The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
More importantly, in their political culture, was the question of who to elect phrased as "to whom shall we delegate our sovereign power?" or was is phrased as "who do we think has the true divine mandate?" In the former sense, the source of authority is the people themselves; in the later, the source of authority is God. So an elected monarch would still be very different than an elected president for life.
When I write divine mandate I am thinking of the Asian concept that the ruler rules with the mandate of heaven.
A broader example: In traditional Islam, the caliph was selected by consultation. This was a form of election, it varied between election by consensus, and election by majority. Of course, "the people" meant the Community of Believers (Ummah) which excluded women and non-Muslims. But most importantly for this discussion, they weren't delegating their power to the caliph; all power and legitimacy came from Allah and was delegated by Allah directly to Muhammad. The Ummah was merely using the "wisdom of the crowd" to decide who was Muhammad's true successor. In that sense, the caliph could be said to be a sort of elected monarch.
Do you see the difference?
So aside from snarking Bush as some sort of theocrat, which is absurd, I just don't see the utility of the term elected monarch to describe the US Presidency, or even Hamilton's ideas.
I am the most conservative Unitarian-Universalist you will ever meet.
by Frank Schnittger - May 27 2 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 5 22 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 23 1 comment
by Oui - May 13 64 comments
by Carrie - Apr 30 7 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 272 comments
by Oui - May 2712 comments
by Oui - May 24
by Frank Schnittger - May 231 comment
by Oui - May 1364 comments
by Oui - May 910 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 522 comments
by Oui - May 449 comments
by Oui - May 312 comments
by Oui - May 29 comments
by gmoke - May 1
by Oui - Apr 30254 comments
by Carrie - Apr 307 comments
by Oui - Apr 2830 comments
by Oui - Apr 2644 comments
by Oui - Apr 879 comments
by Oui - Mar 19143 comments