|
by Jerome a Paris
Usually, I ignore editorial in papers - it's usually the microwaved edition of stale conventional wisdom. But lately, it's become quite fascinating, as the pundit class tries to process the financial crisis, energy prices or dollar weakness (in other words, grappling with Anglo Disease, Countdown Oil or Europe. Is. Doomed syndromes).
This week-end, the FT has it all, with a new name for the Anglo Disease (the nasty decade), concern trolling for the euro (The euro's success could also be its downfall - to be fair, this is an Op-Ed, not an editorial), and German envy (Germany through the looking glass). That last article deserves a detailed commentary follow me below the fold. A proud member of the Europe.Is.Doomed series.
Hmmm:
In case there was any ambiguity here:
A quick look at EU statistics tells me that the UK has a 23bn trade deficit, while France had a 10bn trade deficit - it's fascinating to learn these days how the French economy is similar to the UK one - not just its trade deficit (ignoring any tourism surplus/deficit), but its budget deficit (ignoring its position relative to the 3% Maastricht limit) or its housing bubble (ignoring banks's recklessness) are now regularly compared to the UK's - I'm sure this has nohing to do with the fact that these look bad, and that misery loves company. Heck, even France's and UK's GDP are comparable these days... Anyway, Germany looks good compared to France, thus one of the big eurozone economies looks bad and all is well.
It's cyclical, it's linked to "special factors", it's just a catch up. What's clear is that these good numbers do not reflect any underlying reality.
Hmmm. Let's look at recent numbers, from the already quoted EU trade numbers
(in EUR bn)
Eurozone imports, Feb. 2007: 116.9 And that's with the euro going from roughly 1.30 to the dollar in February last year to 1.47 in February this year. The "headwinds" have been announced for over a year (and before that, Germany was going to suffer from the VAT increase in early 2007 - remember how that particular decision, which made it possible for Germany to have a budget surplus last year, was seen as a horrible thing back then?). And yet, here we are, a year later, with new euro records - and new export records. It has to be unsustainable.
Ah, I see - it's not reform that cut wages that are the cause for lower spending power - it's high fuel prices. How conveeeeenient. And businesses are the good guys, see: despite the "turbulence", they have been willing to hire people in record numbers. See how nice they are - it has nothing to do with crushed wages and record demand, promise, it's only "reform" in action as promised.
See how open minded we are: we're perfectly willing to praise a leftwing government (as long as it does neoliberal policies). And how consistent we are: anything good that happens is thanks to "reform", and anything bad that happens (or threatens to happen, if only in our vivid imaginations), is aused by the lack thereof. |
Menu
. Home
. About . Contact . New User Guide . FAQ . Search . Search (Google) . Archives (Wiki) Art, Economics, Energy, Environment, EU Politics, Mech & Tech, By Country Login
|
||
|
Europe.Is.Doomed (6) - 'impressive' German economy needs (what else) "reform" | 26 comments (26 topical, 0 editorial, 0 hidden)
Europe.Is.Doomed (6) - 'impressive' German economy needs (what else) "reform" | 26 comments (26 topical, 0 editorial, 0 hidden)
| ||||
| ||||