For A Lark: Streetwise Failure

by Nomad
Sun May 11th, 2008 at 03:28:08 PM EST

Last year, I set out a list of development goals I wanted to achieve or look into their potential. These were:

Continue and develop education program for high school students from Alexander Townswhip with the aim to get them to pass matriculation exams and put them into university.

Investigate the extent and/or develop a program for Street Outreach for street kids.

Investigate the extent and/or develop a (local) program of Food Banks for the poor, especially children.

Investigate and where able adopt the practicalities of living carbon neutral in South Africa - minus the car which remains (sad to say) an inherent necessity.

Investigate possibilities of creating a more comprehensive and modern Direct Aid scheme.

Report and rely on feedback from a familiar internet community...

Some six months later, I need to conclude that my second aim, development of Street Outreach, has failed totally.


It started, as so many of these things happen, by fortune and the fact that the absence of a car exposed me better to the street life in Johannesburg compared to many others. The area where I was living, and am now living again, is a middle class area, located nearby a main street (called, without inspiration, Main Street), which hosts two shopping areas, a string of bars, a McDonalds and a KFC. It's an important thorough fare, and is also an assembly point and hang-out place, especially during the weekends. That makes it the ideal space for street kids to score their buck and other stuff. A large group of these children derives from the more poorly developed Sophiatown neighbourhood, a few kilometres further west. Most kids walk back and forth every day and they have seemingly established a highly competitive - and sometimes aggressive - rotation system for favourite junctions.

One particular place is the exits of the MacDonalds and the KFC across the street. Another at the junction nearby a major shopping area which I pass on a daily basis to get my minibus-taxis. During winter last year, children would drift a little further and assemble at the corners of 7th street in Melville - an aorta of bars, restaurants, hostels and other assorted shops, a backpacker and student mecca.

Passing these nodes frequently last year - either when I'd been walking, or when I'd been making use of the public transport - I soon was familiarized with some of the faces of the streets kids that asked me for money.

Shain was one of the more haunting ones. When I shook his hand, the second thing that struck me was how callous it was. The first thing that had struck me was the misty blue of his left eye - blind. He had never finished matric (secondary education) but he seemed to know exactly what he wanted: back to school and finish his education in making furniture. He said he enjoyed using his hands to create. I asked him what had made him drop out, why he was standing in front of the MacDonalds asking money of strangers. A confused story followed - the man his mother was dating had gone away and put them on the street. The money for his schooling got eroded away for food and housing, his mother had no job. Shain, some 15 years now, was the oldest man - and in Africa that makes him important; it makes him the head of the family and responsible for income.

Then there was Thomas. Unkempt, with a dirty hat on greasy hair, he'd hang out at the main junction at Main Street. He doesn't really know his age - he's about ten, the other kids think. Despite his appearance of docility, one day I watched from a distance how he chased off a competitor (a white guy) by threatening to throw a brick while shouting vile insults. That streak of aggression was rather revealing; I'd not confront it with him later on.

My principal philosophy to which I strictly adhere to this day is simple: I do not give money, period. Thomas was inventive enough to catch on - the money he needed was for food, so couldn't I give food instead? For a while I made sure to bring a piece of fruit every day, or some bread on another day. At the end of last year, things had gone dire enough he braved to ask if, instead of one piece per day, I could do bulk shopping instead. I had a university car that day, so we bought basic food stuff in the supermarket, a total of some 90 Rand (then about 9 Euros), and I dropped him and another kid at the place where he lived: a dilapidated multi-floored brick hostel, a flock of children on bare feet playing in front. After another month, in December, he'd ask again.

But it nagged. It wasn't sustainable what I was doing. Those kids didn't get education. They were not working for a future - they were clinging on, surviving.

So my first attempt was to look for people who did outreach, similar to whataboutbob described with his Tanzanian 50% campaign. First the Internet. But there was very little to be found for Johannesburg which could immediately be slotted with my aims. I've cut out all the links, and the contacts I've found so far, it doesn't make much of a great story. The best initiative I found was Twilight Children, whose goals have been outlined here:

Twilight Children

To initially make contact with the street children of Johannesburg through the Outreach Programme and to provide them with a shelter and a place of refuge. Thereafter to encourage their participation in the Twilight Children Programme which has been established in Hillbrow, Johannesburg since 1983.

To determine the boy's family circumstances and to encourage him to return to the care of family or guardian where possible and to provide counseling to such family or guardian if necessary.

But Twilight Children operate in Hillbrow - and although this is an area where a project of such scope is indeed direly needed, the Melville and Sophiatown areas are literally kilometres away from Hillbrow and inaccessible for street kids living in Sophiatown. Johannesburg needs more of these nodes.

I visited a shelter for street children in a nearby area, set up by Father Laslo Karpati, who began the Yithubalami project - but now race became an issue. Yithubalami refuses to shelter children who are perceived as Coloureds. Now Coloureds was a linguistic headache, a juridical farce under apartheid, despite the multitude of farces in that time. A collective basket of anyone who'd not be immediately classifiable as Asian, White or Black - the Coloureds represented all kinds of intermingling cultures, from Lebanese to the Malaysian influx to the descendants of cultural mixing. Under apartheid, the divisionary line who'd be considered "more black" could run straight through families.

As it appears to me, Coloureds voted in 1994 overwhelmingly for the National Party - the party that had always oppressed them - while shunning the ANC. Although I only have anecdotal observations, this has aggravated a "racial" division still existing today. As an ethnic(?) group they are now caught between a rock and a hard place.  

Although I fully support the Yithubalami initiative, I got queasy with the apparent ethnic division - although I never spoke with Karpati personally, I was told "Coloureds" were no longer welcome after several "incidents" - from what I could read between the lines, this meant occasions of theft and fighting. Anyway, I also get very queasy when religion is so blatantly printed on their badges of honour - something that is beginning to frustrate me here to no end. Rich African people are mind-numbingly oblivious for the most abject poverty living cheek to cheek in their world, or when they are there standing on the breach, 9.5 out of 10 is absorbed in Christian do-goodiness.

Still, it was about finding the right people while the clock was ticking. It's too late now.

I left in December for the Netherlands, still building out my plans - trying to get free out-of-shelf date food from the supermarkets, incorporate the political representative of the area, finding new projects already active nearby. I had given Thomas a final stash of foodware, had organised some clothing, given my old pair of shoes to Shaun - but already he was telling me that with increasing food prices his family's situation was getting increasingly dire. I said I could only help him again in the next year and told him to hold on. I remember him biting his lip and saying, "Yes boss" (which I detest).

When I came back living here, early March, I found everything in shambles. I met a new guy, Ricardo, 26 years old but looking 35, HIV positive (and Coloured), who seemed now in control of the junction at Main Street. I asked about Shain, Thomas, Lucky, the others. Jail. All of them. Shain had attempted breaking and entering shortly after I left in December and had been dragged off by the police. With one of the more stabilising factors gone, the network of which Shain had been part had collapsed - all of them had begun stealing, and had been caught. Perhaps even purposefully - because one is at least guaranteed of food in jail. But I knew I had lost them. Even worse was to come: I learned that in January a restaurant owner in Melville's 7th street was arrested on charges of sexually molesting children, street children. I felt my heart rip: it was the corner where, among others, Thomas would frequently hang out.

I tried to pick up some new things with Ricardo - because there are always more people on the street, always others who flock in. As long as they want to work, as long as they express they want to get out, I'm willing to see what can be done. I tried with Ricardo, who wept openly when one day I brought back 50 Rand of foodware from the supermarket, but my attempts had become half-heartedly. I feared Ricardo would be too old, he's been on the street since he was 12. He carries the marks of street fighting, his front teeth are missing.

The final straw was two weekends ago, a long holiday weekend in SA. I came back from the laundrette and passed the corner that is now Ricardo's hangout.

He was sprawled half over the pavement, half over the street, lost in a stupor of alcohol. The next day, I learned he'd been arrested for public drunkenness.

Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password
-->
Display:
Too few happy endings lately.

The core of evil is a lack of empathy
by Nomad on Sun May 11th, 2008 at 03:32:08 PM EST
It sure seems so. Lately I have been wondering if there is really progress or if it is not a timewise illusion. Where ever one looks it seems to move back- and downwards.
by Fran (fran at eurotrib dot com) on Sun May 11th, 2008 at 03:44:03 PM EST
[ Parent ]
I admire your efforts - it's a pity you couldn't get more support.

Maybe it's because I'm a Londoner - that I moved to Nice. Blog - Nice Experience
by Ted Welch (tedwelch-at-mac-dot-com) on Sun May 11th, 2008 at 05:14:31 PM EST
[ Parent ]
I live in a house where 4 out of 5 inhabitants are deeply involved with volunteering projects - projects that suck up spare time for everyone. Had I not been involved in other projects, had they not been dedicated to other projects - I may have been able to organise more. But all  interested to aid are already occupied, and one must take great care to not suffer from burnout in this country. I learned my lesson: a street outreach programme needs constant dedication and attention to be built up, it can't be done just on the fly by people occupied most of the time with other stuff.

Would I want to try again? Very much so. Would I do it differently? Very much so. Do I, or others with me, have the time (or money) for that different approach? Unfortunately not.

The core of evil is a lack of empathy

by Nomad on Mon May 12th, 2008 at 09:59:26 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Luckily my idealism was tied up with my own interests and pleasure - in learning, using media, politics and passing things on through my teaching. But in becoming a bit of a workaholic, my own social life did tend to suffer and that can be depressing, so has an effect on  one's work.  So I agree with your  point about avoiding burnout - trying to personally compensate for failings in social systems can be very demoralizing.  

Now, I feel I've done my bit for others and am focusing more (a bit belatedly) on  enjoying life. But I still tend to get spend too much time online - as summed up in that cartoon someone put in an open thread about the guy who couldn't go to bed yet because "There is someone who is wrong on the internet"  :-) Don't exhaust yourself because there's something wrong with society.

Maybe it's because I'm a Londoner - that I moved to Nice. Blog - Nice Experience

by Ted Welch (tedwelch-at-mac-dot-com) on Mon May 12th, 2008 at 12:04:59 PM EST
[ Parent ]
It´s really heartbreaking to see so much risk and effort not seeming to work, for now, BUT

You dared and you did it and IT WAS GOOD!  Those boys, early men, cannot forget now that ´there are caring people in this world´!  At some level you had an impact on them and it was positive, even if you could not save them.

Everyone leaves a mark on others and especially those that break through patterns, like you, so you cannot call ´failure´ doing your part and doing it well, when it´s really the duty of an entire  organization/country.  

Please, please, give yourself a treat and many pats on the back!!!  Now I´m going to have a good cry, because taking on ´too damm much´ is my middle name...

_Our knowledge has surpassed our wisdom. --Charu Saxena._

by metavision on Sun May 11th, 2008 at 06:14:57 PM EST
you, my friend, are a card...

heartbreaking diary, i can so relate...well done for trying. as m-vision said, you did more than you think, and i agree with her that those kids got a message from your example that will be important to them in later life.

what a pit you describe so well, and such a pity....

Lobbyists are people too...

by melo (melometa4(at)gmail.com) on Sun May 11th, 2008 at 07:24:51 PM EST
What are the ANC doing about this ? S Africa is not a poor country so how come this situation has come into being ?

Yea, I know M'beki is incompetent and running a dog-pound is obviously beyond him, let alone a country. But why aren't the rest of the leadership up in arms ? what is this solidarity with failure ?

I appreciate that it is heart-breaking to see so much need surrounding you and feel helpless, but the solution to this really lies in government hands

keep to the Fen Causeway

by Helen (lareinagal at yahoo dot co dot uk) on Mon May 12th, 2008 at 10:53:55 AM EST
It's very hard for me to answer these questions and not trip into very generalized (and therefore wrong) descriptions how I view the current state of government at this point.

Let's just say that I find the governmental ANC track record bizarrely schizophrenic. They have done, and do, some things exceptionally well, and are sometimes unable to sell the message; on the other hand, some departments have been, to my impression, catastrophically inept and have still not been able to get their act together. Graft is always threatening. Yet, although it not being an excuse - what has been done with the bureaucratic and administrative re-alignment in the past 14 years is nothing short of miraculous. Going on a limb, I would say it's unparalleled in the world - to take the heritage from apartheid and create nine semi-autonomous provinces under one republic state structure.

Mbeki, however, has over the past year proven himself an increasing disappointment to me. He has done tremendous work for the country, but he's become an autocratic fossil, cramped by his own style and the mistakes he just cannot admit to have made and it's undoing his entire legacy. This is exactly the reason why Jacob Zuma is now leading the ANC and why there is an open revolt in the party. There is revolt in Mbeki's own government - with powerful ministers overruling some of Mbeki's more lax approaches. The Chinese ship with a cargo of weapons for Zim is case in point - Mbeki kept silent on it, and it would've allowed the unloading of those weapons on the shore - but ministers ordered the confiscation of the containers, in the spirit of the workers who refused to unload the ship.

The core of evil is a lack of empathy

by Nomad on Mon May 12th, 2008 at 03:15:48 PM EST
[ Parent ]
for title names:

Excellent Example
Most Outstanding Effort

or, at the very least,

Partial Success
....

_Our knowledge has surpassed our wisdom. --Charu Saxena._

by metavision on Mon May 12th, 2008 at 10:58:30 AM EST


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]