The European Tribune is a forum for thoughtful dialogue of European and international issues. You are invited to post comments and your own articles.
Please REGISTER to post.
This past January, Laura Poitras received a curious e-mail from an anonymous stranger requesting her public encryption key. For almost two years, Poitras had been working on a documentary about surveillance, and she occasionally received queries from strangers. She replied to this one and sent her public key -- allowing him or her to send an encrypted e-mail that only Poitras could open, with her private key -- but she didn't think much would come of it. The stranger responded with instructions for creating an even more secure system to protect their exchanges. Promising sensitive information, the stranger told Poitras to select long pass phrases that could withstand a brute-force attack by networked computers. "Assume that your adversary is capable of a trillion guesses per second," the stranger wrote. Before long, Poitras received an encrypted message that outlined a number of secret surveillance programs run by the government. She had heard of one of them but not the others. After describing each program, the stranger wrote some version of the phrase, "This I can prove." (and how about this...) "They took my bags and checked them," Poitras said. They asked me what I was doing, and I said I was showing a movie in Sarajevo about the Iraq war. And then I sort of befriended the security guy. I asked what was going on. He said: `You're flagged. You have a threat score that is off the Richter scale. You are at 400 out of 400.' I said, `Is this a scoring system that works throughout all of Europe, or is this an American scoring system?' He said. `No, this is your government that has this and has told us to stop you.' " .... After being detained repeatedly, Poitras began taking steps to protect her data, asking a traveling companion to carry her laptop, leaving her notebooks overseas with friends or in safe deposit boxes. She would wipe her computers and cellphones clean so that there would be nothing for the authorities to see. Or she encrypted her data, so that law enforcement could not read any files they might get hold of. These security preparations could take a day or more before her travels. It wasn't just border searches that she had to worry about. Poitras said she felt that if the government was suspicious enough to interrogate her at airports, it was also most likely surveilling her e-mail, phone calls and Web browsing. "I assume that there are National Security Letters on my e-mails," she told me, referring to one of the secretive surveillance tools used by the Department of Justice. A National Security Letter requires its recipients -- in most cases, Internet service providers and phone companies -- to provide customer data without notifying the customers or any other parties. Poitras suspected (but could not confirm, because her phone company and I.S.P. would be prohibited from telling her) that the F.B.I. had issued National Security Letters for her electronic communications.
The stranger responded with instructions for creating an even more secure system to protect their exchanges. Promising sensitive information, the stranger told Poitras to select long pass phrases that could withstand a brute-force attack by networked computers. "Assume that your adversary is capable of a trillion guesses per second," the stranger wrote.
Before long, Poitras received an encrypted message that outlined a number of secret surveillance programs run by the government. She had heard of one of them but not the others. After describing each program, the stranger wrote some version of the phrase, "This I can prove."
(and how about this...)
"They took my bags and checked them," Poitras said. They asked me what I was doing, and I said I was showing a movie in Sarajevo about the Iraq war. And then I sort of befriended the security guy. I asked what was going on. He said: `You're flagged. You have a threat score that is off the Richter scale. You are at 400 out of 400.' I said, `Is this a scoring system that works throughout all of Europe, or is this an American scoring system?' He said. `No, this is your government that has this and has told us to stop you.' " .... After being detained repeatedly, Poitras began taking steps to protect her data, asking a traveling companion to carry her laptop, leaving her notebooks overseas with friends or in safe deposit boxes. She would wipe her computers and cellphones clean so that there would be nothing for the authorities to see. Or she encrypted her data, so that law enforcement could not read any files they might get hold of. These security preparations could take a day or more before her travels.
It wasn't just border searches that she had to worry about. Poitras said she felt that if the government was suspicious enough to interrogate her at airports, it was also most likely surveilling her e-mail, phone calls and Web browsing. "I assume that there are National Security Letters on my e-mails," she told me, referring to one of the secretive surveillance tools used by the Department of Justice. A National Security Letter requires its recipients -- in most cases, Internet service providers and phone companies -- to provide customer data without notifying the customers or any other parties. Poitras suspected (but could not confirm, because her phone company and I.S.P. would be prohibited from telling her) that the F.B.I. had issued National Security Letters for her electronic communications.
this woman is obviously at the very center of such an civilization-changing story. Here filming the Utah NSA center... "Life shrinks or expands in proportion to one's courage." - Anaïs Nin
These precautions might seem paranoid -- Poitras describes them as "pretty extreme" -- but the people she has interviewed for her film were targets of the sort of surveillance and seizure that she fears. William Binney, a former top N.S.A. official who publicly accused the agency of illegal surveillance, was at home one morning in 2007 when F.B.I. agents burst in and aimed their weapons at his wife, his son and himself. Binney was, at the moment the agent entered his bathroom and pointed a gun at his head, naked in the shower. His computers, disks and personal records were confiscated and have not yet been returned. Binney has not been charged with any crime.
the article is spell-binding. read at own risk. (even tho NYT.) "Life shrinks or expands in proportion to one's courage." - Anaïs Nin
...and could influence the upcoming election. "Life shrinks or expands in proportion to one's courage." - Anaïs Nin
I took parts of your comment and the diary by Bjinse to do a follow up @Booman - Follow-up Diary About Lavabit and the Security State.
I made some additions about Laura Poitras as she has made some crucial documentaries as early as 2006 about the US occupation of Iraq. Harassments by federal agents started after her first film "My Country, My Country". Amnesia and Gaza Genocide
by gmoke - May 6
by rifek - May 4 3 comments
by gmoke - Apr 26 1 comment
by gmoke - Apr 20 1 comment
by rifek - Apr 18
by rifek - Apr 17 2 comments
by Oui - May 8
by rifek - May 43 comments
by Oui - May 42 comments
by Oui - May 4
by Oui - May 1
by Oui - Apr 27
by gmoke - Apr 261 comment
by Oui - Apr 25
by Oui - Apr 23
by Oui - Apr 22
by gmoke - Apr 201 comment
by Oui - Apr 204 comments
by gmoke - Apr 18
by Oui - Apr 181 comment
by rifek - Apr 172 comments
by Oui - Apr 12