European Tribune

Week-end Clock Blogging - La Regence

by dmun
Sat May 27th, 2006 at 09:04:07 AM EST

A LITTLE BIT DISGUSTING - THE REGENCE PERIOD

For years, I've been quoting a French saying "everything exquisite is a little bit disgusting"  This week, when I wanted to get a citation for the quote, I can't find any trace of it in English or in French - "tout exquis est un peu répugnant".  Maybe I made it up.  Who knows. In any event, here I am on the premier european leftist political blog talking without contempt of the sun-king and his successors, and their namesake periods of decoration.

This week we talk about the next period of clock design in Paris, the Regence, when clocks begin to loose their rectangular form and begin the transition to the free sculptural forms that prevailed in the mid-eighteenth century.  The designs start to get a little, well, exquisite, for most tastes.

It doesn't help that for years, 18th century French furniture has been the decorating choice for arivistes and the newly wealthy.  That's how the Frick, and the Getty, and the Metropolitan Museum got full of the stuff, after all.  In it's lesser pieces and the endless 19th century reproductions it is truly repellant: in the trade such expressions as "Louis the who" and "Bronx revival" drip with contempt for the stuff.

(image credit: Phototypie A. Faucheaux, Chelles.  An old print: more Louis XVI than Regence, but you get the idea)

I begin last week with a snarky remark about the French golden age of interior decoration.  It's easy to condemn for it's excess, but in a real sense, the modern world was invented in the Salons of 18th century Paris.  The idea was not only that every interior was to conform to accepted taste, and be fitted with harmoniously designed furniture and fittings, but the home was an important place, and that women had an important place in the social and intellectual life of the comunity.  Even the idea that a chair should be comfortable, and fit the human form was a Parisian invention of this period: Up until this time the bench of the peasant and the throne of a king differed only in size and material - they were both equally uncomfortable.


When Louis XIV died in 1715, his great-grandson Louis XV, next in line to the throne, was only five. Until he came of age, the kingdom was ruled by Louis XIV's nephew, the Regent, Philippe d'Orléans. During the Regency (1715-1723) an important change in style gradually occurred. Just as the period was a political and social parenthesis between the reign of Louis XIV and that of Louis XV, it also represented a transitional period in art, from the architectural rigor of the first era - of which the typical horological representation was the rectangular "Religieuse" clock with its strict lines and ceremonious decor - to the exuberant rococo style of the second, which reached its apogee with the Louis XV cartel.

The Regency style contained all the features of the future Louis XV style, but in a latent form. During this period the bracket cartel clock remained symmetrical in form, but the straight lines of the Louis XIV clock began to melt, giving way to gentler, more curving shapes, often referred to as the "violin" silhouette. The copper, ebony, and tortoiseshell marquetry of the previous era, made way for wood veneering in rosewood, kingwood, amaranth and "bois de violette". The cases were ornamented with finely chiseled gilt bronze.

(credit: antiquorum.com)  
_

The less rigorous and more fluid designs reflected a loosening of French society at this time:

<<C'est le joli temps de la Régence / Où l'on fit tout, excepté pénitence>> (chanson populaire)

The clock started to strain against the constraints of it's rectangular form:

(image credit: La Pendule Française 1re partie,   Tardy   Self-published, undated)

Watch here, as the door starts to flare, and be shaped at the bottom, in this example by Mousset á Paris.

The door starts to assume odd shapes, and be caved-in at the bottom:

(image credit: Les Ouvriers Du Temps,   Jean-Dominique Augarde   Antiquorum, undated)

Pay no attention to the hands and the positions of the winding holes in the dial.  This example, from the Wallace Collection, London, is an example of the awful practice of the English replacing French period movements with English Fusee movements.

Now the door starts to assume the typical "balloon" shape:

(image credit: French Clocks in North American Collections   Winthrop Edey   The Frick Collection 1982)  

This clock, by Mynuel á Paris, is in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum in New York.

Finally, the bracket clock settles into the form that it would hold through the entire Louis XV period:

(image credit: Bordeaux Antiquities)

The door is now balloon shaped, as is the case.  Note that except for a bit of ornament, the clock is still entirely symetrical. Also, the carved steel hands, instead of elaborate gilt ones, are a sign that this is an early example.

The Regence was a transitional period:

(image credit: La Pendule Française 1re partie,   Tardy   Self-published, undated)

As well as awkward transitions, there were idiosyncratic triumphs, as in this bracket clock by Jean-Baptiste Baillon á Paris.  Note the fact, since this is a small clock with a 5" (or so) dial, that the dial can be made of one piece of enamel.  The elaborate multiple piece enamel dials in a gilt surround was dictated by the fact that at this early period, they couldn't successfully make large one-piece enamel dials.  Also note the early use of chased gilt hands.  Here the clock is more fully integrated into it's matching bracket, giving the appearance of a one-piece wall clock.  There is also more use of gilt mounts, which would soon cover the entire wooden frame.  Again, they wanted to make one piece cast bronze clock cases, but design kept ahead of technology, except in smaller examples:

(image credit: Les Ouvriers Du Temps,   Jean-Dominique Augarde   Antiquorum, undated)

This clock is an early example of the cast bronze wall clock that the French call a Cartel.

The case is made of several castings, not yet a one-piece construction.

Next time: The elephant in the room - the invention of the temperature compensation pendulum.

Previously:

Monastic alarms and the beginnings of clockmaking
De Dondi's remarkable astrarium
Early tower clocks
Gothic iron clocks
Rennaisance clocks
Early english lantern clocks
Huygens and the pendulum
Fromanteel's English pendulum clocks
Huygens in Paris
Clement and the recoil escapement
Edward East and the golden age
Thomas Tompion
Daniel Quare
Joseph Knibb
Golden age recap
The balance spring
Paris - Louis Quatorze

Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password

Display:
This week, Sophia Coppela was booed at Cannes for presenting a film that depicted Marie Antoinette in a postive, or at least neutral, light.

It's clear that some people are still uneasy with the opulence of the Ancienne Regieme.  It's true that there is a lot to be uneasy about.

So, have a good weekend.  It's a holiday weekend here in the States, Memorial day.  Have a good one.

David

arcadianclock.com

by dmun on Sat May 27th, 2006 at 09:15:18 AM EST
Was she booed for a positive Marie-Antoinette, of for the general low-quality of the picture ? I saw it last friday. It certainly is not positive. It shows dear Antoine totally frivolous, clueless and disconnected from the realities of her time. And eventually reality dealt with her.
But the whole movie lacks rhythm, it's too slow, photo & editing are not top-notch, and the shooting in location in Versailles with all that money in the dresses are not enough to save it.

Pierre
by Pierre on Tue May 30th, 2006 at 10:19:14 AM EST
[ Parent ]

 What?

  No poll ?

 All right, I'll ask:

  Who here really likes this style of décor?

  Moi, thumbs down.

"In the interest of democracy, repressive actions were taken; In order to preserve democracy, repressive actions were taken"

by proximity1 (proximity1-at-free-dot-fr---end-o'adresss) on Sat May 27th, 2006 at 04:11:14 PM EST
French 18th century interior decor was excessive.

Some of it was really dreadful.

Some of it was incredibly beautiful, but not really in this period.

After you get past the dead tortoises, and the mercury poisoned fire gilders, and tropical forests ravaged, some of it has a real beauty.  

I have to say, it's a little like admiring the architecture of Albert Speer

But stick with me, you have to understand the 18th century stuff, to see what the real masterpieces of early 19th century French clockmaking were reacting against.

by dmun on Sat May 27th, 2006 at 06:48:21 PM EST
[ Parent ]
One can admire craftsmanship without supporting its ownership, and one can certainly understand history better by its artefacts.

Even dear Leonardo was hired for his military engineering skills and was supported through his life by the patronage of all kinds of power beings that you wouldn't want as your boss.

You can't be me, I'm taken

by Sven Triloqvist on Sun May 28th, 2006 at 06:57:22 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Well, I'm certainly not uncomfortable with it... (Hell, that's why I sold my soul and went in banking !)

Pierre
by Pierre on Tue May 30th, 2006 at 10:14:17 AM EST
[ Parent ]


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]