Welcome to European Tribune. It's gone a bit quiet around here these days, but it's still going.
Display:
I posted this (uncorrected) over on Frank Schnittger's current Diary, but it seems relevant here, too....

I am more interested in the values that underpin religion than in religion itself. In particular, in religion as "code for living" and the extent to which the code that was relevant in first century Palestine or seventh century Arabia is still relevant today.

For instance, is it any surprise that most "fundamentalists" of Abrahamic traditions proscribe contraception because at the time the "code" was written life expectancy was so short, and large families a necessary response? Or that covering the body in a savagely hot and sunny climate is a good idea? Or that eating pig meat in a hot climate was not a good idea?

More generally, and more importantly, there is the shared tradition of mandatory sharing of risk and reward eg the proscription of "usury" and the concept of the "Jubilee" freeing borrowers from debt, the prescription of charity such as zakat.

Then there is the concept of "Commons". Were the Prophet alive today, would he not go beyond the "Commons" of Pasture, Fire and Water to include knowledge? The very idea that anyone could lay claim to "ownership" of knowledge had probably never been conceived of in the seventh century (correct me if I am wrong!).

The values underpinning religion as legal code survive in our body of secular law of course, and the secular and the religious mix in different countries in different ways.

I have been extremely interested to see how the risk and revenue sharing traditions of mutuality, equality and cooperation - also land as a "Commons" - live on in the Scandinavian countries, and Scotland in particular. This is, I think, as with seventh century desert Islam, a necessary response to a pretty unforgiving environment.

I think it is easy to lose sight of why religion is the way it is, and why it may become irrelevant if it does not evolve with the circumstances which gave rise to it.

"The future is already here -- it's just not very evenly distributed" William Gibson

by ChrisCook (cojockathotmaildotcom) on Mon Dec 31st, 2007 at 03:40:26 AM EST
I have to protest the idea that religion as an utilitarian code for social and physical life. A lot of it is purely arbitrary.

For example the Trobrian islanders' culinary taboo was that the higher up one was in the social stratification, the less things one was allowed to eat... Is it of practical rather than symbolic use ?

As for sexual life, there is a Pacific society where in order to maintain fertility, young boys are to perform fellatio on teenagers... Abrahamic confessions do not as much forbid contraception (which was mostly unknown at the time of their foundation) as promote the sacred aspect of the male gametes, based on the belief that it constitutes human life (whereas the Trobrians believe the males have no role in reproduction)...

Organised, written religion is needed when a society gets to large to properly enforce behaviour according to shared, non-codified social norm ; as such, it is a primitive form of law. It is clear that the Koran was at heart a codification of the laws Muhammad needed to rule over his people.

But this doesn't prevent much of religious rules from being arbitrary. Agreeing on arbitrary rules is as useful when it comes to social and political norms as for language definition.

Un roi sans divertissement est un homme plein de misères

by linca (antonin POINT lucas AROBASE gmail.com) on Mon Dec 31st, 2007 at 04:25:55 AM EST
[ Parent ]
I doubt that proscriptions of contraception were (or are) for maintaining a population's size as much as for increasing the size relative to ones neighbors.  Population excess is used as a nationalistic military weapon (gaza strip, nazi germany, napolianic france, etc.?) and I suspect it is fundamental to militaristic religions such as the judeo/christian/islamic complex.
by Andhakari on Mon Dec 31st, 2007 at 12:52:19 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:

Occasional Series