Impressionism - "a great sign of democratic progress"'

by Ted Welch
Mon Jun 29th, 2009 at 06:53:51 PM EST

I took a break from Paris and had a weekend in the country with LEP and visited the kind of area around Paris frequently painted by the Impressionists. Now their paintings are extremely popular and the idea that they were political radicals seems bizarre. However they struggled against the authoritarian system, most directly the Salon system, which regulated access to the public, but also against the political system France in their early years.

I was lucky enough to be able to stay at LEP's place, near Fontainebleau, which was quite a contrast with the bustle of central Paris:


a-lenshouse-paris-4 171

a-lenswindow-paris-4 173

In his garden one could listen to the bird-song:

a-lensgarden-paris-4 176

On Saturday we went to nearby Moret-sur-Loing:

couple-bridge-moret-paris-4 087

The Impressionist painter Alfred Sisley had spent his last decade there, sadly in poverty:

sisley_moret_loing_1888_l

Sisley_Alfred

Sisley was born in Paris to affluent English parents ... At the age of 18, Sisley was sent to London to study for a career in business, but he abandoned it after four years and returned to Paris. Beginning in 1862 he studied at the atelier of Swiss artist Marc-Charles-Gabriel Gleyre, where he became acquainted with Frédéric Bazille, Claude Monet, and Pierre-Auguste Renoir. ... Sisley and his friends initially had few opportunities to exhibit or sell their work. Unlike some of his fellow students who suffered financial hardships, Sisley received an allowance from his father until 1870 [when his father's business collapsed following the Franco-Prussiian War], after which time he became increasingly poor.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred_Sisley

Now of course his paintings sell for millions and there is a "Point Sisley" in the town celebrating his life and work.

a-point-sisley-4 069 copie

The spry eighty-something man inside pointed to the photograph of him (above) and said that it was the cigarettes which killed him, at only 59.

Sisley by Renoir:

sisley-by-renoir

In his time the streets were traffic-free:

Street-in-Moret(Porte-de-Bourgogne-from-across-the-Bridge)-large

Now people like ourselves fill the streets and the narrow bridge over the Loing with cars, especially at the weekend:

a-cars-moret-4 067

imps-cars

Impressionists and Politics, Philip Nord

But it's still a pretty, idyllic place:

moret-church-river-4 016

fishing-loing-s-paris-4 022

a-moret-chateau-river-paris-4 107

a-moret-boat-paris-4 105

Some people seem to fully abandon themselves to the experience:

 a-moret-guy-swans-paris-4 118_modifié-1

amoret-willow-paris-4 109

kids-moret-dam--paris-4 126

girl-river-4 056

couple-swan-moret-paris-4 090

But, of course, the countryside is not always idyllic; as I started this there was a report on French TV about the high level of suicide amongst those working in agriculture, a symptom of wider hardship.

Progressive art

The political views and activities of the Impressionists are not widely known, despite the many popular books about them; just like the CIA backing for Abstract Expressionism in the Cold War (see Rapallo diary). Books tend to concentrate on the formal aspects of their work and on the personal lives of the artists, reinforcing the romantic image of the artist as individual concerned with the expression of feeling and formal issues. But this is misleading, they were social beings, involved in history and in politics of a progressive and sometimes radical kind. In part it was a generational rebellion, against the academic painting of people like Charles Gleyre, in whose studio some of them studied:

imps gleyre-radicals

Impressionists and Politics, Philip Nord

imps-renoir-pissaro_modifié-1

Ibid.

It's important to understand the aesthetic and related political context. When the future Impressionsts began their careers the respected painters were people like their teacher, Charles Gleyre. He was recognised for his very academic paintings on mythological and religious themes, such as The Dance of the Bacchantes:

Gleyre_Danse_Bacchantes

The Impressionists came to reject this style and at the same time the political context which it reflected:

imps-politics

Ibid.

Gleyre_Apotres

The Separation of the Apostles, Gleyre

The critics who defended them attacked the classical style, calling for paintings of modern French life and emphasised the connections between art and politics:

renoir-le-moulin-de-la-galette

Moulin de la Galette, Renoir

impress-critics

Ibid.

Monet - St. Lazare Station Paris

Gare St. Lazare, Monet

This is not to say that the Impressionists produced overt political propaganda, and they did rely on middle-class as well as some wealthy collectors, but even these often shared their progressive views.

imp-patrons

Ibid.

Later some of the Impressionists, such as Degas and Renoir, became more right-wing, deploring the new urban society, while Monet and Pissarro stayed more radical.

imp-mod life

Pissarro the anarchist

One of the most politically committed was Pissarro, who was scornful of those painters he regarded as supportive of reactionary forces in French society:

pissarro

pissarro-politics

Ibid.

Ironically you now need to be very rich to be able to afford a painting by Pissarro, and exhibitions of his work are accompanied by smart parties for the bourgeoisie:


The National Gallery of Victoria, Australia, is curently showing an exhibition of works by Camille Pissarro, The First Impressionist. And ironically, while contemporary local anarchists will be celebrating ten years of the Black Star on March 4th, Melbourne's yuppies will be celebrating the opening of the exhibition at a "Parisian soiree". Join them, if you wish, "for a beautiful French inspired evening with live entertainment, wine, canapés and a preview of the exhibition." Admission is available to anyone with $55.00 to spare ...

pissarro-woodcutter

Camille Pissarro is revered today as a father of Impressionism. But the radical spirit of one of the world's most revolutionary art movements stayed with him all his life, much to the horror of his dealer.

"He was an active supporter of anarchist politics well into middle age, at a time when anarchists were bombing restaurants, theatres and horse-drawn taxis," says the National Gallery of Victoria's senior curator of international art, Ted Gott.

... Still, the millions (upon millions) of victims of European capitalism and imperialism weren't Presidents or Prime Ministers, Kings or Queens, so who cares? In fact, I expect that contemplating their fate -- and the reasons why Pissarro dedicated much of his life and work to overthrowing the social structures responsible for their deaths -- would only spoil, say, "a beautiful French inspired evening with live entertainment, wine, canapés and a preview of the exhibition". And let's face it, which is more important?
...

Of course, Pissaro's politics is not the only remarkable fact about Pissarro, Impressionism, or, importantly, their legacy to the local Victorian economy:

[The Pissarro exhibition] follows the NGV's 2004 Impressionism exhibition that generated $25.7 million for the Victorian economy and attracted more than 380,000 visitors, including 78,000 from interstate and overseas...

An outcome that would, no doubt, generate joy in Pissarro's heart were he alive today. (Then again, probably only if he could use it to subsidise local anarchist projects.) ...

http://slackbastard.blogspot.com/2006/02/camille-pissarro-anarchist_28.html

800px-Sisley-Small_Meadows_in_Spring

Small Meadows in Spring, Sisley

One year after Sisley died in poverty, one of his paintings sold for 400 times the original price - the serious speculative process had begun and with it went the ideological suppression of the political aspects of the movement - even Degas had been progressive in his early years. Impressionism was no longer "a great sign of democratic progress"; now it adorned the walls of the very wealthy and even Pissarro's work provided a decorative background for yuppie parties.

Login
. Make a new account
. Reset password

Display:
Brilliant from beginning to end!
by afew (afew(a in a circle)eurotrib_dot_com) on Tue Jun 30th, 2009 at 02:18:57 AM EST
I say, steady on old chap :-)  Thanks, and thanks to my main source, Philip Nord, Impressionists and Politics, though I first came across these connections (after years of exposure to the orthodox art histories which generally ignored them) in the '70s in Egbert's monumental study, which was grudgingly reviewed by Haskell, who adopted a more conventional approach to the social history of art:

From Courbet to Che

By Francis Haskell

Social Radicalism and the Arts: Western Europe
by Donald Drew Egbert

Knopf, 928 pp. 1970

Professor Egbert's enormously long book refers to the opinions on art of almost every left-wing writer (in the loosest sense of the term) in Western Europe from Saint-Simon and Fourier to Mr. John Berger. Though in his Preface he is careful to disassociate himself from most of these opinions, he is fair and dispassionate throughout, and his volume can be recommended as an invaluable source of facts for those teachers trying to cope with the 'Che Guevara and Art' kind of lecture now in demand. It also deserves to be looked at (though hardly read through) with some attention by anyone interested in the wider relationships between art and society...

http://www.nybooks.com/articles/article-preview?article_id=10700

And my thanks to LEP for his hospitality.

Maybe it's because I'm a Londoner - that I moved to Nice. Blog - Nice Experience

by Ted Welch (tedwelch-at-mac-dot-com) on Tue Jun 30th, 2009 at 06:33:42 AM EST
[ Parent ]
My previously written comment didn't get posted, perchance from stray fingers on the keyboard.  What i remember...

Second afew's  understated praise.  Sets a new standard for historical village blogging, or bridge between cultures blogging, or how to extract the most salient from where you are at the moment blogging.  Not to mention really good, and for me, interesting.

Skennah Kowa

by Crazy Horse on Tue Jun 30th, 2009 at 05:05:50 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Oh my - even a "not bad" tends to make Brits blush :-) Thanks.

Maybe it's because I'm a Londoner - that I moved to Nice. Blog - Nice Experience
by Ted Welch (tedwelch-at-mac-dot-com) on Thu Jul 2nd, 2009 at 04:03:52 AM EST
[ Parent ]
yes, *** diary, great pix, great history, superb art, and very good links between painting and politics.

gaugain's art described as superstition got me thinking too. paradise as eternally 'other' and 'far away', rather than a responsibility to create here. an institutionalised worship, fetishisation of exoticism, that hints at europeans' lack of enchantment, what kc describes as magic, or sense of the truly beautiful being able to exist, in all the pollution, noise and confusion from modern speeds turning ancient brains.

escapism that has had huge economic effects for good and ill, obviously.

nostalgie de la boue morphing into nostalgie de la plage.

it's symbolic of one of the ways we use to split our integrity, (to then get really into searching for it again in some sunnier clime, or on a psychiatrist's couch?)

the painting style the impressionists displaced looks so contrived, skilful, but emotionally flat, empty virtuousity. the very definition of mannered!

certainly something at the end of its journey through meaning.

sisley's painting is charming, the english influence pastellises and washes some of the emotional intensity seen in van gogh or other continental painters, with their more passionate colours and tones.

there's a fairytale quality, diaphonous, and a little removed, yet the subjects are still fierier than those the english painters had to contemplate, so there's a lovely fusion.

the pix of LEP's house are gorgeous, you can just feel the peace amidst the green, and the quiet hum of nature in the garden.

well done, and merci.

"Two wrongs don't make a right, but three lefts do." Jim Hightower

by melo (melometa4(at)gmail.com) on Wed Jul 1st, 2009 at 12:22:36 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Thanks for the very positive comments.

Sitting with the windows closed (on another hot day, with pollution levels leading to speed restrictions on main roads) to cut the roar of traffic, especially the hordes of bloody motorbikes, and electric drills, etc. I wouldn't mind escaping to a nice calm island myself :-)

"sisley's painting is charming, the english influence pastellises and washes some of the emotional intensity seen in van gogh or other continental painters, with their more passionate colours and tones."

There wasn't much English influence, Sisley was brought up in France, spent a few years in England before abandoning a career in business, to return to France to study in Gleyre's studio with some of the other Impressionists and then worked and socialised with them and his work is quite similar to theirs.

Van Gogh is usually identified as a post-impressionist and early Expressionist - it wasn't just a matter of him being a "continental" painter.  

Maybe it's because I'm a Londoner - that I moved to Nice. Blog - Nice Experience

by Ted Welch (tedwelch-at-mac-dot-com) on Thu Jul 2nd, 2009 at 07:11:09 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Ted Welch:
There wasn't much English influence,

in the blood, innit!

does anything else differentiate his work from his gallic comrades?

that quality is slightly tenderer, shyer, more ethereal. he uses their techniques, but it comes out less 'in your face', imho, still largely suggestive but a little less direct.

(playing art critic on the internet, lol)

the problem i found with island life is the spell only lasted 10 years or so, then you wake up to how much people living at powers' periphery suffer from that fact, the happy ones don't think about it much...

wishing you a peacefully sybaritic, low decibel day

"Two wrongs don't make a right, but three lefts do." Jim Hightower

by melo (melometa4(at)gmail.com) on Thu Jul 2nd, 2009 at 10:07:28 AM EST
[ Parent ]


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]