Welcome to European Tribune. It's gone a bit quiet around here these days, but it's still going.
Well done Frank, and thanks for drawing all those tangents into a circle.

Like a lot of people, I knew traces of the basics, have seen the prisons from the outside and wondered "what would I have done in their situation", while watching politicians infect, then protect and inflame racism with the flawed but powerful logic of class warfare which their adherents rarely see.

Of course, most would agree that these types of incidents are the logical outcome of colonialism as the power source fades, just as similar acts are done when the power source is ascendant. There is always a Cromwell and a Netanyahu clone who will pull the chains for the scrapes and glory they get in return for convincing distant soldiers to kill with hidden ammo and fake reports.

But what you have written points to the energy that would have been needed, even if there were a leader so inspired, to do what Gandhi did in India in similar circumstances to the same failing empire...and again, what would it take to do that in the Levant to some beneficial conclusion?

Never underestimate their intelligence, always underestimate their knowledge.

Frank Delaney ~ Ireland

by siegestate (siegestate or beyondwarispeace.com) on Wed Jun 16th, 2010 at 03:58:27 AM EST
One of the great sadnesses of my life is how the Provisional IRA took over the civil rights movement and the logic of militarism was accepted by many in the nationalist community as the only logic to which the Empire would listen or understand.  

And to a degree they were right.  Britain only changed its tune when it realised it had a conflict they couldn't win by purely military means. And it wasn't for the lack of a Gandhi.  John Hume, Ivan Cooper, the Peace People, and many others championed non-violence and civil disobedience in the face of ridicule and intimidation often from their own side.  

My problem with violence is not just the direct suffering it causes, but that it tends to favour the most ruthless and the most powerful - and the often unseen damage it does to those in whose name it is carried out.  Northern Ireland, and by extension, Ireland and the UK lost nearly 30 years to a pointless ever diminishing cycle of violence, suffering, and ever more violence.  

Socially there is still huge deprivation, demagoguery, bigotry, fear and racism.  People don't change for the better through violence: it brings out and reinforces the worst in them. It becomes a self justifying and self-perpetuating cycle.  

Thankfully some people managed to break it - and here I would have to give credit, too, to Gerry Adams, Martin McGuinnness, Ian Paisley and to a few less prominent leaders on the Loyalist side.  But mostly it was a lot of very hard work by community leaders on both sides on the ground.

Index of Frank's Diaries

by Frank Schnittger (mail Frankschnittger at hot male dotty communists) on Wed Jun 16th, 2010 at 04:57:47 AM EST
[ Parent ]
Thanks for an insightful diary, Frank.

One of the great sadnesses of my life was not being able to visit Donegal in 1979, even though a train went by every day through the town of Balbriggan. Why? The only answer I was given at the time was to blame it on William of Orange, who lived in 1650? Never made sense to me, why all these handsome young Irish lads would want to kill one another. But that's just the way war is. It's never made sense to me. Thankfully, due to the good efforts of many (yourself included), things have finally changed for the better, calmer minds prevail and violence is no longer the order of the day.

by sgr2 on Wed Jun 16th, 2010 at 06:10:48 AM EST
[ Parent ]


Occasional Series