Welcome to European Tribune. It's gone a bit quiet around here these days, but it's still going.
Display:
Did China steal Japan's high-speed train? - Fortune Tech

"Don't worry too much about Chinese companies imitating you, they are creating value for you down the road," said Li Daokui, a leading Chinese economist at the Institute for New Economic Thinking's conference. Such "bandit innovators," he expanded, would eventually grow the market, leading to benefits for everybody.

Kawasaki Heavy Industries (KHI), maker of Japan's legendary Shinkansen bullet trains, bitterly disagrees. After signing technology transfers with CSR Sifang, the builder of China's impressive, new high-speed rail, KHI says it deeply regrets its now-dissolved partnership. It planned to sue its previously junior partner for patent infringement, but it backed down recently.

(...) What could drive the normally unlitigious Japanese into such a frenzy? Not only did China copy their technology, say the Japanese, after patenting remarkably similar high-speed-rail (HSR) tech, CSR now wants to sell it to the rest of the world -- as Chinese made. Both Japanese and European rail firms now find themselves frozen out and competing with their former Chinese collaborators for new contracts, inside and outside China.

With a diminishing domestic market, Japan's train industry is hoping to pick up orders abroad for its HSR. Before China stepped in, undercutting Japanese offers by about half, Japan looked very attractive to foreign buyers with its record for fast, reliable train systems.

This has probably been discussed before, but the INET conference in Hong Kong is recent.

by afew (afew(a in a circle)eurotrib_dot_com) on Sun Apr 21st, 2013 at 04:30:11 AM EST
Yes, the competition against own technology transferred to China theme has been touched upon in a number of diaries and discussions since Globalisation catches up with rail industry?, also technology ownership rows (for example here), but 'the story is developing'.

Li Daokui has a point, in more than one way.

  • China will sell its cheap knock-off products to customers who couldn't afford to buy the more expensive original. That's an expansion of the market. (A recent example: the CNR Datong locos for Belarus which are knock-offs of Alstom's PRIMA electric loco.)
  • The original producers, however, can still aim for customers valuing reliability, quality and efficiency, especially given the fact that what they sold to China is not their latest technology. (This includes KHI, as I argued in China's premier line.)
  • Customers who first bought Chinese products on the cheap may switch to Western producers later. Here an interesting example is Kazakhstan. In 2004 and 2010, CSR Zhuzhou supplied 27 express locomotives which were based on a Siemens type (this cooperation was more benign though: Siemens still got to supply parts rather than see them reverse-engineered). Then Alstom established a joint venture and built a factory in Kazakhstan (opened last December), which is delivering 95 express and 190 freight locomotives. In fact last year Alstom got to maintain and modernise the Chinese locos, too.

Specifically on the high-speed market, it's too early to bury Shinkansen export chances: neither CSR nor CNR sold any of its high-speed trains abroad. (As for Japan, the article quotes Hitachi's recent success in the UK to finally sign the contract for the Intercity Express Programme, although omitting to mention that these are just 200 km/h trains.)

Still, in the case of Shinkansen technology, the original developers' problem is not just the reverse-engineering of technology not covered by the transfer agreement, but the patenting of that technology. Japanese companies and even the government of Japan is bothered by this at least since June 2011.

A report in the China Daily last week suggests Chinese manufacturers are filing patent applications for high-speed rail products in various countries including the United States, Brazil, Russia, and Japan.

JR Central chairman Mr Yoshiomi Yamada has recently called on the Japanese government to take action if there is a violation of Japanese intellectual property rights.



*Lunatic*, n.
One whose delusions are out of fashion.
by DoDo on Sun Apr 21st, 2013 at 02:37:29 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:

Occasional Series