What is it?

by Ted Welch
Mon Dec 10th, 2007 at 05:47:04 AM EST

On Friday at about lunch-time I wandered into Nice's old town and came across this scene:

crowd-event-nice-40918

It reminded me of the "What is it?" subject sometimes used in the Friday photo-blog - I had no idea what this was all about.

Interesting collage - diary rescue by Migeru


[editor's note, by Migeru] Fold inserted here for the front page
Some of them sounded Italian:

nice-event-40922

I followed them to La Petite Maison, recently revealed in Nice Matin to be the favourite restaurant of the mayor and local political leaders:

nice-event-40923

Of course I could have asked someone what was going on, e.g. the blond in the centre :-), but then I'm a male and we don't even like to ask for directions. Anyway she might have answered in rapid French and then I would have had to reveal that not only was I ignorant, but also linguistically challenged.

There were police everywhere and not just local police, but national CRS, not noted for their gentleness:

nice-police-40966

A heavily guarded convoy was waiting near the restaurant, one car had a flag and dark windows:

nice-event-40930

I decided to leave the media to do their job and headed for the Promenade des Anglais - which was free from the usual traffic :

nice-event-40931

- it must be an important meeting.

The beach was free from the tourist hordes of summer and the beach café had plenty of room - very relaxing:

nice-beach-empty-40933

 But - what were those boats doing, drifting ominously over there?

beach-plane-navy-s-40938

Clearly the security presence didn't end in the old town - beyond the boats was what looked like the war ship they'd come from:

navy-beach-40944

The next day all was revealed in Nice Matin - petit homme va a la restaurant Petite Maison:

sarko-pet-maison-50005

sarko-nice-prodi-50007

And - what do you know - we're back to energy issues, from the IHT:


"A pact sealed Friday that gives the Italian utility Enel a chunk of Électricité de France's prized nuclear assets chimes with European Union plans to break down energy borders - and provides Italy with cheap nuclear energy without having to house a politically sensitive plant on its own soil.

Under the €2 billion, or $2.9 billion, deal, signed in the presence of President Nicolas Sarkozy of France and Prime Minister Romano Prodi of Italy, Enel takes a 12.5 percent stake in France's first, third-generation European pressurized water reactor, or EPR, which is being built in Flamanville in northern France.

http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/11/30/business/energy.php

The IHT also explains the previously antagonistic context:


The deal signed Friday has been stalled for the past two years as both countries bristled at the other's forays into its energy market. A preliminary accord was signed in May 2005.

After EDF swooped on Edison - Italy's second-largest power company after Enel - the previous Italian government of Silvio Berlusconi capped EDF's voting rights at 2 percent, even though the French company controlled a majority stake. The cap was later removed.
France responded by blocking Enel's interest in the French utility Suez, creating instead a government brokered merger with Gaz de France.

"We had some upsets," Prodi said Friday. "This period is now behind us."

http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/11/30/business/energy.php

While this will help cut CO2 emissions, it is not, of course, going to be welcomed by environmentalists. However France isn't going to give up its nuclear industry any time soon, while Italian politicians are keen to reduce their reliance on imported gas:


Colette Lewiner, a former EDF executive now with Capgemini, said the European Commission should welcome the deal, not least because of its promotion of nuclear energy, which is increasingly seen as a crucial part of the energy mix if the EU is to have secure and sustainable supplies.

"This should help meet the European union climate change objectives on CO2 emissions reduction," Lewiner said.

Italy banned nuclear power generation on its own territory following a referendum after the world's biggest nuclear disaster at Chernobyl in 1986.

But its overdependence on imported gas has made some politicians and industry executives reconsider, improving the domestic environment in Italy for a deal with the world's biggest nuclear power operator.

EDF has 58 plants in France providing nearly 80 percent of the country's electricity.

ibid.

It doesn't end there; the meeting included other important issues:

Nicolas Sarkozy and Romano Prodi also raised questions of immigration, a priority announced by the French presidency from 1st July, 2OO8 and the organization of the Mediterranean area

... In the field of the immigration, the President of the French Republic and the Italian Leader of the government stated an agreement, creating the Council of safety(security) and Defence. Agreement also as regards training and higher education. In the sector of space, the European preference for rockets was asserted.

Finally, both men again announced their intention to reduce forgery. Nicolas Sarkozy and Romano Prodi also made a brief survey of the most pressing issues on the international scene: Iran, Kosovo and the peace process in the Middle East.

http://mediterranee.france3.fr/info/36918255-fr.php


While outside, others raised further issues :


Also, in the margins of the above, a gathering was held of opponents to the high speed line: Lyon-Turin.

... ten miltants of ATTAC  denounced the passage by force of the new European treaty, demanding a referendum on this subject and presenting the "ten principles" defined by ATTAC for a "democratic treaty ".

http://mediterranee.france3.fr/info/36918255-fr.php

Attac's 10 principles:

1. To launch a democratic process
 2. To improve democracy
3. To install transparency
 4. To develop participation and direct democracy
 5. To improve basic rights
 6. To protect and improve democratic achievements
 7. To open the field with an alternative economic order
 8. To define the ends and not the means
 9. To aim high on social matters and tax
10. To found the obligation of peace and solidarity

http://www.france.attac.org/spip.php?rubrique1001

As the American painter Ron Kitaj - who included texts in his earlier works - said: "Some books have pictures and some pictures have books."

Optional extra :-) - but very relevant (in my mind - note the reference to "picture puzzles").

While not quite a book (and, unlike earlier works, there's no text actually in the picture), here's an example of Kitaj's work and his notes about it:

autumn-kitaj


R.B. Kitaj comments on his works:

The Autumn of Central Paris (after Walter Benjamin) 1972-74

Dear Benjamin is now a truly chewed over cultural spectre, not least in art writing. I started to chew on him myself in the late sixties after having fallen upon him, before the deluge, in a publication of the Leo Baeck Institute. His wonderful and difficult montage, pressing together quickening tableaux from texts and from a disjunct world, were called citations by a disciple of his who also conceded that the picture puzzle distinguished everything he wrote.

His personality began to speak to the painter in me the adventure of his addiction to fragment life, the allusive and incomplete nature of his work (Gestapo at his heels) had slowly formed up into one of those heterodox legacies upon which I like to stake my own dubious art claims against better judgements of how one is permitted to burden the crazy drama of painting.

When I first showed this picture, a reviewer even began his attack by choking on the title, which he said I'd stolen from a sociological treatise having nothing to do with Benjamin. The critic was dead right. Benjamin thrills me in no small measure because he does not cohere, and beautifully. He was one of those lonely few who lived out Flaubert's instruction: "Not to resemble one's neighbor; that is everything." A lot of people, a whole lot of artists would wish for that, I think, but it eludes us more than we imagine it does. His angry neighbors drove him to kill himself in that very Autumn Of 1940 which saw the Fall of France and in which I've set this picture.

Some of my working notes for which follow below. I feel I ought to apologise for this type of painting because it's such a rouged and puerile reflection upon such vivid personality, but maybe I won't (apologise); maybe a painter who snips off a length of picture from the flawed scroll which is ever depicting the train of his interest, as Benjamin did, may put a daemon spirit like Benjamin in the picture.

Citations, (sketchbook entries for Benjamin painting)

B's montage practice, which he called 'agitational usage'. See fractured suggestion in trompe l'oeil example ... (things covering up, overlapping other things, fooling the eye in painting depiction ... ).

THE DIORAMA ('for the last time, in these DIORAMAS, the worker appeared, away from his class, as a STAGE EXTRA in an IDYLL'). Painting as Diorama/Tableau (ask Cleveland Museum if they still have those dioramas they showed in my childhood; also sculpture of workmen (by Max Kalish?) I must have seen those dioramas as B was about to die in 1940.)

Cafe life as an AUTUMNAL REVERIE of bourgeois society; NATURE MORTE; cafe as OPEN AIR INTERIOR (past which the LIFE OF THE CITY moves along).

Collage implication in B's treatment of THE BARRICADE; B cites barricade metaphors like: 'broken irregular outlines, profiles of strange constructions' from Les Miserables.

PILE UP (BARRICADE) of figures as in THE MOVIES POSTER.

THE SMOKERS; THE PASSERBY; MEN ABOUT TOWN; RUMOUR and IDLENESS; THE COCOTTE IN HER DISGUISES; OCCASIONAL CONSPIRATORS; THE SWIFT GLANCE; GROWD AS REFUGE; CHANCE (as a guide through city life); PROSTITUTION (the life of the erotic person in the crowd); FETISHISM (as the 'vital nerve of fashion'); PROLETARIAT driven Out Of CENTRAL PARIS (title) leading to emergence of a RED BELT (margins of picture).

ANGEL OF HISTORY IDLE STROLLER face turned 'toward the past', blown backwards into the future by the storm of progress while the pile of ruins before him grows skyward (PILE UP of images).

MAN WITH HEARING AID ... THE POLICE SPY/ SECRET AGENT.

THE MAN WALKING AWAY ... B's suicide? (the flaneur's last journey: death ... 'to the depths of the unknown to find something new' from Flowers of Evil).

http://www.artchive.com/artchive/ftptoc/kitaj_ext.html

Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password

Display:
Is it a movie star? A music celeb ? The mayor?

The opacity of reality to vision - and the reassuring order of media reporting of political contacts across cultures - related to a thinking painter who enjoys ambiguities.

Cf.:


European photography Reggio Emilia 2007

Second edition  cities /europe

We need to find new imaginary elements in the opacity of reality, to sharpen our gaze to define the cities where we live and not to limit it to indicating a presumed, ready made European identity. It should touch the common element that is constructed in our open cities and that lets itself be captured by all those who want to penetrate it.

Photography embodies this gaze more than any other art. It plays an irreplaceable role in imagining or capturing a Europe that is abandoning old horizons and is being reborn in a new and different form.

Elio Grazioli

http://www.undo.net/cgi-bin/undo/pressrelease/pressrelease.pl?id=1177426415




Maybe it's because I'm a Londoner - that I moved to Nice. Blog - Nice Experience
by Ted Welch (tedwelch-at-mac-dot-com) on Sun Dec 2nd, 2007 at 03:11:51 PM EST
Thanks! A fascinating collage as if news bits were glanced-at parts of a promenade through a much larger context. Burrough's cut-up technique came to mind- and Walpole's Serendipity.

And then I was taken back to a hotel in Rue Monsieur le Prince, late Sixties, having a disorderly and entirely forgotten conversation with Brian Gysin.Come to think of it, more a morning-after monologue on his part.

by de Gondi (publiobestia aaaatttthotmaildaughtusual) on Mon Dec 3rd, 2007 at 04:41:32 PM EST
Thanks to you - nice to get some feedback :-) and that you understood.

Checking online, I see the relevance of your chat/his monologue

Brion Gysin (January 19, 1916 - July 13, 1986) was a painter, writer, sound poet, and performance artist born outside of London, Taplow, Buckinghamshire.[1]

He is best known for his rediscovery of Tristan Tzara's cut-up technique and its influence on the work of William S. Burroughs, calligraphic paintings inspired by Japanese and Arabic script, and for co-inventing the Dreamachine, a flicker device.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brion_Gysin




Maybe it's because I'm a Londoner - that I moved to Nice. Blog - Nice Experience
by Ted Welch (tedwelch-at-mac-dot-com) on Mon Dec 3rd, 2007 at 06:49:33 PM EST
[ Parent ]
There are two quotes from Gysin at the link that might fit into the panorama:

"Writing is fifty years behind painting."

"Language is an abominable misunderstanding which makes up a part of matter. The painters and the physicists have treated matter pretty well. The poets have hardly touched it. In March 1958, when I was living at the Beat Hotel, I proposed to Burroughs to at least make available to literature the means that painters have been using for fifty years. Cut words into pieces and scramble them. You'll hear someone draw a bow-string. Who runs may read, To read better, practice your running. Speed is entirely up to us, since machines have delivered us from the horse. Henceforth the question is to deliver us from that other so-called superior animal, man. It's not worth it to chase out the merchants: their temple is dedicated to the unsuitable lie of the value of the Unique. The crime of separation gave birth to the idea of the Unique which would not be separate. In painting, matter has seen everything: from sand to stuffed goats. Disfigured more and more, the image has been geometrically multiplied to a dizzying degree. A snow of advertising could fall from the sky, and only collector babies and the chimpanzees who make abstract paintings would bother to pick one up."
- Cut-Ups: A Project for Disastrous Success

I've done a little remembrance of things past, savoured that period of my life. It was either in 1970 or 1971. Gysin lodged then in rue M. le Prince, in a hotel as always. I can't remember much of what was said. The impression is morning and a young woman standing naked on a table, which I'm afraid clouds everything else out.

by de Gondi (publiobestia aaaatttthotmaildaughtusual) on Tue Dec 4th, 2007 at 04:39:13 AM EST
[ Parent ]

I've done a little remembrance of things past, savoured that period of my life.

Funny you should say that - I've just been reading: "How Proust can change your life" Alain De Botton - very interesting. Thanks to the internet the real thing is available online.

Regarding the approach - there's also surrealism - which links to the above coincidence :-)


They rejected Futurism, preferring the Metaphysical painters, especially the haunting enigmas of Giorgio de Chirico (b 1888).

Andre Breton's phrase 'pure psychic automatism' was intended to apply to the process of writing and Breton even gave practical hints on how to do it. In 1930 he published his second Manifeste du surréalisme in which he defined 'surreality' as the reconciliation of the reality of dreams with the reality of everyday life into a higher synthesis.

Underlying the interest in automatism and dream lay the Surrealist notion of what was called 'objective chance'. They believed that the existence of coincidences (events for which there were no rational explanations) was evidence and that true reality was not ordered or logical. Access to reality could only be gained through the unconscious mind.

http://www.artchive.com/artchive/surrealism.html

Though generally I'm very rationalist, but it's good to  sometimes remember that much still escapes our reason and we too easily accept reasons which are later shown to be mistaken.

Maybe it's because I'm a Londoner - that I moved to Nice. Blog - Nice Experience

by Ted Welch (tedwelch-at-mac-dot-com) on Tue Dec 4th, 2007 at 07:22:18 AM EST
[ Parent ]
I think we'll end up in a conceptual hornet's nest. I suppose all creatures organize "reality" to eek out significance to their identity and survival. We humans after all do not see ultraviolet naturally as certain fish do. The ultraviolet isn't essential to our survival, although nothing excludes it having become part of our perceptual baggage.

Our slight difference with other organisms is language which does get in the way of perceiving exactly that which language suggests or enables us to be aware of.

I really can't perceive of "realities" beyond us or that some sort of "unconscious" mind may have "access" to "it." It's all there for the grabs. Tying it down and trying to communicate it to others is the crux of the problem. So we have the arts and the farther reaches of science to suggest- to re-mind us of- the ineffable, the stochastic, the ordinary chaos from which we distill meaning.

by de Gondi (publiobestia aaaatttthotmaildaughtusual) on Tue Dec 4th, 2007 at 08:18:57 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Our exchange drove me to re-read Hannah Arendt's articles on her friend Walter Benjamin (Men in Dark Times). Her prose evokes endearing images of a clumsy man who jokingly considered himself persecuted by the "hunchback," a German childhood figure. Once he had interiorized this figure he developed into one of the most revolutionary thinkers of his time. His idea of fragmentation of reality seems to come from broken vases as he bumped into them, just as Dostoevsky's Prince Myshkin. And his cautious way of walking led him to embrace Baudelaire's flaneur, transforming the flaneur into a modern archetype.

It comes as no surprise that Benjamin translated Proust into German.

My daughter gave me De Botton's book as a birthday gift when it came out. I enjoyed it, especially Proust's fascination with crime and trashy periodicals. Another delightful aspect of Proust's character was to write two versions of a review or a letter- one in which he confided to posterity what he really thought while publishing or sending a perfectly false version of his judgements or sentiments.

by de Gondi (publiobestia aaaatttthotmaildaughtusual) on Mon Dec 10th, 2007 at 08:35:44 AM EST
[ Parent ]
European Tribune - What is it?
Also, in the margins of the above, a gathering was held of opponents to the high speed line: Lyon-Turin.
Because making it easier to cross the Alps is a bad, bad idea.

We have met the enemy, and he is us — Pogo
by Migeru (migeru at eurotrib dot com) on Mon Dec 10th, 2007 at 06:42:56 AM EST
Well... crossing the Pyrenees drove Benjamin to suicide.
by de Gondi (publiobestia aaaatttthotmaildaughtusual) on Mon Dec 10th, 2007 at 08:36:48 AM EST
[ Parent ]


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]