Welcome to European Tribune. It's gone a bit quiet around here these days, but it's still going.
It must be a common story of the evolution of life on Earth: from time to time a species appears so successful that is able to exploit diverse resourses and expand to diverse environments. It "discovers" vast benefits of unrestricted greed, and it grows and grows... until the environment is not able to sustain it. Sadly, we cannot have much empirical clue how this typically happens and what follows. But we may guess, any of possible scenarios could have played out in various measures, scales and frequences:

Scenario I: The greedy species eat out a critical resource for themselves, the individuals not able to replace it, and must die out. A poll of other species make a feast of the remains.

Scenario II: A critical resource is gone, but a small portion of the greedy species in some locations adopts and survives. They are among the feasters, but their aggregate impact is now modest.

Scenario III: The greedy species start to cannibilize or competatively kill each other, just before critical resources are gone, so that a small portion of them survives without much change in "the way of life" (except that they become increasingly aggressive towards each other).

Scenario IV: For some reason, the greedy habits or genes are supressed by some cooperative mechanisms, at least for a considerably long time. But then a "libertarian political economy" takes over anyway, the species rapidly expand and "prosper" for a few generations, and then they found themselves in one of the above scenarios.

Scenario V: The greedy habits or genes are supressed by some cooperative mechanisms, but when the "culture of greed" makes a progress, cooperation and other restricting mechanisms evolve as well. This scenario might get good traction after a number of "boom and bust" cycles has happened to the same species.

Scenario VI: The greedy species does not have restrictive mechanisms in the genes or in the social structure, but the environment has the functionality of detecting its own stress, and is able (for example) to provoke a sharp "boom and bust" cycle on the greedy species, forcing them either to diminish their impact, or join the controlling environmental system. On the global scale, this is called Gaia.

It is an interesting exercise to ponder relative actuality of these scenarios ;-]

by das monde on Wed Jan 17th, 2007 at 01:20:36 AM EST
[ Parent ]


Top Diaries

Occasional Series