Welcome to European Tribune. It's gone a bit quiet around here these days, but it's still going.

Two comments on abortion

by Jerome a Paris Tue Nov 1st, 2005 at 04:40:29 AM EST

Two comments on abortion from a dark thread over at Booman's that deserve more readers:

I would like to ask my brothers, by Ductape Fatwa


if you have never done so, to imagine, as best you can, how it would be to live under constant threat of your body embarking on a process from which there is no escape save gestation and giving birth, or interrupting said process, at the very least, at the cost of considerable physical discomfort, and with the risk of serious illness, injury, or death.
I don't think we are capable of truly comprehending this, but with a little effort, you should be able to get just a hint of the horror.

Women cannot run away from pregnancy. They cannot pretend they do not remember the encounter, they cannot employ magical thinking that it is not really so, not really theirs, changing their phone numbers or leaving town will not work. The pregnancy leaves town with them.

They can, if they have the money, buy their way out of it, but not as easily as men can. The money must be used to purchase a medical procedure, which they and only they can undergo.

If they do not have money, the effect on their lives, and the life of the child, can be devastating.

In the US especially, a man who impregnates a woman is considered to be taking care of his responsibilities if he sends money. It is not required that he go without sleep for the better part of a year, while maintaining whatever work he can get. He does not have to stagger out into the cold dawn to wait for a bus with the baby in his arms, or figure out how to haul baby, large box of diapers, case of formula and diaper bag onto that bus and through the streets.

It is not he who makes the call whether to forfeit the low wage job in order to take the baby to some grim waiting auditorium, to spend the day, baby in arms, in a hard plastic chair, in hopes of receiving some form of medical treatment, which more often than not, will include a prescription for a medicine that cannot be purchased without spending at least part of the rent money.

All that he needs to do is send maybe enough money to buy the diapers every week, and that's it. He is said to be doing the right thing.

Over 90% of people living in poverty in US are mothers and their children in situations where the father has chosen not to make even that financial contribution.

Being a father is not, if the ladies will excuse me, depositing sperm. Sending a check does not make one a parent, and while it may be enough to satisfy one's conscience, and more than society demands, it does not make one a parent. The parent is the lady standing there at the bus stop, in line at the food stamp office, trying to ignore the ache after nine hours in the hard plastic chair, it is she who cleans up the various effluvia of infancy, she who knows how much the rent is and how much she is short, and just how many boxes of diapers the check you sent purchased.

Now the society wishes to increase the burden placed on our sisters and our daughters, by denying them even the most rudimentary control over the most basic and primitive of biological processes of their own bodies. And that is the fundamental principle, their bodies are their own. Not the state's. Not any man's.

Oppression of women, keeping them shackled to the bonds of reproductive biology is the oldest and most effective method of social control known to man. It is also one of the most debilitating and harmful practices that any society can engage in, and while our sisters undeniably suffer most from it, our children also suffer, as do we. It impedes our progress as a species, and limits our own futures, again, not in the immediate and physical intensity as our sisters, but in a way, it may in the long run, damage us more, because it erodes our souls.


Before Roe by bughouse canuck


When I got pregnant at 19, my country had had legal abortion for several years, so I had a safe legal abortion in a hospital, fully paid for by my government health insurance.
When my mother got pregnant at 19, she and my then 21-year-old father "had to" get married. They concocted a face-saving lie that they had actually secretly gotten married down in the States, a year earlier. They kept their secret for 20 years, even from their children.When my mother finally told me about it, she was too ashamed to look me in the eye.

When my mother's mother got pregnant as an unmarried teenager, in a strange city far from home, she gave her baby up for adoption. After she was married, after my mother was born, she had at least three back-alley abortions. My mother came home from school, when she was 13, to find her mother home sick in bed, in pain and bleeding. "You're old enough to know about this, now," her mother told her.

When my grandmother's mother got pregnant, young and unmarried, she and her uncle went down to the States and got married. Later, they had the marriage annulled, and my great-grandmother married again. My grandmother didn't know her stepfather wasn't really her father, until she needed her birth certificate to get married. Was my great-grandmother's uncle the baby's father? Or did he marry his niece to save her from the disgrace of having a baby out of wedlock? We've never been able to find out the true story.

Three generations of women in my family, pregnant, unmarried, no access to safe legal abortion. And a legacy of pain, shame, lies, secrets and silence.

For me: A safe, legal, affordable, unstigmatized abortion, freedom from an unwanted pregnancy, freedom from unwanted early marriage, freedom from the pain and fear of the back alley, and a story I'm not afraid or ashamed to tell.

There can be no going back. Abortion must be legal.  

Display:
In most western countries, even those where abortion is illegal, I suspect the majority of the population would like it to be legal. Here are some polls from the US. Yet these polls never seem to get the press they deserve.

Do not feel safe. The poet remembers.
Czeslaw Milosz
by Chris Kulczycki on Tue Nov 1st, 2005 at 08:20:00 AM EST
It's commonly accepted, however, that a majority of Americans are pro-abortion.

While it's still legal, a majority of Americans will prioritize other issues ahead of this right to privacy, while those who oppose abortion seem to prioritize that opposition above all. Unfortunately, that means anit-abortion forces are more powerful than pro-abortion forces politically, and the corporatists sure know how to drive that wedge between the two camps and split apart potentially like-minded votes on other issues.

by Upstate NY on Tue Nov 1st, 2005 at 11:44:36 AM EST
[ Parent ]


Display:
Go to: [ European Tribune Homepage : Top of page : Top of comments ]