|
by Jerome a Paris
Of course, this is not the headline today, but I hane the sneaky feeling that it would be if the vote had not been 49.80%-49.73% for the left, but for the right. Instead, we get:
Prodi claims victory as Italy faces paralysis Not "Prodi wins", but Prodi claims victory, despite the fact that the article quotes the final, official results for the lower chamber. And "Italy faces paralysis", because, what else, it has a coalition of the left in government. Would Italy have "faced paralysis because of the presence of Lega Norde in the Berlusconi government?
That article is from the FT, on the front page of their internet edition, but I suspect it will be representative of what we should expect elsewhere:
Italy faced political paralysis on Tuesday morning after the closest election result in the nation’s modern history showed that voters were split almost exactly in half between left and right.Well, one side won. How's that for paralysis?
Romano Prodi, the former European Commission president, and his centre-left opposition won control of parliament’s lower house by taking 341 seats against 277 seats for the centre-right government of Silvio Berlusconi, prime minister. Another 12 seats remained to be allocated.You see, the only goal of any government these days is "serious economic reform" which, as we know now, is just a code for "pay workers less, give pensioners and unemployed people smaller benefits, and make them all work harder so that companies can make better profits". But would a narrow majority for Berlusconi lead to stories that he "has little control"? No, you'd have the breathless paragraphs about his unexpected last minute victory, crowing about his bet on the voting rules which paid off handsomely, and, of course, deeper meaning found that another major Bush ally won...
A similar problem of parliamentary arithmetic bedevilled Mr Prodi’s 1996-98 government and eventually contributed to his downfall at communist hands.Let's try to ignore the results of this election, and say that another one is inevitable. Who do these people think they are? Again, do you really think they'd call for new elections if Berlusconi had the same narrow win? And of course, the only task of a caretaker government would be "maintaining fiscal discipline". That's not partisan or a policy choice, of course... But the thing is - there should not be commies in government, even if they won! Again can you imagine calls for a broad coalition government if Berlusconi has won, however narrowly?
Still another complication on the horizon is that Italy must choose a new head of state to replace Carlo Azeglio Ciampi, whose seven-year term expires next month. The choice rests with members of parliament and representatives of Italy’s regions, and it may prove difficult to achieve a consensus between centre-right and centre-left after the acrimony of the election campaign.Again, it all sounds factual, but the order in which it is presented tends to validate the claims of the right that the left may not actually have won: the narrow victory margin is provided as input AFTER the claim that a recount is needed, thus giving credence to it, and the comment on the voting system goes on to make the left's victory in the chamber appear less real than it is, a result of electoral shenanigans (without any commentary that that reform was introduced by Berlusconi precisley to try to turn a narrow victory, the best they could hope, into a stable majority). But the system was put in place by Berlusconi precisley to give a clear majority. Now that it has delivered exactly what it was meant to do, it's electoral trickery?
The uncertainty helped drive Italian stocks lower on Tuesday morning with the MIB 30 down 0.8 per cent to 38,392 in early trading.Yes, the verdict of the money men to finish with. Italy lost but Berlusconi still won...
|
Menu
. Home
. About . Contact . New User Guide . FAQ . ET Editorial Guidelines . Search . Search (Google) Login
|
||
|
Article Deconstruction (vol. 7): "Berlusconi triumphant as he wins narrow victory" | 28 comments (28 topical, 0 editorial, 0 hidden)
Article Deconstruction (vol. 7): "Berlusconi triumphant as he wins narrow victory" | 28 comments (28 topical, 0 editorial, 0 hidden)
| ||||
| ||||