European Tribune

Dumping out the garbage: US sheriff `wheelchair dumper' criminally charged

by euamerican
Sun Feb 17th, 2008 at 03:36:24 PM EST

YouTube video: Police Caught Throwing Paralyzed Man From Wheelchair

Articles from BBC News:

US police 'dumped paralysed man'

US wheelchair-dump deputy charged

It's my impression that Europeans and the rest of the world seem to think that police abuse is limited to just American minorities in the South. Nope! It is my impression that police abuse by American police is increasing and becoming more wide spread. Also, understanding abusive practice in American prisons and jails leads to a full grasp of the abuse at Abu Ghraib.

There is now the infamous and reveling case of a Brian Sterner, a wheelchair-bound man in Florida who was dumped on his face by and a calm Hillsborough County Sheriff's Deputy (Tampa), and then frisked on the floor. Deputy Charlette Marshall-Jones' hands then slid along the body of the helpless man, the helpless man's belongings were tossed to the counter in an angry fashion. The "dumping" and dehumanizing frisk on the floor were apparently triggered because Mr. Stener "refused" to "stand up."

Mr Sterner said that when he arrived in the booking office the officers told him to stand up, but he was unable to do so. According to an interview he gave to the Tampa Tribune newspaper, Mr Sterner said that Dep Jones "was irked that I wasn't complying to what she was telling me to do".


"It didn't register with her that she was asking me to do something I can't do."


At the root of the problem here, as with abuse by government officials, is the dehumanization of the person. The report from Mr. Sterner and the video tape indicate that there was no concern with the basic human dignity and that Mr. Sterner was regarded as "garbage to be dumped out of a wheelchair." In the moments prior to his dumping, Mr. Sterner's statements that he cannot stand up due to his disability where automatically taken as fabrications. After all, you cannot believe anything from a filthy dirtbag traffic offender, right?

The dehumanization the leads to police abuse in American policing appears to be accompanied by extreme cynicism toward the "innocent until proven guilty" criminal suspect, who is reduced to "garbage." As with other violations of human rights by police authorities in other parts of the world, the victims need to be dehumanized so abuse against the victim can occur.

As you can see from the video, America is nothing special when it comes to "celebrating human rights," or abusing human rights.


The abuses that the world saw at Abu Ghraib simply did not come out of thin air. The abusive practices at Abu Ghraib were probably born and nurtured in the American prison and jail system. At least one of the prison guards that was involved in the abuses at Abu Ghraib worked in the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections.
See: The Implications of Abu Ghraib for the American Prison System- Martin F. Horn -Vera Institute of Justice. June 22, 2004
Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password

Display:
Note where the incident occurred-in a police station.  A number of police officers are present.   Regardless, the wheelchair bound individual was dumped onto the floor.   The deputy did not hesitate even with witnesses present.  Apparently, none of the other police present confronted the deputy on the spot for brutality.  Obviously, the deputy had no fear of consequences for his actions.  That a deputy would dump somebody out of a wheelchair in public is very damning.

Something is deeply dysfunctional at that Florida police station.

But I wonder if this action was an isolated incident or reflective of a systemic problem throughout American police departments nationwide.  For every video of an incident such as this, how many others are not available on video?

In a healthy democracy, citizens should not be afraid of their police.  Unfortunately, the video reflects a disrespect for a presumed innocent citizen and a willingness to use casual violence without compunction on a non-violent detainee.  This video suggests that citizens should be afraid of the police.

The police are supposed to serve the public.  Somewhere along the line, this deputy has either forgotten or never knew the role of police within society.  The deputy will be punished because of the video but will his superior officers suffer as well?  Are not his superiors responsible for the actions of their personnel?

Is the relationship between the police force and citizens dysfunctional in American?  Is the video a small example of a systemic problem throughout American police forces or just an isolated incident?

by Jagger on Mon Feb 18th, 2008 at 02:27:51 AM EST
relationship between the police force and citizens dysfunctional in American?    

The worst stories come out of Florida, as this one does.  

But yes, step by step, it is going bad everywhere in North America--and that includes Canada, too.  

In both the US and Canada police misbehavior is being encouraged by the highest levels of the executive, with the enablement of the highest judges.  

Total corruption is setting in.  

by Gaianne on Tue Feb 19th, 2008 at 02:37:48 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Yes,I subscribe to the idea that policing in a democracy means the up most respect for citizens, including criminal suspects and those who are part of a class that you find offensive (homeless, gays, mentally ill). For the most part, police are good in their relationship with people. Policing in a democracy is a hard job.

I lived in Florida from 10 years, half of that in the Tampa Bay area. The perspective down their in very much unlike other parts of the US and more like a despotic third world nation.

I know about the RCMP and it's really sad.

by euamerican on Tue Feb 19th, 2008 at 09:48:03 AM EST
[ Parent ]
It starts with the militarisation of the police, which has been ongoing since the early 1970s. US Police routinely refer to the population as "civilians"--and that's one of the more civil terms they use. There are far more contemptuous labels for members of the public out there, such as "NHI": "No Humans Involved." This one's employed by bad cops when someone the police see as "inhuman" (black, immigrant, poor, disabled, mentally ill, a prostitute) is the victim of crime. And it means that crime won't be investigated.
I would like to think that "bad cops" are in the minority, but my experience with American police, and that of my friends, indicates otherwise. A close friend of mine was literally beaten to a pulp by two cops, then brought up on trumped-up and politically motivated charges, with false data passed to the news media. He eventually got justice in the courts but it was slow. He was unarmed, did not attempt to defend himself--and was a maths major who weighed about 100 pounds. My husband has seen police use a billy club to break the skull of a medic (clearly uniformed as such) near a demonstration, break the arm of a child, and walk police horses across demonstrators who had lain down in a street, all on one day. I could go on and on. As for common criminals, I watched many horrific interactions between police and suspects (can't say whether they were guilty of any crime) whilst living in Black neighbourhoods in the US. Force was routinely used, guns were usually drawn as well. My neighbour's son, a nice, non-criminal University student visiting on the holidays, was almost killed when police shot up his car, having mistaken him for a crime suspect. In the same city, there have been at least three killings of unarmed mentally ill people by police in recent years.
As a result, I had a really hard time learning that police could at times actually be helpful and considerate, after moving to the UK.
by expatyank on Mon Feb 18th, 2008 at 03:35:12 AM EST
Bad cops are in the minority in most places I've been.  It depends on where you are.  But you make a very good point about the militarization of police forces here, with all the talk of "civilians" and the like.  Cops are essentially poorly-trained soldiers, at least until you get into the elite units or the detective work.

My experience with UK cops wasn't spectacular, though.  (Stories of them beating the shit out of people for very little reason were not uncommon in Notts.  And they generally behaved like assholes whenever I asked them for help with directions or something along those lines.)  They're less frightening than American cops, of course, mainly because (1) they don't have guns and (2) they're less intimidating in terms of size and strength than American cops.

Where's your motherf*%&ing flag pin?

by Drew J Jones (blahblahblah@blahblahblah.com) on Mon Feb 18th, 2008 at 08:28:40 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Professor Darius Rejali about police and torture:
The basic idea here is that soldiers who get ahead torturing come back and take jobs as policemen, and private security, and they get ahead doing the same things they did in the army. And so torture comes home. Everyone knows waterboarding, but no one remembers that it was American soldiers coming back from the Philippines that introduced it to police in the early twentieth century.

Via A Tiny Revolution

The plural of anecdote is bullshit.

by generic on Tue Feb 19th, 2008 at 07:28:28 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Yep - that's exactly what they do here in America. Soldiers, especially military police, return to civilian life and enter policing or become a prison guard.
sometimes they become a police officer AND join the National Guard or Reserves.

It was not a shock when I learned that the abusers of Iraqi detainees were prison guards in civilian life.

by euamerican on Wed Feb 20th, 2008 at 01:58:10 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Hillsborough County sheriffs.  Of course.  More proof of why no one in their right mind should ever live in a hole like Tampon Bay.  If you want proper white-trash, racist, brutal cops, western Florida is the place to be.  They'll make the LAPD's antics look like child's play.

Sheriffs are a whole different ballgame from cops in America, too.  They're generally rednecks, and much meaner and more drunk with power.

Where's your motherf*%&ing flag pin?

by Drew J Jones (blahblahblah@blahblahblah.com) on Mon Feb 18th, 2008 at 08:33:18 AM EST


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]