The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
In these cases you have several options. You can retreat into mysticism or religion, you can try to leave, you can try to set up a defensive fortress, or you can live for the moment.
I claim, without any proof, that many people fear their lifestyles are about to change. There are the threats from unseen enemies, unstoppable diseases, loss of the economic underpinnings of society, and climate and raw material catastrophes being predicted. The reactions seem to be those I listed.
There is a rise in religiosity, hedonism and self protection. Notice that even among those who feel that something can be done (like the bloggers here), most of the discussion is about defining the problems, and very little about providing solutions of a magnitude large enough to be meaningful.
Perhaps being selfish and irrational is actually rational in such circumstances. Policies not Politics ---- Daily Landscape
When I wrote my version of what you are trying to do: Goals for the 21st Century I tried to include as much discussion on implementation and opposition issues as on the goals themselves.
The issue with the the Gulf Coast is a perfect example. The problem was well known (weak flood controls). The solution was proposed (detailed plans to improve the levees). The funding was not provided. The disaster happened. And now even having seen all that, the remediation plans are still not in place. New flood control plans are non-existent as are rebuilding or resettlement plans.
There is just something lacking in the current world leadership. What is missing is vision, or competence, or the ability to rouse the populace to sacrifice, or perhaps only rich, self-centered people can get into top policy positions in modern society.
So, please continue with your energy policy efforts, but keep in mind that unless you have a plan which will counter the power of the world oil industry/government alliance it has little chance of having a major impact. Policies not Politics ---- Daily Landscape
In these cases you have several options. You can retreat into mysticism or religion, you can try to leave, you can try to set up a defensive fortress, or you can live for the moment. <snip> Notice that even among those who feel that something can be done (like the bloggers here), most of the discussion is about defining the problems, and very little about providing solutions of a magnitude large enough to be meaningful.
<snip>
Notice that even among those who feel that something can be done (like the bloggers here), most of the discussion is about defining the problems, and very little about providing solutions of a magnitude large enough to be meaningful.
Slavery in the US was a major issue during the writing of the constitution. But a broad shared vision was not able to win out. On this issue, the founders "kicked the can down the road",,they couldn't work it out, so they took what good things they could agree on, and ran with that. But the inequities to fellow man were egregious, those with the vision of freedom for all formed many common groups with interests that are purely altruistic (which focuses on interests that are solely others', which one pursues only out of a sense of stewardship, ethics, or morality.
These were massive efforts that we are all aware of. But their are smaller efforts like this that are under the radar of the press and population in general. There are small deadly diseases, where friends and loved ones of those that have the disease desire that money and resources be dedicated to solving it. Often this starts with a few loved ones forming a group to try to develop a program to fix the disease. I've been reading about Lupus a little recently, so I googled it and found The Lupus Foundation of America. Just some of the headlines on the site: 1. Federal Employees Can Donate to LFA through the Combined Federal Campaign - Agency #0533 2. Grants Available from Department of Defense for Lupus Research Letter of Intent Due April 10, 2006 - Final Application Due May 12, 2006 3. Save the Date! 3rd Annual Champion to Champion Awards Gala Ritz-Carlton Hotel, May 10, 2006, Washington DC
(btw, I don't really know this Lupus foundation, so I'm winging it here a little in implying they are reputable--I assume they are, and know of many like them that have wonderful motives and are hoping for results. But I haven't carefully researched this)
The US government, (the UK and perhaps others as well) have put programs into place to support the efforts to find solutions. Clinical trials today can run to $100's of millions, which is an incredible challenge if the disease only effects a small part of the population. The orphan drug act was created to make that process easier for these small incidence diseases.
Enlightened self interest then brings in start-up companies, investors willing to take risks, to try to solve the problem, with the hoped for reward of financial gain, or perhaps for scientific employees, recognition by peers. One company that I have become familiar with, La Jolla Pharaceutical had some technologies that they thought would impact Lupus, and they formed a company, did all the science, went public, ran their clinical trial--got just OK results, but didn't hit their end points on the trial, so the FDA said they thought the drug could make it but the trial had to be redone, and prove it factually. At that point the company had "blown" $250 million. They came close to bankruptcy, but convinced more investors it was worth rolling the dice and betting another $88 million.
But there are many stories in healthcare of people with enlightened self interest banning together to try to accomplish altruistic objectivers--and the supporters are loved ones of patients, the governments, scientists, investors, business people to run the firm, engineers to develop the products and manufacturing processes.
I mean for these examples to support the point of enlightened self interest, and hopefully they do.
There is a rise in religiosity, hedonism and self protection. Notice that even among those who feel that something can be done (like the bloggers here), most of the discussion is about defining the problems, and very little about providing solutions of a magnitude large enough to be meaningful. Perhaps being selfish and irrational is actually rational in such circumstances.
Perhaps being selfish and irrational is actually rational in such circumstances.
If you believe Jesus is going to come down on a cloud and sweep you up into Heaven - that may seem like a justification for strip mining the entire planet, but I think most non-fundies aren't going to think it's particularly rational.
Also, if your present behaviour guarantees a catastrophe when it could mitigate it or even avoid it, that doesn't seem very rational either.
I think all of our environmental problems can potentially be solved. There might be some drastic change, but drastic change isn't a new or unusual thing in history. I think with good leadership the changes could even be smooth and relatively painless.
The political problems are a harder call, because so many leaders seem to have no ability to model the long term, or even to think about it honestly. So I can't see serious progress on the bigger issues unless political systems are overhauled to make sure the right people end up on top - and not the sociopaths, careerists, egotists, bullies and paranoiacs, which seems to have been the way things have happened throughout most of history.
by Frank Schnittger - May 27 3 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 5 22 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 23 1 comment
by Oui - May 13 65 comments
by Carrie - Apr 30 7 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 273 comments
by Oui - May 2712 comments
by Oui - May 24
by Frank Schnittger - May 231 comment
by Oui - May 1365 comments
by Oui - May 910 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 522 comments
by Oui - May 449 comments
by Oui - May 312 comments
by Oui - May 29 comments
by gmoke - May 1
by Oui - Apr 30258 comments
by Carrie - Apr 307 comments
by Oui - Apr 2644 comments
by Oui - Apr 882 comments
by Oui - Mar 19143 comments