are swallowed by WPP). Or in the current IT nerdscape that is producing so many new organizations at exponentially increasing speed that it is often hard to know at any one moment who belongs to which group or company. And I see that as a good thing ;-)
So you will not find any sympathy for Nokia's plight from the people I work with. We all have our horror stories of Keilalahti. You can't be me, I'm taken
Turnover: 278 M (31.12.2011) Personnel: 2,818 President & CEO: Erkki KM Leppävuori Established: 1942 You can't be me, I'm taken
Rovio Entertainment, based in Espoo, also receives high marks as being a fine place to work.
"Germany #3″ in effect placed the right bet: by locking in chronic devaluers to a currency union (thereby precluding the traditional expedient of currency devaluation to regain export competitiveness), Berlin in effect entrenched Germany's mercantilist model and consolidated the country's dominance as the trade superpower of Europe. The benefits are self-evident, given the contrasting data between Germany and the PIIGS. ... More to the point [regarding the Hartz reforms], Germany benefited from "first mover advantage": they initiated these reforms in the context of a growing global economy. Demanding such wage repression in the context of a global recession makes such "reform" virtually impossible, to say nothing of the fallacy of composition problems, when all other countries seek to deflate their wages in order to gain the elusive export competitiveness. ... The German response so far? "Oops. This guy is blackmailing us. What shall we do?" Because Germany as a creditor nation faces huge losses if the entire banking system starts to come under pressure, to say nothing of the end of their vaunted "wirtschaftwunder" as the entire eurozone implodes. Greece, by contrast, has already experienced 5 years of unremitting economic austerity. The country has been virtually reduced to the state of a barter economy. What has it got to lose at this juncture by refusing to roll over to the Troika?
More to the point [regarding the Hartz reforms], Germany benefited from "first mover advantage": they initiated these reforms in the context of a growing global economy. Demanding such wage repression in the context of a global recession makes such "reform" virtually impossible, to say nothing of the fallacy of composition problems, when all other countries seek to deflate their wages in order to gain the elusive export competitiveness.
The German response so far? "Oops. This guy is blackmailing us. What shall we do?" Because Germany as a creditor nation faces huge losses if the entire banking system starts to come under pressure, to say nothing of the end of their vaunted "wirtschaftwunder" as the entire eurozone implodes. Greece, by contrast, has already experienced 5 years of unremitting economic austerity. The country has been virtually reduced to the state of a barter economy. What has it got to lose at this juncture by refusing to roll over to the Troika?
The first "typo" is
This was corroborated by truly powerful increases in total German employment, whichwith unemployment now standsing at a 20 year low.
It was subsequently discovered that Peter Hartz himself had only secured the acquiescence of Germany's workers by sanctioning illegal payments to Germany's powerful works council (see here) for which he was given a 2 year suspended sentence.
Finally, when the article talks about bank runs. First, a typo on the size
El Mundo reported that depositors had withdrawn one million euros from the Spanish bank Bankia since its takeover by the government on May 9th
If you're a depositor at a Spanish bank in Barcelona, there is nothing stopping you from withdrawing that money and re-depositing it in at a local German bank down the street. There are no capital controls or border controls in effect.
by truly apparently powerful increases in total German employment
Fixed it for Auerback. He should take a look at the reality of jobs created in Germany over the past decade. Part-time, low pay - but they bring the unemployment rate down.
The point is important because the real mechanism at work is wage reduction, but it has to be billed as "economic success". And the unemployment rate, as we know, goes with GDP growth as the headline metric all journalists have learned to measure economic success by.
The Hartz measures have been extremely far reaching in terms of the labor market policy that had been stable for several decades. Bill Mitchell and Ricardo Welters noted that while the reforms appeared to be successful in early 2003, with lots of jobs created, there was a downside: "From the bottom of the cycle, in mid-2003, employment grew much less quickly than in previous upturns. And much of the rise took the form of `mini jobs' - part-time posts paying no more than 400 a month, regardless of hours."As Mitchell and Welters pointed out, the "reforms" actually decreased regular employment. Workers got stuck with so-called "mini/midi" jobs - a new form of low wage part-time employment. Such jobs were hailed as "flexible" and "efficient" by their champions, while detractors such as Mitchell noted that they were part-time jobs characterized by heightened insecurity, lower wages, and poorer working conditions.
(But Auerback shouldn't have said "truly").
If you find this unsafe, then transferring the money to an account in another country, if you have access to that, is probably the only solution. Wind power
Rome, May 20 (AFP) Panicked people rushed into the streets when a powerful earthquake shook northern Italy early today, killing three people and injuring at least 50, emergency services said. The 5.9-magnitude quake struck around 0730 IST and was felt throughout the northeast of the peninsula, from the Emilia-Romagna region to Venice, with its epicentre at Finale Emilia, 36 kilometres north of Bologna. It took place at a depth of 10 kilometres and lasted around 20 seconds, followed by several aftershocks. Earlier a 4.1-magnitude quake shook the Lombardy region around Milan, Italy's financial and business capital, and was felt in the historic cities of Modena, Mantua, Ferrara and Rovigo. Rescue services said the three fatalities were workers on night shifts.
Un ex ufficiale dell'aeronautica, con un passato vicino ai Servizi, famigliari che vendono bombole di gas e buone conoscenze di ingegneria elettronica. E' una delle piste seguite ieri dagli investigatori, che lo hanno interrogato a lungo, seguendo l'ipotesi del gesto isolato per l'attacco alla scuola. E assieme all'uomo - secondo quanto riferisce Brindisireport.it, il sito che per ieri ha diffuso le prime immagini dell'attentato - ci sarebbe anche una seconda persona interrogata.
an ex airforce officer, with a past connection to secret service, family members in the gas cylinder business and good knowledge of electronics, was lengthily interrogated. there are supposedly incriminating pix.
trib ex translate never worked for me, sorry. The power of knowledge is in mortal combat with the knowledge of power. It really is that simple... That's the Edenic apple we are all munching on.
.twitter,.facebook {float:left;margin-right:7px;width:55px;} CloseStyle: MLA APA Chicago More Sharing Services Buy PDF Login or Register to leave a comment.Sign-up for free weekly updates from ForeignAffairs.com. In my frequent visits to the United States these days, I am asked most insistently two questions about Europe: "What will happen in 1992?" and "Can a united European market work?" Many Americans are either skeptical about the future of Europe or nervous about it. Some predict that when put to the test a united Europe will quickly splinter under national and local political pressures. Others fear that Europeans will drop their internal trade barriers only to erect a higher new external wall, creating a kind of "Fortress Europe." I have reason to believe that neither of these doomsday scenarios will come to pass. My hope is not mere irrational optimism, but is rooted firmly in the history of the last forty years. Who would have believed that the very same nations that twice in this century nearly destroyed each other would be as closely united as they are now? If we are able to travel a similar distance in the next forty years, a truly united Europe is well within our grasp.
In my frequent visits to the United States these days, I am asked most insistently two questions about Europe: "What will happen in 1992?" and "Can a united European market work?" Many Americans are either skeptical about the future of Europe or nervous about it. Some predict that when put to the test a united Europe will quickly splinter under national and local political pressures. Others fear that Europeans will drop their internal trade barriers only to erect a higher new external wall, creating a kind of "Fortress Europe."
I have reason to believe that neither of these doomsday scenarios will come to pass. My hope is not mere irrational optimism, but is rooted firmly in the history of the last forty years. Who would have believed that the very same nations that twice in this century nearly destroyed each other would be as closely united as they are now? If we are able to travel a similar distance in the next forty years, a truly united Europe is well within our grasp.
by DoDo - May 20 9 comments
by Nomad - May 10 14 comments
by JakeS - May 15 7 comments
by Metatone - May 14 85 comments
by ARGeezer - May 16 13 comments
by gmoke - May 17 1 comment
by DoDo - May 12 10 comments
by Migeru - May 6 100 comments
by DoDo - May 209 comments
by gmoke - May 171 comment
by ARGeezer - May 1613 comments
by JakeS - May 157 comments
by Metatone - May 1485 comments
by DoDo - May 1210 comments
by Nomad - May 1014 comments
by Migeru - May 78 comments
by marco - May 782 comments
by Migeru - May 6100 comments
by Ted Welch - May 35 comments
by afew - May 340 comments
by ceebs - May 26 comments
by gmoke - Apr 301 comment
by Frank Schnittger - Apr 3067 comments
by joelado - Apr 2954 comments
by Metatone - Apr 2854 comments
by ATinNM - Apr 275 comments
by ceebs - Apr 265 comments
by Frank Schnittger - Apr 2686 comments