The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
In cities like Chicago and New York with large and organized Russian communities, the renewed patriotism has come in the form of more interest in Russian culture.
A Russian ex-girlfriend of mine, who has been living in Madrid for the past six years (because she "could no longer stand living in Russia"), recently updated her Facebook status to "... is in Moscow and thinks Russians are interesting again."
European Tribune - Comments - Odds & Ends: Manta Ray of Political Analysis Edition
"I'm here for the swimming and the women," says Chris Oganda, a 22-year-old Kenyan who came to the camp with Russian university friends. He made the 16-hour bus trip to Seliger from the town of Cheboksary. His two-week stay costs him nothing: the Kremlin pays all bills.
This was important for me to read. I had assumed that the Nashi were xenophobic and racist. Clearly, I was very much mistaken:
BBC NEWS | Europe | Murder of African alarms Russia
Murder of African alarms Russia This year has seen a sharp rise on attacks on foreigners in Russia A Russian youth movement allied to President Vladimir Putin is to demand action against racist violence after the murder of an African student. A spokesman for Nashi (Our People) said it wanted public condemnation of rising racial intolerance in St Petersburg, Mr Putin's native city.
A spokesman for Nashi (Our People) said it wanted public condemnation of rising racial intolerance in St Petersburg, Mr Putin's native city.
Searchlight Magazine: RUSSIA The ultimate risk of being an anti-racist
The next calculated murder of an anti-racist was on 7 April this year when Lamsar Samba Sell, a Senegalese student, was shot in the neck by a nazi skinhead. Samba was actively involved in an NGO called African Unity and had helped organise intercultural festivals with Nashi. On his way home after attending an intercultural friendship evening at a discotheque, he and other African students were ambushed by a nazi gunman who had hidden in a doorway. When the nazi ran out into the street and screamed slogans, the students panicked and ran. A shot rang out and a man seen firing it escaped after throwing away a gun engraved with a swastika.
This reminds me of the way every Thai household and restaurant seems to have a photogragh of the Thai royal couple:
"People are buying them for their offices, for presents and for themselves," she said. "We had a couple who bought a portrait of Medvedev and Putin together and the wife said, 'It's for our bedroom.' "
And since you had no picture of him in this edition of O&E...
WBUR & NPR's On Point : Russia, Riches, and the Law Aired: Thursday, July 24, 2008 10-11AM ET By host Tom Ashbrook Mikhail Khodorkovsky was the richest man in Russia. Multi-billionaire. Oil-rich oligarch. No saint, but no worse a sinner, maybe, than many other Russian oligarchs. Then he crossed Vladimir Putin. Ended up in a cage, on trial, and then in a prison in Siberia. Gilded life -- gone. Now, an American attorney is fighting to free Khodorkovsky. He says it's Russia on trial here -- and whether or not a now oil-rich Kremlin believes in the rule of law. His story is a legal thriller where losers end up in Siberia, or dead. And the answers ripple well beyond Russia. This hour, On Point: Russia, riches, and the law.
By host Tom Ashbrook
Mikhail Khodorkovsky was the richest man in Russia. Multi-billionaire. Oil-rich oligarch. No saint, but no worse a sinner, maybe, than many other Russian oligarchs. Then he crossed Vladimir Putin. Ended up in a cage, on trial, and then in a prison in Siberia. Gilded life -- gone. Now, an American attorney is fighting to free Khodorkovsky. He says it's Russia on trial here -- and whether or not a now oil-rich Kremlin believes in the rule of law. His story is a legal thriller where losers end up in Siberia, or dead. And the answers ripple well beyond Russia. This hour, On Point: Russia, riches, and the law.
Awesome writing. eXile needs to get a clue and start reading ET. Cynicism is intellectual treason.
Racism hardly arrived in Russia with Nashi. Though I am sure that there are racists in Nashi. From what I can gather, it seems that Nashi's been conflated with and a magnet for other, smaller, more extreme youth movements, including skinheads, etc. And frankly, given their name, I mean, I just can't possibly imagine why anyone would ever accuse Nashi of being exclusionist...
("Nashi"="Ours")
Awesome writing. eXile needs to get a clue and start reading ET.
Haha. Please feel free to drop them a line!! ;) "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
Also, speaking of facebook... I had a nightmare featuring facebook! I dreamt that it just got completely out of control, and everyone's friends automatically were linked to everyone else's friends, ad infinitum, and the government or some mysterious everything-controlling organization had the ability to compile and automatically distribute information about everyone to everyone else, and where ever you went there was information posted on everyone in the room, etc. Like, you'd go to work and there would be a huge screen on the wall listing everyone's birthdays, upcoming events, facebook status. You'd get on a train - same thing. I'd watched the movie, 1984 a few weeks ago, and I think some anxiety from that coupled with my anxiety about facebook created this scary scenario in my dream, which, upon awakening, seems entirely plausible, if not already a reality! I want to go back to having bad dreams about goblins and other things that go away when you wake up. Sheesh! "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
"Cossackia?" Where the hell is "Cossackia!?" And don't give me that cock and bull about "Cossackia cannot be understood with the mind, nor its land measured by the acre. It is a special case. You can only believe in Cossackia."
Americans and Nazis thought that if there was an Cossack SS unit on the Nazi side, there must be an opressed Cossackia. Simular for Idel-Ural, it's coming from Nazi designs.
"I feel like as a patriot I should do my bit in contributing to the improvement of Russia," the U.S.-born son of Soviet immigrants said from his suburban Chicago home.
Might be that American exceptionalism is getting tired. Or most likely is that Moscow is more interesting place than Chicago suburbia.
Slightly related, I saw an article (in Russian) yesterday that 82% of Russian jews in Israel think that Israelis do not see them as Israelis but as Russians; 25% think they were discriminated for being Russian, 51% of their kids in school were discriminated against and 31% of kids were physically assaulted by non-Russian kids.
On emigration topic, remember this from Medvedev G8 interview:
MICHAEL LUDWIG: Mr President, a few days ago we read in a survey that among the young middle class elite that you want to develop up to 60 percent, that is the majority of this elite is contemplating emigrating from Russia. They are the future, the professionals, people who have been fortunate in life, and yet most of them are nonetheless considering emigration. What can you do so as to not to lose this generation? DMITRY MEDVEDEV: To be honest, I do not know what survey you are talking about.
DMITRY MEDVEDEV: To be honest, I do not know what survey you are talking about.
Before G8 the theme of 60% of Russian elite wanting to emigrate appeared in inosmi.ru translations of Polish and UK press.
Levada Center published an explanation that they were conducting a poll among upper middle class (Levada Center estimates 2-3% of population) 6% are thinking about "leaving a country at least for some time" and 15% think "often" about leaving. The way question was worded, it could be understood as a tourist/business trip.
WCIOM had a similar poll among general public, and 35% wanted to travel abroad, 9% to work, 4% - to study. 8% wanted to emigrate. 50% did not want to leave Russia at all.
V-Dawg. Looking particularly Original Gangsta today...
Did you hear his latest doctor joke that cost Mechel 7.5 bln $ in market capitalization (50% on the Russian stock exchange)?
Operative words being "Polish and UK press", probably.
Did you hear his latest doctor joke that cost Mechel 7.5 bln $ in market capitalization...
Hahaha. Oh yes, he gave them quite a little bit of a lashing. People are already comparing Mechel to Yukos... I'm not really interested in these business affairs, but genuinely enjoy Putin's thuggish sense of humour. "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
I hope this comment doesn;t ruin my reputation on this site as as eserious intellectual.
Three more beers and I;ll be speaking the fbrench.
Also, if yo ucan get your nhands on beer from north coast brwery, do so. damn fine stuff.
I'd do a shot of vodka to memorialize of our nBA benchwarmers heading to mother Russia, buit I don't have any.
you are the media you consume.
To be completed by someone cleverer and more twisted than I, then sung to tune of some jazz-age standard such as "Come away with me, Lucile, in my merry Oldmobile."
(runs)
Also. I am NOT a bottom feeder! "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
Being ripped to shreds by wolves over a period of several minutes after the acceptance of the sureness of death, holds far less attraction. ;-) You can't be me, I'm taken
"In the interests of safety they didn't come out to work -- the people are scared by the invasion of bears," the spokesman said. A bear killed two geologists at the worksite on July 18, officials said.
"In the interests of safety they didn't come out to work -- the people are scared by the invasion of bears," the spokesman said.
A bear killed two geologists at the worksite on July 18, officials said.
The one and only Soviet horror-adventure-action film I saw (and it was a good one) was about a hunt for a man-eating bear in Siberia. (Featuring: endless forests, endless tundra, endless swamps.) Where the final twist was that the man-eating bear was so hard to track because it was two man-eating bears. *Lunatic*, n. One whose delusions are out of fashion.
I really hate it when they put them on a leash and make them dance for money. Have they outlawed that yet? "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
people raised on shchi and kotlety.
As part of my college (mis?)education I learned a little ditty: shchi da kasha, pischa nasha "Kotlety" seems like a big step up. Do you know the context of the little ditty I learned?
Wonderful diary, BTW. "It is not necessary to have hope in order to persevere."
I don't know. At least you know what's in the shchi and kasha. FWIW, I love cabbage soup, so I don't judge anyone for their "peasant" food. And I think I'd have to have a bowl of borscht if I could choose my last meal. In fact, I could live off the stuff. I was recently talking to a friend of mine who is in cooking school, who was lamenting the popular attitude towards beets in in this country... But mystery meat cutlets freak me out! "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
That about the concrete buildings proved a mis-communication, of course. But my sister, her boyfriend and their little child, as well as their host, and a couple of visiting relatives all fit into one 60 m² apartment of one concrete apartment block. At that get-together, there was allegedly a toast every two minutes, ending in scenes reminding of 4...
On politics, they say everyone said that the government is hard at work to build the New Russia image, and that as part of it, there is an effort to remove old Soviet and communist symbols where they aren't historically protected. The closure of Lenin's mausoleum is allegedly a decided matter (on which they confirm what I heard elsewhere, that most locals think the display of Lenin's mummy is something silly). They also listened to rants to the tune that Lenin & the communists have ruined Russia (uhm, was what was there before really that good? Not to mention the ruin by the Nazis?)
Moscow is said to be very expensive, but while they confirmed that for real estate (that 60m² concrete block apartment was worth more than a 200m² house in a posh district here), they say everything else was much cheaper than in Budapest, except for a trendy café with bad service. Speaking of public places, they say there was music from megaphones from the shopping streets to through the apartment blocks to the village in which a relative had a dacha. (I knew this madness from Czechoslovakia, where it is going out of fashion since.)
They photographed all kinds of public transport for me, praising the inside of the new Elektrichka; but just to the airport, they thought a taxi is more convenient with a child than the airport train links.
And this will surely make you happy: back to the airport, the taxi driver asked them: "Why do you go back to the EU? The EU is finished. But here we have a boom, there are lots of unexploited opportunities!" *Lunatic*, n. One whose delusions are out of fashion.
I'd taken this to be a pretty widespread phenomenon, as I've experienced is countless times both in Russia and here in Chicago, among Russians, Ukrainians, Georgians, Moldovans... You mean this completely mad tradition doesn't extend to Hungary? I'm surprised. They say it's a result of Communism, where people holed up in their small communal apt kitchens to let loose, discuss life, etc. But there are similar scenes in 19th Cent. literature, so I don't know what is the origin of this type of soiree. Endless toasts, fire-code violations, and something almost but not exactly like a hostage situation (getting up and leaving in the middle of it is simply unheard of!) seem to be the defining characteristics of these events. "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
What comes closest to it starts with "...but don't leave before you tried our homebrewn pálinka...", where you have to know that home-made pálinka is said to be about the fastest way to ruin by alcoholism (worse than vodka). Toasts are involved, but may not be necessary. But this tradition survives most strongly not in Hungary but among the Szeklers (a subgroup of ethnic Hungarians in Transsylvania). Being an abstainer myself, on the rare occasions I meet upon the tradition, I do manage to escape these downward spirals, though :-) *Lunatic*, n. One whose delusions are out of fashion.
It ended very late in a tiny office inside the beautiful Nizhny Novgorod's Kremlin after many more toasts with a group of totally drunk collaborators of Serguei Kirienko (Putin's representative in the Volga Federal District)...
That's my only experience of Russia so far, and it's a very surrealistic and good memory... "Dieu se rit des hommes qui se plaignent des conséquences alors qu'ils en chérissent les causes" Jacques-Bénigne Bossuet
Must be just that people they were talking to were anti-communists. There may be too many streets and monuments dedicated to revolutionaries, but attempting to rewrite history 90 years after the fact or to re-fight a virtual civil war is a bit stupid.
Orthodox church made a few noises recently about communism (I understand that this must be coming from the Foreign Russian Orthodox church which formally reunited with Russian Orthodox) and general tone of the blog/media comments was that church is risking followers if it is to push for anti-communist campaign: for one, the church is overstepping boundaries by talking politics, and secondly, communists left the church and religion alone, and church should do the same for the communists.
Russian MFA Information and Press Department Commentary in Connection with the Signing by the US President of the Proclamation on Captive Nations Week, 2008
Last week US President George Bush signed a regular proclamation on the theme of "captive nations," with which he annually comes up on the basis of a law adopted way back in the Cold War era. Well, it's business as usual, but this time around one "novelty" has appeared: quite unambiguously the equal sign is put between Nazi fascism and Soviet communism, which are now coupled as a "single evil" of the 20th century. By the way, one cannot but see that such assessments simply feed the efforts of those, who for political and selfish ends are striving to falsify the facts and rewrite history. All this takes place against the backdrop of the surprising tolerance being shown in the United States toward those who in a number of European countries are trying to whitewash "their own" Nazi accomplices.
By the way, one cannot but see that such assessments simply feed the efforts of those, who for political and selfish ends are striving to falsify the facts and rewrite history. All this takes place against the backdrop of the surprising tolerance being shown in the United States toward those who in a number of European countries are trying to whitewash "their own" Nazi accomplices.
I remember being taught that both were baaaad growing up, but there seems to be a recent concerted effort to link the two indelibly. Which seems a bit rich to me. And kinda weird since, you know, the Soviet Union is now defunct and it seems the time has passed for propaganda and demonization. Seems like this would be the time to begin to look back and try to understand what happened, why it happened, what can be learned from it. Also, it seems pointedly aimed at Russia, solely Russia (not countries in which some people collaborated with Russia, not places like Ukraine, not Communist countries that, uhm, still exist, etc.) and at all of Russia, as if it were some monolithic entity collectively responsible for everything that happened. Also, and this is probably what gets me the most, Nazism required human rights violations, atrocities. The extermination of ethnic peoples was part and parcel of the ideology. Atrocities were committed in the name of Communism (as we've also seen them committed in the name of Democracy and Christianity and so on) but were not exactly the cornerstone of the ideology. I have to struggle to find anything redeeming whatsoever about Nazism (can't) but it's -to me- possible to understand and even appreciate the noble and humane sentiments inherent in Communism. And even now, I repeatedly hear those who lived under Soviet regime lament the loss of some of aspects of life which seemed more humane than what has replaced it, without nec. calling for a return to those days. This is so completely lost on Americans. They hear "Communism" and think "pogroms, gulags, censorship." Which are in fact things we should condemn. But that's not exactly the whole story... "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
communists left the church and religion alone
Do you mean after 1991, or after Stalin, or throughout? *Lunatic*, n. One whose delusions are out of fashion.
Attitude to the communists did not change much, and when did, became slightly more positive. Consensus is that Russians in XX century suffered more from the Nazis and Anglo-Saxon free marketeers than from the communists.
Say, in Levada poll the question "What October Revolution brought to the people of Russia", "new era in their history" was the opinion of 23% in 1990 and 30% in 2006, "gave impulse of social and economic development" gets 26%/28%, "slowed down their development" is at 18%/16% and "was a catastrophe" for 12%/10%.
Do you mean after 1991, or after Stalin, or throughout?
State stopped attempts to eradicate church in 30ies, more or less official truce started in 41 and after the war church was left alone in "don't ask don't tell" style.
About the latter, OK that way. I add that Khrushchev also conducted an anti-Church campaign, where the irony is that he is buried at Novodevichy Monastery (which my sister also visited). *Lunatic*, n. One whose delusions are out of fashion.
Authorities do not want to deal with demonstrations of the elderly and leftist youth and pick up a fight with communists, the largest opposition party, so I would not expect anything that could be considered as symbolic or be too visible: this kind of political capital can be spent on something more tangible. In particular, this means that Lenin is going to stay in mausoleum.
I've not heard this before. What I have heard is much moaning about Putin's attempt to integrate symbolism, etc, from the "bad old days" into contemporary Russian national identity (lots of brouhaha regarding the national anthem and textbooks, which are "official...") So I wonder, if these anecdotes are correct, if we're seeing the beginnings of Medvedev's great Westernization of Liberalization of Russia, as so many have prayed for. Lol. Sometimes I can't tell if he's meant to be Putin's puppet or the next Peter the Great! I'm deeply suspect of either claim...
About the latter, OK that way. I add that Khrushchev also conducted an anti-Church campaign, where the irony is that he is buried at Novodevichy Monastery (which my sister also visited).
So I had to do a bit of research to know what you were talking about. It seems he did in fact do this toward the end of his regime. But wasn't he primarily known for his "thaw", which relaxed some of the official repression, censorship, etc? I believe (though I cannot remember the title) there was even an openly Christian Soviet film made during the time. It was banned, but shown originally. I might be wrong. Also, I've been reading these "memoirs" of Limonov, and he talks about some friends of his who were religious when he was a kid (under Krushchev.) They didn't seem to be in any official danger for being so, just considered backwards and weird by a lot of people.
BTW, did your sister like Novodevichy? I think it is one of the most serene and beautiful spots in Moscow. A good place to go to clear your mind. If cemeteries don't freak you out. "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
Other than that the shag area has always been a wonderful idea....
A pleasure I therefore claim to show, not how men think in myths, but how myths operate in men's minds without their being aware of the fact. Levi-Strauss, Claude
We'll let it pass this time. I may not be so forgiving in the future. ;) "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
</snark> "Pretending that you already know the answer when you don't is not actually very helpful." ~Migeru.
by Frank Schnittger - May 27 3 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 5 22 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 23 1 comment
by Oui - May 13 65 comments
by Carrie - Apr 30 7 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 273 comments
by Oui - May 2712 comments
by Oui - May 24
by Frank Schnittger - May 231 comment
by Oui - May 1365 comments
by Oui - May 910 comments
by Frank Schnittger - May 522 comments
by Oui - May 449 comments
by Oui - May 312 comments
by Oui - May 29 comments
by gmoke - May 1
by Oui - Apr 30269 comments
by Carrie - Apr 307 comments
by Oui - Apr 2644 comments
by Oui - Apr 886 comments
by Oui - Mar 19143 comments