European Tribune

LQD Velvet Fascism, Italian Style

by melo
Sat Aug 16th, 2008 at 09:48:08 AM EST

It's a slippery road, and someone is afraid of how the Italian people, already squealing at rising food costs, energy prices, deaths in the workplace and worry over globalisation's ambiguous benefits, will react.

The anti-Rom gestures, while repulsive, were merely that, there are too many for such grandstanding sallies to make more than a small dent in, it's a dogwhistle to all thuggish types that their attitudes are in season,  primordial spasms of hatred given a target.

  Below this level of mediated hate-whipping, there is a concern Italian excitability may erupt into social unrest, specifically targeted against 'la Casta', those pampered courtiers to the status quo, whose machinations are being increasingly exposed by citizen journalism, and criticised by law'n'order types like Antonio di Pietro, whose magisterial career ripped the lid off many a shady set-up in the early 90's.

With the fearless French strikers showing the way to confront governments just to the north, it's possible that we may be nearing a flashpoint here, not in the Red Brigade sense, thankfully, but probably millions 'in piazza', bills in their hands, looking for change that will help them deal with the inflation that has held back economic growth predictions to 0% for the coming year.

Promoted by Colman


I know it's not much better elsewhere in Europe, but my gut says it might be Italy where the combination of global economic downturn and corrupt, incompetent, out-of-touch leadership will kindle the tinder, break the camel's back.

With all the surveillance, surely the authorities know much more than we in the public do about the simmering levels of tension below the already grumbling and accusatory voices that are starting to get more national attention.

Italy has five different police forces, and now this:

Beppe Grillo's Blog

This letter, sent in to us by a Police Services trade union representative, should make us worry, and very much so at that. At the start of this current legislature, Police Chief Manganelli made a speech in parliament, wherein he denounced the current state of affairs as regards the Justice system. What he said, in effect, is that while the Country's policemen regularly risk their necks, the criminals are released early and, in fact, often avoid jail altogether. Manganelli was simply ignored. Just as Judge Bruno Tinti stated in "Toghe Rotte" (Broken Togas), 95% of all crimes go unpunished, thanks to certain laws created by Berlusconi, which were designed specifically to protect himself and his henchmen. What is also true, however, is that the centre-left also did its part by approving the 2006 pardon, an action that was necessary. Just as all cats are grey in the dark, corrupt public servants belong to all of the parties. While the Police Forces are being lambasted, the Army is replacing them on the streets. There are currently some 6,000 soldiers on the beat, but this number could well rise as high as 60,000. Three billion Euro cut from the Police budget (a Mafia-style warning perhaps) and a justice system that is being held on a short leash. They are preparing themselves for the possibility of another Argentina.

"Dear Beppe,

The position taken by the COISP (Police Forces Trade Union Independent Co-ordination Committee) as regards many of the initiatives introduced by the current Government has been extremely critical, because these initiatives are contrary to the both our Constitution and common sense!

We do not agree with the use of the military in order to ensure law and order and public safety. We are also against certain provisions that smack of "racism", as we are against the introduction of the position of the mayor-sheriff, against a number of private, self-protection provisions, such as the vigilante patrols and absolutely against the unjustified and absurd cuts that have been made in the area of law and order. We are talking about three billion Euro in cuts! In addition, those cuts have come precisely at a time that is particularly disastrous for the Police Forces.

I feel obliged to point out that all, and I repeat ALL of the representative trade unions within the security and defence sector took part in a demonstration in front of the offices of the Italian Prefecture, while handing out fliers informing citizens about the absurdities being perpetrated by the current Government. These brutalities clearly also fly in the face of certain of the election promises made by the centre-right alliance during the period leading up to the last elections. Quite obviously the national television stations failed to give us adequate coverage or, for that matter, appropriate interest. In the interests of fairness, it must be said that only the local press and television stations gave the matter fair coverage.

At this moment in time we are busy deciding on what action needs to be taken. What remains firm, however, is the principle that, while we are deciding on the form of the next demonstration, we will continue in our efforts to keep the situation in the public view as regards the incoherent and contradictory nature of these state promulgated provisions.

Above all else, we must continue to energetically denounce this latest decree, namely the so-called "anti-layabout" provision, which has resulted in us being heavily penalised when compared to all of the other public institutions. The regulation provides that any Police Force employees who are ill must accept a 20 Euro per day salary deduction for the first ten days of sick leave (taking only the employee's basic pay into account). This confusing provision also stipulates that the rule should not be applied in the case of employees that are off work due to work-related illness or injury on duty. The problem here is that "work-related" status may only be granted perhaps even six or seven years after the event. Meanwhile, the salary deduction is applied and stands firm. The legislator is obviously oblivious to the fact that you have mortgage payments to make, that you have a wife and kids to support, that you have car payments to make and that you have taxes to pay and costs to carry, just like any other person living on this planet. Minister Brunetta, the architect of this havoc, has exploited the general public's legitimate disapproval as regards certain types of absenteeism and has decided to use this to justify the adoption of a provision that is patently punitive and discriminatory against all public servants and even more so, as I stated earlier, against members of the Police Forces.

Our Council was pleased to note and express its heartfelt appreciation to Dr. Di Pietro for his strenuous and tenacious defence of the members of the forces of law and order! Furthermore, we were equally pleased to note your stand, as expressed in the national press, where you rightly scoffed at the demagogic and hypocritical provision in question, namely, the deployment of soldiers in our towns.

I wish to thank you once again." Fausto Fanelli -Member of the National Executive of the COISP.

  I think this show of force is pro-active, and the police violence against people protesting the ramp up of Italy's role as chief jumping off point in Europe for the U.S.A'S military 'readiness', and the forcing of dioxin-spewing incinerators onto poor neighbourhoods where cancer rates are already outstripping the national averages, are a telling foretaste of this diseased mentality.

  The media reports daily how this move to roll out troops everywhere is being greeted with gratitude and relief by the Italians, but then that's what they get paid for, natch...

 When incinerators are counted as 'renewables', and to simply protest their presence and ubiquity is a crime, where do you all think this is going?

  Will Italy manage to balance out its historical tendency to authoritarianism, with its equally particular welcome and kindness so many travellers have lauded?

  Berlusconi is old and will not caper much longer, but who will follow his depredations, and how far will the people be pushed into fearful submission before something cracks?

  Football, Ferrari, Ferragamo... this allure brings in much tourism income. How many people will want to come visit a country where people are irascibly protesting the latest insult to injury, like a big nuclear plant rollout, to think of the absolute worst case scenario?

Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password

Display:
Troops on the streets is seldom a good sign.
by Colman (colman at eurotrib.com) on Sat Aug 16th, 2008 at 09:52:41 AM EST
Will Italy manage to balance out its historical tendency to authoritarianism, with its equally particular welcome and kindness so many travellers have lauded?

I don't know about Italy, but in the US deep south the genteel white southerners were well known for their hospitality and kindness.


We are for Justice and Mercy, and Truth and Peace, and true Freedom. Edward Burroughs 1659

by edwin on Sat Aug 16th, 2008 at 10:11:35 AM EST
i feel like i'm in a dream, can this be really happening?

or is it the italian version, more smoke than fire?

time'll tell...

when i first got back years ago, i was struck by how highly armed the cops were, machine guns just to pull over traffic, airports bristling with dogs etc.

now i realise most of them are pussycats, under the ruff'n'tuff front.

not all, however, and when they warp out, they go all the way, like brutes do all over the world, purtroppo.

Peace is not the absence of war -- peace is the absence of fear. Ursula Franklin

by melo (melometa4(at)gmail.com) on Sat Aug 16th, 2008 at 01:08:31 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Maybe inside Italy it feels like velvet, but the news outside make it sound like sack cloth.  (;  

my gut says it might be Italy where the combination of global economic downturn and corrupt, incompetent, out-of-touch leadership will kindle the tinder, break the camel's back.

It was very depressing that people would fall for the grand B-fraud again, so I don´t understand what has changed, besides financial stress, since the election to cause the uproar.  

It is encouraging though, if people get politically active --because they cannot ´consume´ as they are used to-- and it would be a great example for Europe, if Italy took to the streets and pressured for major change.  Governments may think twice before legislating any more anti-social and anti-redistribution measures, may start taking people a little more seriously and sidelining the free-market pushers.

In Spain, people have gotten the message about the prices and job losses before they went on vacation, so I hope they are more proactive, or at least in full denial by fall, but for now, they seem to be in the whining stage:  ´Don´t you all leave the department store and get in the car at once!´

Our knowledge has surpassed our wisdom. --Charu Saxena.

by metavision on Sat Aug 16th, 2008 at 04:26:21 PM EST
yup, i bet it doesn't feel velvet to be locked up in a holding cell for the 'crime' of economic migration.

but that was happening under prodi also.

in what ways s it worse now? it's shifted a notch rightward, but the difference is not huge afaik.

what's surreal is that italy is so taken with appearances. the mayor of rome talked about the troops arriving in his city as good images, like a movie!

as in other countries, the attacks are much more vicious when a left(ish) government is in power, as the right have the lobbying money from the industries, and no scruples about dishonesty, for them the end justifies any means at all.

in general, leftier pols try and do the right thing, and are loath to stoop to cutthroat politics, trusting that the message of more compassion and understanding will win votes from rational people.

it all comes down to the media, if you want to fool a lot of people a lot of the time, and B. took very good care to sew that up tight before embarking on his career of tinpot despot...

will he leave his riches to further the careers of Fini, or Allemano, or Marroni?

i doubt it...i don't think he is an ideologue, just greedy and vain.

like Bush, he incarnates the shadow of this country's soul, we want to know what qualities to avoid in a leader, it's all laid out, clear as day... unless your mind has been similarly diseased by too much kool-aide.

and it would be a great example for Europe, if Italy took to the streets and pressured for major change.

well, someone is mighty worried about it, and trying to insure against just that...

what do they know, that we just wonder about?

zapatero looks really good from over here...

Peace is not the absence of war -- peace is the absence of fear. Ursula Franklin

by melo (melometa4(at)gmail.com) on Sat Aug 16th, 2008 at 11:32:04 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Fortunately, Berlusconi's power is bound up in his person, combining what ever it has been that has made him so attractive to Italian voters with his wealth, media monopoly and political savy.  The true danger would be if a suitable heir were to appear, able either to inherit or seize the media empire and to replicate or even improve upon his personal abilities.  An Augustus to B's Julius.  

While unlikely to be able to be able to act in the wider world on anything like the scale of the originals, this could make domestic politics decidedly unpleasant.  Considering B to be the political, intellectual and moral heir of Mussolini, as I do, I found it appropriate that he should have been the earliest and staunchest supporter of GWB's Iraqi adventures--a rather unsettling farce of the '30s tragedy, as Marx would have had it.  

If sanity be culturally normative, then by the norms of this culture I claim insanity.

by ARGeezer (argeezer a in a circle yahoo dot com) on Sun Aug 17th, 2008 at 01:13:51 AM EST
[ Parent ]
spot on, there is no-one to follow him who has the same ability to seduce aged women voters, who see him as a cross between jesus christ and frank sinatra.

without his media/football empire behind them, the right would be more transparently negative.
i'm hoping he's the 'sunset effect' in italian politics, a brief flare-up before the right goes down, hopefully for ever.

Peace is not the absence of war -- peace is the absence of fear. Ursula Franklin

by melo (melometa4(at)gmail.com) on Sun Aug 17th, 2008 at 02:29:48 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Hope springs eternal in the Human breast
Man n'er is, but is always to be blest'   A. Pope

If sanity be culturally normative, then by the norms of this culture I claim insanity.
by ARGeezer (argeezer a in a circle yahoo dot com) on Sun Aug 17th, 2008 at 12:20:02 PM EST
[ Parent ]
It's a dynasty. I expect Piersilvio to follow in his father's tracks, then Luigi, who is still very young. The personal political entity known as Forza Italia or whatever catchy new name they can come up with is a total emanation of the Berlusconi clan. It will have no problem selling Piersilvio when the moment comes, and by then I'm sure he'll win by a landslide.

<Cut this out and paste it on the fridge.>

by de Gondi (publiobestia aaaatttthotmaildaughtusual) on Sun Aug 17th, 2008 at 02:50:49 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Obviously you know Italy, de Gondi, but I don´t want to lose that much hope for that long a period!  Tell us you see better possibilities, please....

Our knowledge has surpassed our wisdom. --Charu Saxena.
by metavision on Sun Aug 17th, 2008 at 03:28:51 PM EST
[ Parent ]
ouch...that's just what i hoped i wouldn't hear!

sons of such a father usually don't have the same passion for power, in my experience, plus by then italy will have had to face and deal with issues that will not be covered up by endless tette e culo (t'n'a) teevee shows and hero-worship of footballers.

my gut tells me that reality will not permit such indulgence much longer, either here or anywhere else.

wishful thinking, perhaps.

wistful thinking, certainly.

Peace is not the absence of war -- peace is the absence of fear. Ursula Franklin

by melo (melometa4(at)gmail.com) on Sun Aug 17th, 2008 at 06:25:29 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Informed public opinion is nearly gone in Italy. Facts no longer exist. The only thing that might turn things around is a major economic collapse- which of course will be blamed on the communist domination of Italy over the past four centuries.

Surprisingly, the Catholic weekly continues to be very harsh with the Berlusconi regime, calling it out as neo-fascist.

Not until Berlusconi's monopoly of the media is broken will Italy break out of its pipe dreams. It will get far worse in autumn when Berlusconi will muzzle the press with his execrable wiretaps bill.

by de Gondi (publiobestia aaaatttthotmaildaughtusual) on Mon Aug 18th, 2008 at 12:49:46 AM EST
[ Parent ]
that famiglia christiana article was a shock, huh?

who'd a thunk it?

Peace is not the absence of war -- peace is the absence of fear. Ursula Franklin

by melo (melometa4(at)gmail.com) on Mon Aug 18th, 2008 at 06:19:10 AM EST
[ Parent ]
The debate on public opinion is old hat but taken up a few days ago by Nanni Moretti in Berlin. He noted that he is a film director and writer, yet people always want his opinion on Italian politics. He went on to say that since people ask him, evidently the people who should be discussing the problem, auch as politicians, aren't doing so.

He remarked that after 15 years of being fed Berlusconi's propaganda, the new generations take the Italian situation for granted, as they have no means of comparison. The new generations are spectators of "politics", not citizens who participate in politics (which in the end is the defining nature of citizenry). Since inconvenient hard facts have been reduced to  opinions or swept under the rug, we cannot say that Italy has an informed public opinion. It's no wonder Italy continues to be classified at the bottom in terms of freedom of the press.

On Sunday, Eugenio Scalfari took up Moretti's argument in his Repubblica editorial- and today the debate continues.

Famiglia Cristiana of course does not express any official position of the Church which quite to the contrary much prefers Berlusconi. It is the most widely distributed weekly in Italy and does reflect the unease of Catholics who are by and large more modern and liberal than the hierarchy.

Obliquely, the Pope did come out against racism and its modern forms yesterday. Naturally, the government wholeheartedly agreed. Some noted that the Pope's words has utterly nothing to do with the government's recent actions. He must have been thinking about Greenland, I suppose.

by de Gondi (publiobestia aaaatttthotmaildaughtusual) on Mon Aug 18th, 2008 at 11:22:59 AM EST
[ Parent ]
i sure hope you have time to keep us posted here, i'm trying not to get too dependent on you for the real skinny on what's going down...

Peace is not the absence of war -- peace is the absence of fear. Ursula Franklin
by melo (melometa4(at)gmail.com) on Mon Aug 18th, 2008 at 07:04:09 AM EST
[ Parent ]
When your best hope for salvation is from the Church, you know you are in deep do do.

If sanity be culturally normative, then by the norms of this culture I claim insanity.
by ARGeezer (argeezer a in a circle yahoo dot com) on Mon Aug 18th, 2008 at 01:01:39 PM EST
[ Parent ]


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]