Welcome to European Tribune. It's gone a bit quiet around here these days, but it's still going.
Display:
Ironically, anti-extremism laws were passed last year ostensibly to address religious extremism and the growing problem of hate crimes.  Theoretically they could be used to curb anti-Semitism.  Theoretically the very existence of these laws is curbing freedom of speech.  It's honestly unclear if the problems lie in the laws themselves or the slapdash way in which they are enforced and even just the specter of old-school censorship.

Anti-Semitism has a very long history in Russia, and none of the attempts to get a handle on it since the beginning of the twentieth century has been successful. Soviet authorities once tried jailing people for anti-Semitic slurs, but not even that worked. It was not for nothing that many thousand Jews born and raised in the USSR opted to emigrate because of the discrimination they were subjected to, and even their determination to leave resulted in a new spiral of anti-Semitism in the Soviet Union.

Freedom of speech is one of the issues over which Americans and some Europeans differ significantly. While some Americans proclaim "Give me liberty or give me death," some Europeans say you can't kill six million Jews and afterwards go about business as usual. That's the reason given for curbing the freedom of speech of those who propagate their view that a Holocaust never occurred. Out of respect for those innocent men, women and children who lost their lives.

by Anthony Williamson on Tue Jun 17th, 2008 at 06:42:57 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Soviet authorities once tried jailing people for anti-Semitic slurs

Could you say more about this?

My knowledge of the history of the Soviet Union, Jews and anti-semitism is: Under oppression and persecution, many Jewish intellectuals saw the solution only in radical egalitarian revolution, with communism among the choices. Thus many initial Bolsheviks, in particular in the dreaded secret service of changing names, were Jewish. But soon Stalin began to cleanse, and not many remained, but perhaps due to the return of some lower-ranked Tsarist goons, and certainly due to the 'folk antisemitism' the dying Tsarist regime used to whip up (think Elders of Zion, pogroms) and many new goons brought with them, the state security apparatus became decidedly anti-semitic, and being Jewish became a reason for being under suspicion as potential counter-revolutionary. Which only got worse after Israel was born and got Western support. (I told the story before how in the early eighties, the KGB chided their Hungarian counterparts for not watching over 'the Jews'.)

*Lunatic*, n.
One whose delusions are out of fashion.

by DoDo on Tue Jun 17th, 2008 at 09:51:40 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Poland jailed people for antisemitic activity in the Stalinist period. It jailed people for campaigning against anti-semitism (most notably the current deputy foreign minister, former foreign minster, and wartime leader of the largest organized group working to save Jews, Wladyslaw Bartoszewski. Pretty much any non-party activism was cause for a bit of enhanced interrogation.

Ironically, considering the USSR's tendency to block Jews from emigration, the Poles did the reverse, expelling the remaining Jews in 1968 in the midst of a vicious state organized racist campaign.

by MarekNYC on Tue Jun 17th, 2008 at 10:28:09 AM EST
[ Parent ]
I also have to add to my previous a bit of earlier Polish history, another black irony: the Soviet apparatus long began to turn anti-semitic at the time the Nazis as well as the anti-semites among the Poles occupied under the Molotov-Ribbentop-Pact equated communism/KGB with Jews, which some locals used for anti-semitic pogroms when Nazi Germany began its invasion of the Soviet Union through occupied Eastern Poland.

*Lunatic*, n.
One whose delusions are out of fashion.
by DoDo on Tue Jun 17th, 2008 at 12:14:44 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Yup, there were, though the ones perpetrated by Poles were pretty much all in the northern areas - on either side of the current Polish Belarussian border. Right wing Polish historians like to point out that Jews were significantly more likely to support the Soviet occupation than Poles, which is true. They also like to omit the context of rising prewar antisemitism which contributed to it, except when denying its existence, and the fact that Jews were also slightly more likely to be victims of the Soviet occupation authorities. Though as it turned out, getting sent to the Gulag provided a large boost to the chances of a Jew surviving the war - fifty-fifty odds beat the roughly 97-98% death rate of those who remained under German occupation.
by MarekNYC on Tue Jun 17th, 2008 at 12:28:55 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Soviet authorities once tried jailing people for anti-Semitic slurs
Could you say more about this?

Right off the bat, the new Soviet state started combating the anti-Semitism that had led to a series of infamous pogroms in Imperial Russia. In 1918, some 400 Red Army men who were found to have been involved in pogroms were shot by the new masters. New laws that were promulgated called for people involved in any new anti-Semitic incidents to be executed by a firing squad. The law was applicable to all citizens, from the age of 12.

In 1920, the law of 1918 was extended to outlaw use of the offensive Russian word for a Jew, "zhid" (kike), and all its derivatives. A Russian nationalist site says that by the end of the 1920s, in Moscow alone, there was a court case about every ten days against someone who had uttered the word. I see no reason to doubt that research and cite it here. That state of affairs continued into the 1930s.

In the West, few people seem to be aware of how Jews were treated in Imperial Russia right up to the fall of the regime in 1918. There were strict laws defining the rural areas of the empire where Jews were allowed to live. Only highly professional Jews were allowed to live in the capital and big centers of the empire.
The Communists came in promising a Brave New World in which all men were created equal. Little did people in multicultural Russia realize in those days that the strong medicine of the new regime was apt to kill the patient.

by Anthony Williamson on Tue Jun 17th, 2008 at 07:18:27 PM EST
[ Parent ]
In the West, few people seem to be aware of how Jews were treated in Imperial Russia right up to the fall of the regime in 1918

As century old stuff goes, quite a few people are aware of this IME. Then again, between the northeastern US with its very large Jewish population and Poland, perhaps I'm not dealing with a representative sample.

There were strict laws defining the rural areas of the empire where Jews were allowed to live. Only highly professional Jews were allowed to live in the capital and big centers of the empire.

The Pale of Settlement as it was called was basically the areas that had been part of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth before the First Partition in 1772, plus New Russia, i.e. Odessa and its hinterland. In modern terms that's the eastern half of present day Poland, present day Lithuania, present day Belarus, a little bit of Latvia, and the western half of Ukraine - pretty much everything west of the Dnieper. Within that area Jews could live in cities, and there was massive migration from the shtetls to the big cities of the region (Warsaw, Lodz, and Odessa) Before the 1772 there were no Jews in Russia.

There were also other legal restrictions, as tsarist Russia never got around to granting Jews equal rights, something which other European countries did over the course of the nineteenth century. Russia also had massive pogroms over the last few decades of Tsarist rule, often instigated by the government. The Jewish response was mass emigration and political discontent of various ideological brands - Bolshevism, Menshevism, Polish Marxist nationalism, Jewish Marxist nationalism (Bund), Zionism (which was also sometimes Marxist), plus an attempt by many to stay within the traditional religiously governed world and pretent outside society and the modern world didn't exist.

The Communists came in promising a Brave New World in which all men were created equal. Little did people in multicultural Russia realize in those days that the strong medicine of the new regime was apt to kill the patient.

The twenties were the high point of promoting cultural national autonomy. With the advent of full fledged Stalinism there was a bloody crackdown. Things got better in the post-Stalinist era, but never reached the level of the twenties.

by MarekNYC on Wed Jun 18th, 2008 at 12:46:34 AM EST
[ Parent ]
NB The system of de jure discrimination and residential segregation resulted in the almost complete absence of an assimilated group of Russian Jews during Tsarist times. There were some who become fully acculturated, but they did not really have a Russian national identity.

In contrast, assimilation was the norm in Britain, France, Germany, and to a slightly lesser extent in Hungary and Austria. It was far less common in the Polish lands, but even there the educated Jewish bourgeoisie living in the Austrian Partition and the Congress Kingdom (the ethnic core of Russian Poland) tended to adopt a Polish identity, even though the masses did not. Instead you got a growth of either full rejection of the very concept of national identity, or the adoption of a Jewish one.

by MarekNYC on Wed Jun 18th, 2008 at 01:00:01 AM EST
[ Parent ]
The twenties were the high point of promoting cultural national autonomy. With the advent of full fledged Stalinism there was a bloody crackdown. Things got better in the post-Stalinist era, but never reached the level of the twenties.

In 1931, Stalin answered a question that he had received from the United States about anti-Semitism in the Soviet Union. The party newspaper Pravda published his answer in its 329th edition in 1936:

"National and racial chauvinism are a relic of misanthropic morals inherent in the period of cannibalism. Anti-Semitism, as an extreme form of racial chauvinism, is the most dangerous relic of cannibalism.

"Anti-Semitism is useful to exploiters as a lightening rod drawing capitalism away from the blows of the working class. Anti-Semitism is dangerous for the working class, like a false path leading them off the right way and taking them into a jungle. Therefore, Communists, as consequential internationalists, cannot help but be irreconcilable and implacable enemies of anti-Semitism.

"In the USSR, anti-Semitism, as a phenomenon profoundly inimical to the Soviet system, is strictly prosecuted under the law. Active anti-Semites are punished with the death penalty according to the laws of the USSR."

Unfortunately, Stalin did not practice what he preached. Some of his colleagues later claimed that many of the Old Bolsheviks had considered him an anti-Semite right from the early days of their activities.

by Anthony Williamson on Wed Jun 18th, 2008 at 06:45:41 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:

Occasional Series