European Tribune

Week-end Clock Blogging - George Graham and compensation

by dmun
Sat Jun 3rd, 2006 at 11:52:34 AM EST

A SECOND A WEEK - GEORGE GRAHAM AND THE COMPENSATION PENDULUM

We've covered some technical advances that brought the pendulum clock to the edge of accuracy.  By the late 17th century, the pendulum, the anchor escapement and the seconds pendulum, and weight drive coupled with maintaining power brought the clock to 10 or 15 seconds a week as opposed to the 10 or 15 minutes a day that was common in renaissance clocks. In fact, a lot of these clocks are still running, and keeping better time than when they were new.

(image credit: Wikipedia)

I know. Poor George. Ugly as homemade sin. But he was a remarkable clockmaker. He invented the dead beat escapement, that didn't put the brakes on the pendulum with every tick, and it's watchmaking equivalent, the cylinder escapement. He invented the Orrery, a teaching tool that demonstrates the relative positions of the planets in the Solar System.  But most important, he invented the first, and until modern times, the best method of compensating for changes in temperature in pendulums. His portrait, above, shows his compensation pendulum in the background.


George Graham was born in Cumberland, England in 1673.  He moved to London, and was apprenticed to Henry Aske for the customary seven years. He was admitted to the clockmaker's company in 1695, and went to work for Thomas Tompion, where upon he become Tompion's partner and successor:

George Graham, nephew of the late Mr. Thomas Tompion, who lived with him upward to 17 years, and managed his trade for several years past, whose name was joined with Mr. Tompion's for some time before his death, and to whom he left all his stock and work, finished and unfinished, continues to carry on the said trade at the late dwelling house of the said Mr. Tompion, at the sign of the Dial and Three Crowns, at the corner of Water Lane in Fleet Street, London, where all persons may be accommodated as formerly.

London Gazette, November 28, 1713.

In this period it was discovered that clocks ran faster in cold weather, and slower in warm weather, although the effect was masked by the fact that the crude animal-based fats available for clock lubricants speeded them up by applying more power to the pendulum when they thinned out at higher temperatures. In fact, many early pendulum clocks keep better time now than when they were new because of modern clock oil, and temperature controlled environments.  

It was, in fact, Graham's invention of a clock escapement that was less dependent on train power, that isolated the temperature problem.  It has been said that Tompion invented the dead-beat escapement, but none the less it was Graham who perfected and named it, and to him goes the credit.

(image credit: brendlers.net)

The 'scape wheel rests on a pallet that is "dead": on the circumference of a circle centered at the verge pivot, so that when the pendulum is swinging the scape wheel tooth doesn't move backward (recoil) or forward (draw).  This was more important than it looks.  It was the first time that the two functions of an escapement, impulse, where the pendulum gets it's push, and locking, where the number of swings are counted, were separated, and this was the key to future escapement improvements.

With the pendulum now somewhat free of influence of the clock train, the problem of temperature changes became clear.  The expansion of metals with temperature increase was smaller than could be measured at the time, but the cumulative effect showed in the clock's change in rate.

Modern engineering texts will tell you that steel has an linear expansion of .00000633 per unit per degree f. That's hard to measure, even with modern measuring tools.  It was, however, known that different metals expanded at different rates, and graham put this to work.  The metal with the greatest expansion is mercury, and graham formed a pendulum with a jar full of mercury in place of the pendulum. This had the benefit of being adjustable, (more mercury in the jar would increase the compensation) as well as massive: Mercury has a higher weight per volume than lead.  It was realized early on that massive pendulums kept better time than light ones, because they resist small disturbances, and average out large ones.

I can't find a picture of a Graham pendulum, but here is one from a later regulator:

(image credit: Precision Pendulum Clocks    Derek Roberts   Exhibition catalog  1986)

This is a early 19c regulator by Thwates and Reed, a large maker.  

Here is a fine Graham longcase clock from the Vitale collection:


(image credit: The Vitale Collection Part II,   Christie's auction catalog Nov. 26, 1996)

As the successor to Tompion, Graham's workmanship was of the highest caliber: often better than Tompion's own, as these images show.

We'll end today's discussion on George Graham with a fine month duration longcase regulator, with high count pinions, dead beat escapement, and bolt-and-shutter maintaining power:

(image credit: St. Edmundsbury, UK, Manor House Museum)

Next time: 18th century clockmaking in other European countries.

Previously:

Monastic alarms and the beginnings of clockmaking
De Dondi's remarkable astrarium
Early tower clocks
Gothic iron clocks
Rennaisance clocks
Early english lantern clocks
Huygens and the pendulum
Fromanteel's English pendulum clocks
Huygens in Paris
Clement and the recoil escapement
Edward East and the golden age
Thomas Tompion
Daniel Quare
Joseph Knibb
Golden age recap
The balance spring
Paris - Louis Quatorze
Paris - La Regence

Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password

Display:
A rainy morning here in the US east coast, and I'm slower off the mark than usual.  Still, a good topic, and I hope you enjoyed it.

Have a good weekend.

David

arcadianclock.com

by dmun on Sat Jun 3rd, 2006 at 11:57:45 AM EST
Thanks again for a great post!  Is it just me, or does that guy look a bit like Ben Kingsley?  (apologies if it's Sir Ben)

Maybe we can eventually make language a complete impediment to understanding. -Hobbes
by Izzy (izzy at eurotrib dot com) on Sat Jun 3rd, 2006 at 08:42:38 PM EST
He reminds me more of the guy who played in the Mozart Movie - gosh, I really should start memorizing the names of actors.
by Fran (fran at eurotrib dot com) on Sun Jun 4th, 2006 at 03:47:49 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Oh, that guy -- you're right!  F. Murray Abraham, if memory serves.

Maybe we can eventually make language a complete impediment to understanding. -Hobbes
by Izzy (izzy at eurotrib dot com) on Sun Jun 4th, 2006 at 03:55:32 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Hey your great and still up!?
by Fran (fran at eurotrib dot com) on Sun Jun 4th, 2006 at 04:00:39 AM EST
[ Parent ]
There was a framed copy of this print on the wall at clock school, (Bowman Technical School in Lancaster PA) and my friends and I used to laugh at the guy for being so UGLY.

We didn't think he looked like any movie star.

by dmun on Sun Jun 4th, 2006 at 07:57:27 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Thank you for another enjoyable diary.
by Fran (fran at eurotrib dot com) on Sun Jun 4th, 2006 at 03:48:30 AM EST


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]