Register
Reset password
Welcome to European Tribune. It's gone a bit quiet around here these days, but it's still going.
by DoDo
Tue Nov 21st, 2006 at 05:42:52 AM EST
As you may recall, in September the leak of a closed-doors speech by PM Gyurcsány in which he said he lied led to protests and riots by the right-to-far-right. I also reported that protests continued after local elections (both by the far-right and the right), and further mess. Then in the comments of my 1956 series, I reported the 23 October riots, and when protests finally subsided, I looked back with a far-right freakshow in pictures.
I told that the riots were worsened on one side by the involvement of experienced football hooligans, on the other side by police brutality (also applying 'experience' from football riots), and a disgustingly uncritical 'support' for the police afterwards from the 'socialist' and 'liberal' governing parties. In the last day or two, there have been some significant developments on the latter front:
- There's an internal police report out about the first day of the riots,
- there is new evidence in the highly publicised case of police brutality against a politician,
- The rumour about someone having died in police action has been tracked down to its source.
Details below the fold.
- An on-going internal police investigation released its first report:
- the report on the first riot, the storming of the state TV building on the night of 18/19 September.
The names of those responsible are blackened out, but besides and above
material and training insufficiencies, it is clear the commanders were
totally inept. A map of one stage:
- MTV=state TV,
- TÖMEG=crowd (on-lookers, thousands),
- "Támogató mag"=supporting core
(those cheering on, 100-200),
- "Nagyon agresszív támadó csoportok"=very aggressive attacking
groups (rioters, 50-100);
- red is policemen,
- you'll recognise the symbols of water cannons.
You see the symbol of those trapped in the building, and you see that a supporting force tried to get there circling the building -- but only on one side, and their water cannon's water ran out...
The report says
- police leaders failed to make real action plans and acted
ad-hoc, their plans seemed the reproduction of blueprints and contained
false data;
- the TV building was missing on the list of buildings to protect, despite protesters' prior threats;
- information
flow to lower-ranked was insufficient, most glaringly, an operation
commander for the units around the TV building was chosen but none of
the unit leaders learnt of that, and he himself didn't know who
everyone should be under his command and gave up trying;
- most
damagingly, forces were sent uncoordinated, leading to disintegration
of units one by one, and even to silly episodes like a unit holding
back the rioters on the front stairs being water-gunned by a unit
inside the building...
- Evidence on the police beating-up of an opposition MP.
- As
I reported, on 23 October, police pursued rioters 'into' the dispersing
crowd of a rally by right-populist main opposition party Fidesz, and in
the course of this, a Fidesz leader, Márusz Révész was rubber-bulleted
unconscious and/or beaten with batons.


This case developed into an ugly controversy. On one hand, after the
initial barely self-aware hospital interview, Révész switched into
politician mode, and sought to get the most out of his case --
including wearing his bandages when it was no longer necessary, leading
to accusations of faking from the government side. Meanwhile, selective
leaks of police tapes implied that police in fact tried to hold back
the crowd and called Fidesz leaders to get their protesters out of the
way, leading to paranoid government-side claims that Fidesz wanted trouble on their crowd so that police and government can be demonised.
However, now a foreigner sent an amateur video to the attorney of
Révész, which confirms the version witnesses told to Révész (who
himself suffers from amnesia): it reportedly shows Révész approaching
the policemen and protesting while showing his Member of Parliament
card (which ensures immunity by law), but the policemen surround him
and then beat him up, stopping only when a photographer approached. - Was someone killed on 23 October?
- On the last day of riots, rumours spread that a young girl died from the effects of tear gas. Internet news site Index
tried to track down the origin, and found it: a man who claimed his
daughter died in the events, and got a compensation of €1,200 from his
Austro-Hungarian firm. The man wouldn't tell details to the press, and
there is no trace of the dead girl in hospital or cemetery records, so
this is most likely an insurance fraud...
I note I am personally very dismayed at the law-and-order-ist turn of the nominal Left and its supporters -- including close friends and relatives, with whom I had the most bizarre heated debates... But this is what you get in a 'cold civil war'.
Top Diaries
by Cat - Jan 25 53 comments
by Oui - Jan 9 21 comments
by Oui - Jan 15 91 comments
Recent Diaries
by Oui - Jan 27 31 comments
by Cat - Jan 25 53 comments
by Oui - Jan 21 10 comments
by Oui - Jan 18 39 comments
by Oui - Jan 15 91 comments
by Oui - Jan 14 4 comments
by Oui - Jan 12 19 comments
by Oui - Jan 11 20 comments
by Oui - Jan 10 31 comments
by Oui - Jan 9 21 comments
by Oui - Jan 7 17 comments
More Diaries...
|