|
by STA
It has become a long-standing strategy for Karl Rove and the Republican Party to have recourse to ad hominem attacks against their political adversaries.
A brief history first:
In philosophy courses, we don't let students make ad hominem arguments. They have as much persuasive value as "yo moma jokes" (Ad Mominem?) However you call it, it is low but seems to work in American politics these days.
Today's case: al-Mashhadani
Conservative websites are going after one of the reporters who broke the Haditha massacre:
Given the breathless coverage (actually only repetition of the same paltry facts) from our one party media about the civilian deaths in Haditha, I am surprised that we have heard nothing about the curious background of one of the first journalists to report the story, Ali Omar Abrahem al-Mashhadani, from the "restive town" of Ramadi. Indeed, it is true that he has been jailed, twice:
An Iraqi cameraman for Reuters news agency was released Thursday after being held for 12 days by the U.S. military. Ali al-Mashhadani, 37, was arrested at a U.S. base in his home town of Ramadi on May 20 while trying to recover Reuters cell phones confiscated from him a week earlier, Reuters reported. It said U.S. officials deemed the cameraman a security threat, although no allegation or charge was made against him. Al-Mashhadani was repeatedly interviewed about his work as a journalist in Anbar province, Reuters said.
No justification. No charges. No reason given. Nothing. But here is the conclusion reached by the same conservative website did Ali al-Mashhadani have an axe to grind against the US after having just been released after being held for five months by the Americans? Would one have an "ax to grind" if imprisoned without being given any reason, any charges? Perhaps. But that is not exactly the point. What did he report? Was that proven to be fabricated? No. But that does not seem to matter. An ad-hominem seems to do just fine. What a relief! The logical upshot? The Haditha Massacre Did Not Take Place! (A roughly similar post in French) |
Menu
. Home
. About . Contact . New User Guide . FAQ . Search . Search (Google) . Archives (Wiki) Art, Economics, Energy, Environment, EU Politics, Mech & Tech, By Country Login
|
||
|
The Haditha Massacre Did Not Take Place (Ad Mominem Victory!) | 1 comment (1 topical, 0 editorial, 0 hidden)
The Haditha Massacre Did Not Take Place (Ad Mominem Victory!) | 1 comment (1 topical, 0 editorial, 0 hidden)
| ||||
| ||||