French blogger harassed by right wing dynasty

by Jerome a Paris
Tue Jun 21st, 2005 at 04:32:41 AM EST

A French blogger, Christophe Grébert, is going to court this afternoon to defend himself of accusations of defamation brought against him by the city of Puteaux, a wealthy suburb of Paris.

His crime? Writing about what's happening in his city, taking pictures of construction sites, and commenting on the latest city council (public) meetings.

::::::::::::::: More :::::::::::::::::


The city happens to have on its land about two thirds of La Défense, the high rise business district of Paris, which the French government decided 40 years ago to build just outside the city limits in what then were almost empty lands (actually a shanty town). It has grown into a huge business area (with 150,000 workers and 20,000 inhabitants) and of course, all these businesses pay some local taxes, a good chunk of which goes to the city of Puteaux. Charles Ceccaldi-Raynaud has been mayor of the city since 1969, and one year ago he resigned to leave the job to his daughter, Joëlle Ceccaldi-Raynaud, while remaining as a deputy (and keeping all the strategic functions of the city). A member of the UMP (the main right wing party), he has effectively run the city as his personal fiefdom, using the vast amounts of money from La Défense to prop up his city and stifle opposition. His daughter was also the "suppléante" for Nicolas Sarkozy, the rising star of the French right and a strong contender to be the next President of France (the suppléant is there to replace a MP should he resign, as bit like the Vice President does for the President in the US) - she replaced him in the National Assembly while he was in government in 2002-2004 and she resigned in late 2004 to let him take the job back.

So, powerful people who don't tolerate opposition too well. Our blogger has been harassed repeatedly (insults, threats, arrests by the municipal police, prohibition from attending the city council). The city even bought the appartment next to his, and is spending 27,000 euros in legal fees to sue him

Ironically, he is being sued not for what he has written, but for quoting a newspaper article from Le Parisien (dated 26 April 2004) where an former town hall employee who had sued the city explained her case, and told how she had been threatened ("shut up, or you'll see what happens when one touches our friends"). He simply commented that, as he had himself been similarly threatened, he took that testimony seriously.

Thankfully, that story has now broken in the mainstream, makes the big headline of Libération (see the full article and the front page (pdf)), and is being talked about on the mainstream radios. Even better, the issue is being discussed as one of "stifling freedom of expression" (equivalent to first amendment issues) which means that in any case the city has already lost the PR battle.

So please have alook at his site and help him if you can (that's the "faire un don" paypal button on the right hand side of his site).

Let's have international solidarity within the left blogosphere!

Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password

Display:
So please have alook at his site and help him if you can (that's the "faire un don" paypal button on the right hand side of his site).

Your wish is my command.
by Colman (colman at eurotrib.com) on Tue Jun 21st, 2005 at 04:51:36 AM EST
Obviously the blogger needs some funds to pay for legal fees...but is there anything else that can be done to give support/spread the word? It would be good to see the further rise of Blogger activism in France and greater Europe...this might be an opportunity. If this person gets stifled, then who next?

Thanks for passing the word, Jerome...

"Once in awhile we get shown the light, in the strangest of places, if we look at it right" - Hunter/Garcia

by whataboutbob on Tue Jun 21st, 2005 at 05:02:06 AM EST
of local, feudal politics in France where car dealers get elected mayor to put other car dealers out of business, where business is conducted in cash only, where physical intimidation is common...  and lose your illusion (if you had any) about French politics being exclusively high brow internationalist stuff !  This legal battle is a good spotlight for showing the world how the French mighty of all stripes shut their opponents up by using defamation and abusing "droit à l'image" (preserving rights to your image) laws.

Spread the word by all means.

by Guillaume on Tue Jun 21st, 2005 at 05:24:57 AM EST
For those not able to paypal for various and sundry reasons, what could we do to help?
by gradinski chai on Tue Jun 21st, 2005 at 05:51:42 AM EST
A quick note:

Just enter the whole number of Euros that you want to contribute.  Don't put any decimal points into the Montant (Amount) field.  

In Europe they have different conventions for writing numbers, and decimal points are used as the thousands separator.  If you include a decimal point (like I did), you'll have to wade through screens of error messages.

by corncam on Tue Jun 21st, 2005 at 07:05:16 AM EST
That's exactly the kind of thing that makes me wondering about my return in France. Is it really worth it ??

Anyway, this guy is pretty courageous and I hope it will turn out well for him. But I'm not that much optimistic knowing the way it works in France : "le pot de terre contre le pot de fer"...

by Jerome USA on Tue Jun 21st, 2005 at 09:58:32 PM EST


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]