European Tribune

Kosovo Independence and Press Freedom in Russia

by Kyle Atwell
Sat Feb 23rd, 2008 at 01:34:21 PM EST

This article was originally published by Kyle Atwell at the Atlantic Review, a website providing news updates and commentary covering transatlantic relations.

The Moscow News Weekly has published an article on Kosovo's declaration of independence, which from its tone I assumed was in the "Comment/Opinions" section.  However, it turns out it was actually in the "World News" section.  Here is a snippet:

While burning KFOR checkpoints may not be the best of ways for Kosovo's ethnic Serbian minority to express its anxiety and anger over recent events, global democratic leaders should think twice before voting to award a chair to Kosovo on New York's East River. In the Basque country, Quebec, Belgium, northern Cyprus, Georgia and many other places across the globe, they have TV sets, too, and are watching. Telling them Kosovo is different and unique won't work. That's the price you pay for being a hypocrite, I guess.

Not to say western newspapers are completely objective, but at least you can read multiple perspectives on a story on this side of the Urals, without worrying about whether your favorite columnist may mysteriously die one day.

Of course this is only one article in one newspaper; it may not be fair to judge the entire Russian media based on this article alone. To get a better idea of press freedom trends globally and by country, you can check out an annual report produced by Freedom House titled "Freedom of the Press."  The 2007 version reported this for Russia:

Media freedom in Russia continued to be curtailed in 2006 as President Vladimir Putin's government passed legislation restricting news reporting and journalists were subjected to physical violence and intimidation. Although the constitution provides for freedom of speech and of the press, authorities are able to use the legislative and judicial systems to harass and prosecute independent journalists.


Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password

Display:
Even a minimum amount of research into Freedom House, say reading the wikipedia entry, indicates that this organisation is not without its critics (including Noam Chomsky), and receives 75% of its budget from the US government. Thus we may question how 'objective' its ranking in fact is. To say that western newspapers are not completely objective is putting it mildly. Of course, we do not do anything as crass as physically assault journalists for what they write. Why would we, when the model whereby media ownership is concentrated in the hands of a financial elite can so effectively limit the scope of the debate, and restrict the multiple perspectives to within acceptable bounds such that the status quo is never really challenged?

Not to say that I believe the Russian press to be free. And 'western' media is probably in somewhat better shape. But I wouldn't take Freedom House's assessment as anything other than the opinions of a mouthpiece of American hegemony.

by someone (s0me1smail(a)gmail(d)com) on Sat Feb 23rd, 2008 at 03:31:49 PM EST
I'd like to respond in depth to this, but my brain just exploded after reading it.  Fortunately, the Internets are full of resources you can take a gander at while I put my head back together...  

Some good places to start
http://www.exile.ru/articles/detail.php?ARTICLE_ID=8000&IBLOCK_ID=35&phrase_id=2044
http://fkriuk.blogspot.com/index.html
http://seansrussiablog.org/2007/07/03/cis-most-dangerous-for-journalists-if-you-leave-out-war-zones/

And after you've familiarized yourself with Freedom House and freedom of the press in Russia (lack of which is in fact mostly limited to the TV) you can go on to explain how recognizing Kosovo's independence does not require some hypocrisy.  Because I'm frankly not sure what the point of this diary is, or what facts have been presented to make it.  


"This is nothing compared to how Putin rigged Eurovision."

by poemless on Mon Feb 25th, 2008 at 02:08:05 PM EST


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]