Welcome to the new version of European Tribune. It's just a new layout, so everything should work as before - please report bugs here.

Ha-Joon Chang - Austerity Never Worked

by Metatone Mon Jun 11th, 2012 at 09:09:15 AM EST

Not news to ET, but it's worth marking it being said:

Austerity has never worked | Ha-joon Chang | Comment is free | The Guardian

It is increasingly accepted that these policies are not working in the current environment. But less widespread is the recognition that there is also plenty of historical evidence showing that they have never worked. The same happened during the 1982 developing world debt crisis, the 1994 Mexican crisis, the 1997 Asian crisis, the Brazilian and the Russian crises in 1998, and the Argentinian crisis of 2002. All the crisis-stricken countries were forced (usually by the IMF) to cut spending and run budget surpluses, only to see their economies sink deeper into recession. Going back a bit further, the Great Depression also showed that cutting budget deficits too far and too quickly in the middle of a recession only makes things worse.

As for the need to cut social spending to revive growth, there is no historical evidence to support it either. From 1945 to 1990, per capita income in Europe grew considerably faster than in the US, despite its countries having welfare states on average a third larger than that of the US. Even after 1990, when European growth slowed down, countries like Sweden and Finland, with much larger welfare spending, grew faster than the US.

As for the belief that making life easier for the rich through tax cuts and deregulation is good for investment and growth, we need to remind ourselves that this was tried in many countries after 1980, with very poor results. Compared to the previous three decades of higher taxes and stronger regulation, investment (as a proportion of GDP) and economic growth fell in those countries. Also, the world economy in the 19th century grew much more slowly than in the high-tax, high-regulation era of 1945-80, despite the fact that taxes were much lower (most countries didn't even have income tax) and regulation thinner on the ground.

The argument on hiring and firing is also not grounded in historical evidence. Unemployment rates in the major capitalist economies were between 0% (some years in Switzerland) and 4% from 1945-80, despite increasing labour market regulation. There were more jobless people during the 19th century, when there was effectively no regulation on hiring and firing.

So, if the whole history of capitalism, and not just the experiences of the last few years, shows that the supposed remedies for today's economic crisis are not going to work, what are our political and economic leaders doing? Perhaps they are insane - if we follow Albert Einstein's definition of insanity as "doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results". But the more likely explanation is that, by pushing these policies against all evidence, our leaders are really telling us that they want to preserve - or even intensify, in areas like welfare policy - the economic system that has served them so well in the past three decades.

For the rest of us, the time has come to choose whether we go along with that agenda or make these leaders change course.

front-paged by afew


Of course, Ha-joon Chang has always been an anomaly in the economics world, being more interested in evidence of what happened than fitting the evidence into a theory.

But it's nice to have the evidence laid out...

Display:
what are our political and economic leaders doing?

-Ideology.

by PerCLupi on Mon Jun 11th, 2012 at 09:45:00 AM EST
It depends entirely on what "never worked" means.
by asdf on Mon Jun 11th, 2012 at 11:09:32 AM EST
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah, someone's catching on.

My allegiance to the human species ends at the California border.
by THE Twank (yatta blah blah @ blah.com) on Mon Jun 11th, 2012 at 02:59:40 PM EST
[ Parent ]
... make these leaders change course.

Good luck with that one; they've got great bodyguards. Anyone have a drone in their garage?

My allegiance to the human species ends at the California border.

by THE Twank (yatta blah blah @ blah.com) on Mon Jun 11th, 2012 at 03:02:20 PM EST
Austerity/"Solving the Credit Freeze" might not be the goal.

This might simply be blackmail.

Extend and Pretend. Earn 5% on money sourced at 0%. Scare the daylights out of North America and Asia. Have them pony up cash.

by Upstate NY on Tue Jun 12th, 2012 at 11:14:13 AM EST


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]

Top Diaries

2034

by Frank Schnittger - Sep 10
5 comments

Labour grows up?

by Frank Schnittger - Aug 27
57 comments

Recent Diaries

Faux Accompli

by Cat - Sep 14
5 comments

2034

by Frank Schnittger - Sep 10
5 comments

The Focus Group

by THE Twank - Aug 31
10 comments

Labour grows up?

by Frank Schnittger - Aug 27
57 comments

Exhibit 1

by Cat - Aug 22
22 comments

EU Position Papers

by Cat - Aug 22
24 comments

PACER

by Cat - Aug 18
5 comments

More Diaries...