It's a bit even worse if you contrast public debt. (Using data in your link.)

Reagan: +$1.35 billion (first term +$0.6 billion, second -$0.75 billion)
Bush I: +$0.95 billion
Clinton: +$0.4 billion (first term +$0.7 billion, second -$0.3 billion)
Bush II first term: +$0.9 billion

Total: $4.3 billion, 3 Rep Presidents: $3.2 billion/75%

Note: not taking inflation into account, nor 2005.

_{*Lunatic*, n.
One whose delusions are out of fashion.}