The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
From my perspective, on the American side of the pond, I see young Democrats and Kos readers, in general, as anti-union, anti-consumer, and pro-business. That they would identify with the students in France would be a non-starter.
Nonetheless, I applaud your efforts and wish you luck.
I will say however that since there are so many variables at work in each and every country, that it's hard to make comparisons between, say, union culture in one country as compared to another.
Kos readers are not exactly your actual representatives of the American Left. They are very involved in the Democratic Party, to a degree far beyond that of most people on the Left. If the Left in America comprises say, 10% of the population (about the same as the far right), then the vast majority of America is in the middle. Kossacks comprise a small subsection of that middle: they can be described as political junkies, but they can't be made to offer a serious critique of the Democratic party. Mention Mother Jones or Counterpunch or Pacifica Radio or Amy Goodman to them, and they turn away toward Air America. They resent true leftists because of Ralph Nader and the Green Party. Air America is the perfect forum for them because it is a partisan radio station, whereas Pacifica's Democracy Now is more apt to air a report such as the one Jerome is offering here.
As for being anti-union, anti-consumer or pro-business, I don't think that's a fair assessment. There is a lot of writing on corporate greed. Kossacks are very concerned with the pro-business congress.
But you're also talking about a country that works very differently than European countries. We don't have a social welfare system like you all do. We pay higher taxes than Europeans do (I read a recent report which shows this to be true) but we receive so very little for it. We have vastly different economic systems. Our unions were once tied to our industries which have declined rapidly. Our unions today (I'm actually a union member) are mainly populated by public employees, and in a country with so few social resources, such unions seem anachronistic even to me precisely because people who do NOT have access to health care and proper schools are footing the bill for unions through taxes. In short, sometimes the unions are causing inequities in the US precisely because the country is so screwed up to begin with, socially. Strengthening union membership would actually retard what America needs to do. America needs to strengthen its social programs and educational system. Too often, the unions get in the way.
We pay higher taxes than Europeans do (I read a recent report which shows this to be true) but we receive so very little for it.
I got hit last year with the AMT because of a peculiar real estate circumstance. That was 28% in my bracket (without AMT I would have been at 25%). Add in SS and Medicare and that puts me at 40%. Tag on 7% in state tax, and I'm up to 47% (it was worse when I lived in Yonkers, NY, where you have an extra income tax, then that was 49%). My local property taxes are 15% of my salary. Yup. I have a house that is less than the national median for homes (sub 250k) and I pay over 10k in local property tax on it. In addition, my locality charges 1.5k in service a year. In total, I pay 64% in taxes a year. That's more than my friends in Italy pay total.
I realize that the Scandanavians are in the 70% range, but America is not the home of low taxes unless you're rich and live in Mississippi. Then and only then may you get away with cheaper taxes.
As for VAT and Sales Tax, can we really measure those?
My local property taxes are 15% of my salary. Yup.
Now, I would agree with you if that was the states only source of tax revenue, but it's not. State sales tax is among the highest in the country, at about 9.5%,,,,sales tax is also high, in the 8--9% range depending....And the property tax does go up for the change in CPI.
starving the state and local governments.
(
by Frank Schnittger - Dec 18 16 comments
by gmoke - Jan 13 9 comments
by gmoke - Dec 22
by Oui - Feb 6
by Oui - Feb 5
by Oui - Feb 52 comments
by Oui - Feb 4
by Oui - Feb 3
by Oui - Feb 1
by Oui - Jan 31
by Oui - Jan 30
by Oui - Jan 29
by Oui - Jan 28
by Oui - Jan 281 comment
by gmoke - Jan 27
by Oui - Jan 27
by Oui - Jan 26